Cheap Car Insurance in Winter Park, Colorado

To Get Free Winter Park Car Insurance Quotes, Either:

  • OR

Car Insurance Winter Park, Colorado Agents

Add FREE Listing
  • Kurt D Neibauer Insurance Agency


    79050 Highway 40
    Winter Park, CO 80482
    (970) 726-9668
    Visit Agent Website


    I am having a horrible experience with this agent and StateFarm.

    They sold me 3 insurance products, homeowners, auto & umbrella and I paid in full for one year. They said everything was good and final so I canceled my previous insurance.

    Then about a month later I received a letter from StateFarm canceling my insurance. My agent said it was an error on their end and it would be resolved. However about 5 weeks later I learn it was not corrected and they are indeed dropping my insurance. This now put me in a terrible position as it destroyed my insurance score. Not because of anything I did but because of an error StateFarm made...that's all it takes for them to ruin someone's ability to get insurance. (Because other carriers ask if you have ever had coverage dropped.)

    I did finally get other insurance and canceled the StateFarm policies (because they forced me to), however now they won't refund my money! I have contacted them many times and I never get a response and they have not refunded any of the policies that were terminated/canceled.

    I didn't believe any company could have customer support this bad, until now. Buyer beware. Do not purchase from this company unless you are willing to have your insurance canceled for no reason of yours, have your insurability gravely damaged for no reason of yours, and then lastly they will not give you a refund after forcing you to cancel the policies. So then you have to seek legal help to get your own money back! It's frustrating beyond belief.

    It does not get any worse than this.

  • Bill Eisenhart Insurance Agency
  • Dailey Insurance Agency
  • Alexandra Kossman
  • Tammy Dolin
  • Bobbie Bale

Nearby Agents

  • The Great Divide Agency
    View Details EDIT
  • Alpine Insurance Management
    View Details EDIT
  • Summit Insurance Professionals
    View Details EDIT
  • Sean M Dee
    View Details EDIT

Did you know ?

Swapping your high heels for a pair of driving shoes can help you qualify for cheap car insurance by avoiding accidents and getting "safer driver" discounts.

Safety Tip

It is easier to get cheap car insurance with a car that has high safety rating than one without one.

Savings Tip

When you are looking for cheap car insurance, ask if the insurance company offers a policy where they forgive the first accident.

Remind Me to Save Again!

Want to remember to get quotes later? Get a reminder!
E-mail address:
How many times?
Remind me in: