Cheap Car Insurance in New Carlisle, Ohio

To Get Free New Carlisle Car Insurance Quotes, Either:

  • OR

Car Insurance New Carlisle, Ohio Agents

Add FREE Listing
  • First Group Insurance Agency


    309 N Main St
    New Carlisle, OH 45344
    (937) 845-0138
    Visit Agent Website


    The staff is wonderful, knowledgeable, and helpful. The prices are competitive and they have several different insurance companies in one place. If you aren't happy with what you have they will gladly try to find you a cheaper price and better coverage. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!

  • J & R Insurance Agency


    100 S Church St
    New Carlisle, OH 45344
    (937) 845-8436
    Visit Agent Website


    NOT Happy with their service!!!!!!!!!!

  • Brian A Grimone
  • Kevin W Whitten
  • Lowell Mcglothin
  • Milliken-williams Insurance Agency
  • The Doug Kilfoyle Insurance Agency
  • Shelly Hoult
  • Tony Muscarella
  • Brittney Barks

Did you know ?

Swapping your high heels for a pair of driving shoes can help you qualify for cheap car insurance by avoiding accidents and getting "safer driver" discounts.

Safety Tip

It is easier to get cheap car insurance with a car that has high safety rating than one without one.

Savings Tip

When you are looking for cheap car insurance, ask if the insurance company offers a policy where they forgive the first accident.

Remind Me to Save Again!

Want to remember to get quotes later? Get a reminder!
E-mail address:
How many times?
Remind me in: