Cheap Car Insurance in Fort Myers, Florida

To Get Free Fort Myers Car Insurance Quotes, Either:

  • OR

Car Insurance Fort Myers, Florida Agents

Add FREE Listing
  • Avalon Insurance Group Inc


    Connie Galewski
    Avalon insurance group, inc. Is an independent insurance agency, which means we represent many different companies so we can find the one that is right for you. We can shop your insurance for you instead of you having to call around.

    7370 College Pkwy Ste 312 Fort Myers, Fl
    Fort myers, FL 33907
    Visit Agent Website


    I have used this firm for insurance for some time and based on the low price expected to be pushed to a claims office when I had a problem. The owner personally called me back when I called for claims information to discuss otpions and to make sure I was good. I am very impressed.

  • Tim Shaw Insurance


    Tim Shaw
    Buying home or auto insurance should not be so casual, it really is serious stuff. Every time you or anyone backs your car out of your driveway, all of your assets (stocks, bonds, collections, real estate) are riding in that front seat with you. Make one little mistake and you can lose them all. With proper planning and willingness on your part, to look at the small print and knowing the right questions to ask, and not just jump at the cheapest home insurance quote is a good place to start, but the best plan is to find an agent with experience, honesty and integrity. You will get honest advice that will be in your best interest, not the agent’s pocketbook. It does require a little planning but that is where we come in. Ignore this part of the process, well that is very risky and very dangerous to your financial future. In the end, is a little bit of savings really worth the extra risk to you and your family?i have a formula that can help you thru the process of buying insurance;

    What makes your specific agency stand out from your competition?
    Are you searching for an experienced, friendly, knowledgeable insurance agent with integrity, one that will always put your interests first rather than hide the small details just to make the sale? Well you have found him. Tim shaw insurance was founded by in 1974 and i’m still very active in the agency. We are an insurance company that serves communities in fort myers, naples, bonita springs, cape coral, punta gorda, port charlotte, venice, sarasota and tampa. For more than four decades, we have privately advised and served our clients home and auto insurance as well as all other personal insurance needs. Please feel free to check us out by clicking the following link. We are a+ accredited by the better business bureau

    • Depending Individually

    • Preperly Licensed For My Trade

    • R001458

    4091 Colonial Blvd Ste 100
    Fort myers, FL 33966
    (239) 939-1010
    Visit Agent Website

  • Michele Losapio - State Farm Insurance


    Michele Losapio
    State farm agent michele losapio provides free quotes for auto / car insurance, home insurance, life insurance & any financial service / bank product(s) you may need in fort myers fl.- bi lingual office - university of central florida graduate

    What makes your specific agency stand out from your competition?
    The mission of our office is to help our customers manage the risk of everyday life and to be the first and preferred choice for all your fort myers insurance needs. We focus on auto insurance, homeowners insurance, renters insurance and life insurance through out the fort myers area; including lehigh acres and cape coral. Our state farm customers are our #1 priority

    • License

      Nmls Mb

      Nmls Mlo


    • FL-A158733




    7950 Dani Drive #145
    Fort myers, FL 33966-8015
    (239) 332-4999
    Visit Agent Website

  • Aaa Insurance


    2516 Colonial Blvd
    Fort Myers, FL 33907
    (239) 939-6500
    Visit Agent Website


    Great customer service. Never have a problem with requesting any help from any of the staff.

    I went in for Theme Park tickets and the Cashier was extremely helpful! She even gave me additional information for another purchase we will be making soon. I was in/out quickly which was nice since I had both of my young daughters with me. I highly recommend this office!

  • Avalon Insurance Group


    7290 College Pkwy Ste 308
    Fort Myers, FL 33907
    (239) 275-3888
    Visit Agent Website


    I have used this firm for insurance for some time and based on the low price expected to be pushed to a claims office when I had a problem. The owner personally called me back when I called for claims information to discuss otpions and to make sure I was good. I am very impressed.

  • Cathy L Sink


    13650 Fiddlesticks Blvd Ste 203
    Fort Myers, FL 33912
    (239) 561-8600
    Visit Agent Website


    I am rating the Cathy Sink Agency as a one because a zero rating was not possible. I have been a loyal Allstate customer for the last 24 years and never made a claim of any kind. I have insured both my autos and my home through them and everything went smoothly until I filed a claim. We were involved in an accident that was not our fault. The other driver freely admitted fault, the police report reflected it was not our fault and witnesses also stated the other driver was at fault. We immediately contacted our Allstate agent and things went downhill from there. Our agent gave us wrong and misleading information, in fact he lied outright to us. He claimed we would be reimbursed for any out of pocket expenses we had. He also told us the other insurance company had approved all reimbursements and would send us a check within the next seven business days. When the seven days came and went we contacted him and that's when he really got rude and extremely unprofessional. He accused us of writing emails critical of Allstate and that was not helping our claim. Then we started getting emails from Cathy Sink herself. She apparently got our agent's side of the story and told us we would never see any further reimbursement. Not once did we get a phone call from either the agent or Cathy Sink to ask for our side of the story. I can only imagine what would have happened if the accident were our fault. It comes down to a lack of trust and confidence in Allstate, especially the Cathy Sink Agency, and an extreme lack of customer service.

  • Metro Insurance Agency


    3940 Metro Pkwy Ste 105
    Fort Myers, FL 33916
    (239) 466-8600
    Visit Agent Website


    I trust Metro Business Agency with my personal and business taxes. The professionalism that they have and the honesty about my taxes are what makes me keep coming back to them. I love that I never have any surprises with my taxes.- Anddy

  • Susan Fahs


    14421 Metropolis Ave
    Fort Myers, FL 33912
    (239) 939-9972
    Visit Agent Website


  • Titan Auto Insurance


    2215 Winkler Ave Ste J
    Fort Myers, FL 33901
    (239) 936-3517
    Visit Agent Website


    Best insurance agent in town!! The agents are friendly and knowledgeable!! Saved me hundreds of dollars without compromising my coverage or the level of service I receive!! THANKS!!!!

  • Ackerman Insurance Agency
  • Alan Williams & Associates
  • Alberta Lewis
  • Ann Clark
  • Art Roberts Insurance Agency
  • At Your Service Insurance Agency
  • Atkinson & Associates
  • Atlantica South East Insurance Agency
  • Brad Nash
  • Brightway Insurance
  • Brooke Agency - Larry Johnson
  • Brown & Brown
  • Bryson's Insurance
  • Chas W Dodson Insurance Agency
  • Clark & Bell Insurance Agency
  • Clifford Clayton Carter
  • Coastal Wealth
  • Conway Hamilton Insurance
  • Dave Hamrick
  • David Anthony Insurance
  • David Anthony Insurance Agency
  • David Anthony Insurance Agency
  • David Anthony Insurance Agency
  • David Wilcox & Associates
  • Dickerson & Associates
  • Dionne Chichester
  • Discount Auto Insurance
  • Edison Insurance Agency
  • Fedusa-insurance Force
  • Fhc Insurance Agency
  • Five County Insurance Agency
  • Florida Gulf Shore
  • Gary L Green Insurance Agency
  • Great Florida - Apple Insurance
  • Great Florida - Fort Myers Insurance Agency
  • Great Florida - Gryphon Group
  • Great Scot! Insurance
  • Harvey Rooker
  • Herndon Mahoney & Company
  • Holly Mcgreevy
  • Huff Insurance Agency
  • Huff Insurance Agency
  • Huff Insurance Agency
  • Humphrey & Whidden Agency
  • Independent Insurance Solutions
  • Insurance Agency Of Erik Ginkinger
  • Insurance Center
  • Insurance Management Company
  • Insurance Office Of America
  • J/k South Insurance
  • Jill Wedeles
  • Jim Gregg Insurance
  • John Perry Insurance Agency
  • Julie Keating
  • Kar Insurance Agency
  • Karen Wolfe
  • Kathy Orr
  • Kevin G Lewis
  • Larry Snider
  • Lott & Gaylor
  • Lutgert Insurance
  • Maher Insurance
  • Mark A Reynolds Insurance Agency
  • Mary Sornson
  • Mezzatesta Insurance Agency
  • Mike Joyner
  • Mountain Insurance Group
  • Mr Auto Insurance
  • Mr. Auto Insurance
  • On The Spot Insurance
  • Oswald Trippe & Company
  • Owen K Waggoner Insurance Agency
  • Pat Limegrover Insurance Agency
  • Philip Thompson
  • Richard K Wynns Insurance Agency
  • Roger Bouchard Insurance
  • Roger Bouchard Insurance
  • Rosemary Steadman
  • Sawyer Insurance
  • Smith-lesher Insurance
  • Stewart & Sons Insurance
  • Ted A Todd
  • Ted A Todd
  • Ted Todd
  • Teri Riley
  • Terry A Keith Agency
  • The Insurance Center Of Fort Meyers
  • The Insurance Center Of Ft Myers
  • Tracey Coppin
  • Tyler Hill
  • Us Insurance Of Sw Florida
  • Valenti Trobec & Woody
  • Ebony Vicioso
  • Lynn Tomaso
  • Morris Lingo
  • Audrey Veerkamp
  • Jeffery Norrington
  • Julie Strahan
  • Milton Bergh
  • Helen Mendola
  • Ted Marek
  • Deborah Rotz
  • Donna Kaizer
  • Judi Daut
  • Melissa Tiernan
  • Rhonda Beltrami
  • Rose Duryea
  • Gina Kroninger
  • Marlene Batcheller
  • Lois Mcgorry
  • Rickey Martinelli
  • Jeremiah Simuel
  • June Voisard
  • Roy Yzaguirre
  • Kristin Pana
  • Jamie Gonser
  • Leah Zarn
  • Virginia Maryland
  • Kyle Kasai
  • Marian Resetar
  • Shelly Villagomez
  • Cody Birr
  • Lee Bargmann
  • Sonya Olave
  • Doris Occhipinti
  • Trace Daiker
  • Cassie Humburg
  • Geoffrey Wismer
  • Kristy Churn

Did you know ?

Swapping your high heels for a pair of driving shoes can help you qualify for cheap car insurance by avoiding accidents and getting "safer driver" discounts.

Safety Tip

It is easier to get cheap car insurance with a car that has high safety rating than one without one.

Savings Tip

When you are looking for cheap car insurance, ask if the insurance company offers a policy where they forgive the first accident.

Remind Me to Save Again!

Want to remember to get quotes later? Get a reminder!
E-mail address:
How many times?
Remind me in: