By Craig Guillot
Renters in some cities may be paying significantly more for auto insurance than homeowners.
A new analysis by the Consumer Federation of America of auto insurance premiums reveals that major auto insurance companies can charge drivers as much as 47% more for basic liability insurance if they do not own their own home.
The CFA used a profile of a 30-year-old female motorist with good credit, a perfect driving record and a 2005 Honda Civic. They then obtained insurance quotes from seven of the nation’s largest auto insurers in ten cities. On average, the renter was quoted a premium that was 7% higher than that quoted to a homeowner.
“It unfairly discriminates against lower income drivers. It shouldn’t matter if a good driver rents or owns their own home,” says CFA Insurance Director Robert Hunter.
Michael Barry, vice president of media relations at the Insurance Information Institute, says many insurers have simply found through data and analytics that homeowners tend to have fewer losses in the auto insurance market. Homeownership status is used in conjunction with a variety of variables that range from credit score to marital status and education.
Barry says it’s not that renters are penalized, it’s that homeowners are often given discounts. “In some cities, renters may pay more simply because the homeowners are being given a discount because the insurer may have better loss experiences with homeowners,” he says.
The CFA study revealed that premiums can vary widely by city and insurer. One insurer showed no premium differences between renters and homeowners while another quoted renters an average of 19% more. The top two cities where renters paid higher premiums than homeowners were Louisville, Ky., and Tampa, Fla.
“There’s a remarkable difference between companies, and even within a company between cities. It makes you wonder about the soundness of these factors because you’d think the company has the same underwriting criteria in pretty much every state,” he says.
Robert Hoyt, Ph.D., professor of risk management and insurance at the University of Georgia in Athens, Ga., says insurers are highly secretive about how they calculate their premiums. While insurers may have data indicating higher loss rates for renters, he suspects insurers could also see an element of “stability” tied to homeownership. Those homeowners may be more inclined to bundle the auto insurance with their homeowners insurance, they may be less likely to move as often, and they may have higher rates of multi-vehicle policies. Because the cost of acquisition can be high, insurers make their best profits by holding policies for longer periods of time.
“They want people that are going to stick around for a few years. I suspect some find that [homeowners] are more profitable and attract them with lower rates,” says Hoyt.
Homeownership status is just one factor in hundreds of combinations used to determine premiums, says Lars Powell, PhD, Director of the Alabama Center for Insurance Information and Research at the University of Alabama in Tuscaloosa, Ala. Powell says in the highly-competitive auto insurance market, insurers have a vested interest in offering the lowest possible premiums to ensure a profit based on their risk calculations.
Powell says many insurers also have preferred markets and can price policies higher for segments of the market they deem less profitable. It’s why insurers can have drastically different premium quotes for the same driver. Powell says while some companies may prefer to do business with and can offer lower premiums for high-risk drivers, others may tweak their premiums to attract more homeowners than renters.
“It’s not a bad thing or something that warrants public policy solutions. It’s just what insurers do to ensure their rates are accurate and that they can make a profit for [forecasted losses]. I tell consumers to shop around because are always insurers that want your business more than others,” says Powell.
Some insurers don’t view homeownership as a factor in premiums. One major insurance company in the study did not quote any difference in premiums between homeowners and renters in any of the ten cities. Another insurer even quoted a premium that was 11% less for renters in Chicago.
Barry says regulatory environments in different states can also impact how insurance companies determine risk and premiums. In California, for example, insurers are prevented by consumer protection laws from using homeownership status.
Nevertheless, higher premiums for renters can have a “profound impact” on the poor because it forces them to pay a larger portion of their income for insurance, says Hunter. According to data from the Federal Reserve, renters have a median income of $28,000 compared to $63,000 for homeowners. “A big impediment on poorer people being able to buy a car is often the insurance. How can you ask someone, who has good credit and a clean driving record, who is making $12,000 per year to pay, $2,500 when an MBA who owns her own home pays $580,” says Hunter.
The CFA is calling for regulators and policymakers to end the use of homeownership and non-driving factors in setting premiums. Hoyt says shopping around remains the best way for renters to avoid paying more than they should because premiums can vary significantly.
“Pricing models are becoming more granular and there’s increasing competition in most states. Look around online, call an agent. Consumers have plenty of options nowadays.
Cheap Comparison Quotes Free and Customized
Renters Often Pay More for Auto Insurance
- Tracie
- $3600
- Jun 30, 2022
- Laura
- $3600
- Jun 27, 2022
- Carol
- $400
- May 31, 2022
- Christopher
- $360
- Apr 11, 2022
- Asam
- $1200
- Mar 21, 2022
- Courtney
- $1200
- Mar 5, 2022
- James
- $3600
- Sep 22, 2021
- Gladys
- $600
- Jun 26, 2021
- Sameer
- $400
- Jun 17, 2021
- Raquel
- $1800
- Jun 2, 2021
- Sharon
- $2000
- Jun 2, 2021
- Julia
- $243
- May 11, 2021
- Stephanie
- $3240
- May 6, 2021
- Tamika
- $480
- Apr 26, 2021
- Ierome
- $500
- Apr 14, 2021
- Sydnei
- $1068
- Apr 9, 2021
- Eavan
- $1200
- Mar 29, 2021
- George
- $1200
- Mar 27, 2021
- Gregory
- $1200
- Mar 26, 2021
- Steven
- $132
- Feb 27, 2021
- Daniel
- $1400
- Feb 24, 2021
- Sandra
- $1200
- Feb 21, 2021
- Sara
- $1000
- Feb 9, 2021
- Cyeriez
- $3000
- Feb 7, 2021
- Beatrice
- $400
- Jan 20, 2021
- Laura
- $400
- Oct 27, 2020
- Angelita
- $1800
- Oct 18, 2020
- Alen
- $3000
- Oct 16, 2020
- Artie
- $2400
- Oct 2, 2020
- Sana
- $1200
- Sep 29, 2020
- Robert
- $2400
- Sep 21, 2020
- Tiffany
- $780
- Sep 15, 2020
- Alisha
- $480
- Sep 4, 2020
- Joseph
- $540
- Sep 4, 2020
- Anthony
- $600
- Aug 17, 2020
- Shuntalisa
- $1200
- Aug 10, 2020
- Kathy
- $1200
- Aug 4, 2020
- Heather
- $1200
- Aug 4, 2020
- Heather
- $600
- Aug 4, 2020
- Yvette
- $1200
- Aug 3, 2020
- Andrea
- $120
- Jul 23, 2020
- Jose
- $720
- Jul 14, 2020
- Kathryn
- $2400
- Jun 4, 2020
- Kevin
- $1200
- May 12, 2020
- Letha
- $840
- May 7, 2020
- Megan
- $600
- Apr 20, 2020
- Gregory
- $3600
- Apr 18, 2020
- James
- $1440
- Apr 16, 2020
- James
- $960
- Mar 24, 2020
- Mahboob
- $3480
- Mar 20, 2020
Read More...
Read More...
Read More...
We can find you the best quotes for your unique circumstances, but we can’t change your driving record or other aspects that impact your insurance options. Here are a few things that can make a big impact now, and in the future.
-
Bundle your auto insurance with other policies
One of the easiest ways to save is by settling on a single insurer for multiple policies. Most insurance companies will automatically prorate savings and pass them along to you.
-
Consider a family or group insurance plan
Insurance costs are often lower if you share a policy with multiple people. Bundle each family member’s insurance or go in on a policy with a group to find lower rates.
-
Build your credit score
The better your credit, the easier it is to get a cheaper insurance policy. Insurance companies use this metric to determine insurance costs, so you’ll want to work on improving your credit to lower premiums.
-
Take a defensive driving course
If your driving record is a little rough, it can help to take a defensive driving course. Insurance companies often take that into account, and it can often lower your rates.
-
Purchase a vehicle with the latest safety features
Cars with safety and anti-theft features can help out your insurance prices because they’re less likely to be stolen or damaged. Definitely take a look at these.
-
Ask about discounts that might be available
Depending on your personal history and a few other factors, there may be a discount or two you qualify for that could lower your rate even further. Some of the most common discounts include good driver or senior discounts.
The opportunities to save even more by applying a discount to your rate are everywhere. Get more affordable car insurance with these discounts:
- Military and Federal Discounts
- Safe Driver Discount
- Good Student Discount
- Multi-policy Discount
- Safety Feature Discounts
- & More!
Read More...
"After being with my insurance company for just shy of 10 years, and after having shopped at companies that everyone around my hometown swore were the cheapest, I decided to shop here... and ended up saving just under $1,100 off my annual insurance bill, which is a lot more than I ever could have imagined anyone saving, especially me, an avid online shopper and extreme bargain hunter [...]”
- Jared
If you’re ready to see how much you could be saving on insurance premiums, look no further. Get quotes from the top insurance companies in less than five minutes!
- Popular: How Does Car Insurance Work? Here's Everything You need to Know - May 18th, 2021
- Resources: The Ultimate List of Life Hacks for your Car: 70 Great Ways To Enhance Your Ride - November 12th, 2020
- Comparison: Does Auto Insurance Cover Non-Crash Injuries? - September 12th, 2020
- Help: More Car Shoppers Using Text Messages To Negotiate - August 14th, 2020
- Driving Record: Auto Insurance Options for High-Risk Drivers - August 28th, 2019
- Safety: Common Roadside Emergencies to be Prepared For - August 19th, 2019
- News: Report: Why US Pedestrian Deaths Continue to Rise - May 8th, 2019
- Employment: Project Manager - May 31st, 2011
