Cheapest Car Insurance in Ohio

Progressive is cheapest of 4 Ohio insurers we compared: $92/mo full coverage (Sept. 2026 rates). Counties, ZIPs, 25/50/25 law, quote tips.

Progressive has the cheapest car insurance in Ohio among the four insurers we compared, and the gap is wide. Full coverage costs $92 a month there, against $121 at GEICO, $127 at Erie and $206 at Allstate. Progressive also posted the lowest price in all 523 Ohio ZIP codes we priced, at every coverage level. Drop to liability only and Progressive’s price falls to $23 a month, though the limits behind that number (15/30/10) fall far short of the 25/50/25 Ohio requires.

Source: Quadrant Information Services, Ohio rates dated Sept. 30, 2026, run for one sample driver. These are prices for one modeled driver, not quotes. Page updated Nov. 2, 2026. How we priced Ohio car insurance

Cheapest Car Insurance in Ohio: Quick Answer by Coverage Level

What Ohio drivers pay at the lowest-priced of four insurers

Top tier: full coverage with 100/300/100 liability and $500 deductibles

Progressive

$92/mo

$1,098 a year. Next lowest: GEICO, $121.

Middle option: 50/100/50 limits, $500 deductibles

Progressive

$89/mo

$1,069 a year. Next lowest: GEICO, $120.

Liability Only 15/30/10

Progressive

$23/mo

$272 a year. Next lowest: Erie, $30.

Below Ohio’s 25/50/25 legal minimum

How Much Is Car Insurance in Ohio?

Averaged across all four insurers, our sample driver pays $137 a month ($1,638 a year) for full coverage in Ohio, $137 ($1,641) for 50/100/50 and $39 ($467) for the Liability Only 15/30/10 tier. Allstate raises that average. Progressive comes in $45 a month under the full-coverage figure, GEICO $16 under and Erie $10 under, while Allstate sits $69 over.

Check the limits before you chase the lowest liability price

The $23 liability-only price covers 15/30/10 limits. Ohio requires 25/50/25, so a policy at the limits we priced wouldn’t satisfy the law. Ask for quotes at 25/50/25 or higher, and expect them to land above the $23 shown here.

Progressive Wins in Every Ohio ZIP Code We Priced

One company tops every list in Ohio, so the useful questions are how far ahead it is and what the others charge.

523 of 523

ZIP codes where Progressive posted the cheapest price, across all three coverage levels

24.5%

how far Progressive’s yearly full-coverage price sits below GEICO’s

$142 vs. $163

Progressive’s priciest ZIP code against Allstate’s cheapest, full coverage, per month

The lead holds at each level on yearly prices: Progressive is 24.5% below GEICO for full coverage, 25.6% below GEICO for 50/100/50 and 25.1% below Erie for liability only. Allstate’s full-coverage price is more than double Progressive’s. Even GEICO’s cheapest ZIP code, at $96 a month, costs more than Progressive’s statewide average of $92.

A lead this size describes one sample driver, and it doesn’t guarantee Progressive will quote you lowest. Your age, driving record, car and credit all feed each company’s rating rules differently. GEICO and Erie sit just $6 a month apart for full coverage, so both deserve a quote beside Progressive’s.

Ohio Requires 25/50/25, but Our Liability-Only Tier Uses 15/30/10

Ohio’s required liability limits are 25/50/25. They have applied since Dec. 22, 2013, when they replaced limits of $12,500 per person, $25,000 per crash and $7,500 for property damage. The 15/30/10 package behind our liability-only prices was never Ohio’s requirement: it falls below today’s law and sits above the pre-2013 figures.

Liability limits compared: our 15/30/10 package, Ohio’s current law and its pre-2013 law
Type of limit Liability Only 15/30/10 (our data) Ohio law now (25/50/25) Ohio law before Dec. 22, 2013
Bodily injury, one person $15,000 $25,000 $12,500
Bodily injury per crash, 2+ people $30,000 $50,000 $25,000
Damage to other people’s property $10,000 $25,000 $7,500
In force Not an Ohio rule Since Dec. 22, 2013 Until Dec. 21, 2013

The 15/30/10 prices stay on the page because they still show who charges least for bare-bones liability and how the coverage levels stack up. Wherever they appear we call the tier “Liability Only 15/30/10” and don’t describe it as Ohio’s requirement.

Sources: Ohio Revised Code 4509.51; Ohio Bureau of Motor Vehicles, Mandatory Insurance.

How the Four Insurers Rank at Each Coverage Level

Progressive finishes first at every level and Allstate last. The middle swaps: Erie beats GEICO for liability only, by $10 a month, while GEICO beats Erie for 50/100/50 ($9 less) and for full coverage ($6 less).

Entry level, under Ohio law

Liability Only 15/30/10

  1. Progressive: $23/mo ($272/yr)
  2. Erie: $30/mo ($363/yr)
  3. GEICO: $40/mo ($476/yr)
  4. Allstate: $63/mo ($756/yr)

Ohio average: $39/mo. Pays for harm you cause to others, at limits under Ohio’s requirement.

Middle step

50/100/50 + $500 deductibles

  1. Progressive: $89/mo ($1,069/yr)
  2. GEICO: $120/mo ($1,436/yr)
  3. Erie: $129/mo ($1,551/yr)
  4. Allstate: $209/mo ($2,510/yr)

Ohio average: $137/mo. Higher liability limits, plus deductibles on your own car.

Top step

100/300/100 + $500 deductibles

  1. Progressive: $92/mo ($1,098/yr)
  2. GEICO: $121/mo ($1,454/yr)
  3. Erie: $127/mo ($1,521/yr)
  4. Allstate: $206/mo ($2,476/yr)

Ohio average: $137/mo. Includes 100/300 cover for uninsured and underinsured drivers.

Get Ohio Quotes at 25/50/25 or Higher

Please provide a valid zip code.

Ohio Car Insurance Rates by Company

All four insurers priced our sample driver in every Ohio ZIP code. Each bar below is one company’s average monthly full-coverage price for an identical driver, car and policy, so the shortest bar is the cheapest.

Progressive$92 lowest
GEICO$121
Erie$127
Allstate$206

Here, full coverage is 100/300/100 liability plus $500 deductibles. Ohio average across the four: $137 a month.

What each of the four insurers charges in Ohio per month
Insurer Full coverage 50/100/50 Liability Only 15/30/10
Progressive $92 $89 $23
GEICO $121 $120 $40
Erie $127 $129 $30
Allstate $206 $209 $63
Ohio average $137 $137 $39

Yearly totals, full coverage / 50/100/50 / Liability Only 15/30/10: Progressive $1,098 / $1,069 / $272; GEICO $1,454 / $1,436 / $476; Erie $1,521 / $1,551 / $363; Allstate $2,476 / $2,510 / $756; Ohio average $1,638 / $1,641 / $467.

Allstate’s full-coverage price runs $114 a month above Progressive’s, or $1,378 a year, for the identical driver and car. That pulls the Ohio average up: Progressive, GEICO and Erie all price below the $137 average.

How much each insurer’s price moves from ZIP code to ZIP code

Every insurer’s price shifts with location. This table shows the lowest and highest full-coverage monthly price each one had in any Ohio ZIP code.

Where each insurer’s monthly full-coverage price bottoms out and peaks among the 523 Ohio ZIP codes
Insurer Lowest ZIP code Highest ZIP code Average
Progressive $70 ($835) $142 ($1,704) $92 ($1,098)
GEICO $96 ($1,146) $165 ($1,982) $121 ($1,454)
Erie $104 ($1,245) $156 ($1,876) $127 ($1,521)
Allstate $163 ($1,960) $264 ($3,162) $206 ($2,476)

The ranges overlap for GEICO and Erie, which is another reason to quote both. Progressive’s highest price ($142) still falls below Allstate’s lowest ($163) and below the top prices at Erie ($156) and GEICO ($165).

Why only four insurers? Our Ohio data holds prices from Progressive, GEICO, Erie and Allstate. Each one has a price in all 523 ZIP codes, and nothing was dropped from the averages. Ohio has other car insurers that this data doesn’t include, so extra quotes are worth collecting. Only four companies sit behind each average, which means one insurer’s price change can shift the Ohio figure.

Which Ohio Coverage Level Fits: Liability, 50/100/50 or Full?

Stepping up from liability only (15/30/10 limits) to full coverage adds $98 a month across Ohio, $137 against $39, or $1,171 a year. At Progressive the step is $69 a month ($92 against $23). Since the liability-only figures use limits under the law, a legal 25/50/25 policy would cost more than they show, and the real jump to full coverage would be smaller.

Liability only may be enough when

  • The car is paid off and no lender or lease requires anything more.
  • You could replace the car, or pay for a major repair, from savings.
  • You buy 25/50/25 or higher, because lower limits fall short of Ohio law.

Full coverage is worth a look when

  • A crash that was your fault would leave you without a car. Liability pays for other people’s vehicles; collision coverage repairs yours.
  • A loan or lease contract calls for collision and comprehensive.
  • You want cover for hits from drivers with little or no insurance. Our full-coverage package includes that at 100/300, though Ohio doesn’t require it.

The middle step barely registers in Ohio. Both packages averaged $137 a month, and full coverage came out $3 a year lower ($1,638 against $1,641). By company, the upgrade adds $3 a month at Progressive ($29 a year) and $1 at GEICO ($18 a year). At Erie and Allstate the full package was cheaper than 50/100/50, by $2 and $3 a month. When you price 50/100/50, request a full-coverage figure from the same insurer at the same time.

Where in Ohio Car Insurance Costs the Least

Our data covers 86 Ohio counties and 523 ZIP codes. A county gets ranked only if three or more of its ZIP codes are in the data, and 55 of the 86 clear that bar. Of those, 26 (marked †) have only three or four ZIP codes, a thin sample, so read their numbers loosely. The remaining 31 counties (17 with a single ZIP code, 14 with two) are absent from the county lists, though their ZIP codes still show up in the ZIP tables when they price low.

Ohio counties with the lowest full-coverage prices

Ohio’s ten cheapest counties for full coverage, out of the 55 counties we can rank
County ZIP codes Monthly Yearly
Putnam County† 3 $115 $1,378
Sandusky County† 3 $115 $1,379
Auglaize County† 3 $116 $1,388
Allen County 7 $118 $1,410
Erie County† 3 $118 $1,417
Miami County 5 $119 $1,431
Darke County† 3 $120 $1,434
Lorain County 14 $121 $1,454
Medina County 6 $122 $1,459
Wood County 5 $123 $1,472
Ohio, all ZIP codes 523 $137 $1,638

Ohio counties with the lowest liability-only prices

Ohio’s ten cheapest counties for Liability Only 15/30/10, out of the 55 counties we can rank
County ZIP codes Monthly Yearly
Athens County† 3 $32 $378
Auglaize County† 3 $32 $381
Putnam County† 3 $32 $385
Tuscarawas County 7 $32 $387
Jackson County† 3 $32 $388
Adams County† 3 $32 $389
Highland County† 3 $32 $389
Darke County† 3 $33 $392
Crawford County† 3 $33 $395
Perry County† 3 $33 $396
Ohio, all ZIP codes 523 $39 $467

Putnam County has the lowest full-coverage average at $115 a month, with Sandusky County a dollar a year behind ($1,379 against $1,378). Both are small samples. The lowest county with five or more ZIP codes is Allen County, home to Lima, at $118. For liability only, Athens, Auglaize and Putnam counties each average $32 a month, and Tuscarawas County (7 ZIP codes) matches that figure on a bigger base.

Prices in Ohio’s biggest counties

Prices in the eight Ohio counties with the most ZIP codes in our data, ordered from cheapest to priciest for full coverage
County ZIP codes Full coverage per month Liability Only 15/30/10 per month
Lorain County 14 $121 ($1,454) $38 ($461)
Stark County 21 $130 ($1,558) $38 ($458)
Montgomery County 27 $134 ($1,606) $40 ($476)
Summit County 26 $139 ($1,666) $41 ($493)
Lucas County 19 $142 ($1,709) $43 ($515)
Cuyahoga County 49 $147 ($1,769) $44 ($522)
Hamilton County 42 $153 ($1,832) $46 ($548)
Franklin County 38 $157 ($1,881) $46 ($552)

Franklin County, which holds Columbus, has the highest county average on both lists: $157 a month for full coverage and $46 for liability only, with Hamilton County right behind it at $153 and $46. Franklin’s full-coverage average is $42 a month ($503 a year, 37%) above Putnam’s. Cuyahoga County, which includes Cleveland, averages $147.

Cheapest Ohio ZIP codes

Cheapest ZIP, full coverage

$111/mo

45840, Findlay

Priciest ZIP, full coverage

$179/mo

44104, Cleveland

Gap between them

$68/mo

$814 a year

The ten cheapest of our 523 Ohio ZIP codes for full coverage
ZIP code and city Monthly Yearly
45840, Findlay $111 $1,332
43420, Fremont $111 $1,333
45891, Van Wert $112 $1,345
45828, Coldwater $112 $1,346
45817, Bluffton $112 $1,347
43449, Oak Harbor $113 $1,352
45885, Saint Marys $113 $1,353
43410, Clyde $113 $1,354
45875, Ottawa $113 $1,355
43452, Port Clinton $114 $1,362
Priciest: 44104, Cleveland $179 $2,146
The ten cheapest of our 523 Ohio ZIP codes for Liability Only 15/30/10
ZIP code and city Monthly Yearly
43724, Caldwell $31 $371
43351, Upper Sandusky $31 $372
43543, Montpelier $31 $374
45710, Albany $31 $374
43756, McConnelsville $31 $375
43316, Carey $31 $376
45885, Saint Marys $31 $376
43713, Barnesville $31 $377
45879, Paulding $31 $377
43832, Newcomerstown $32 $378
Priciest: 43224, Columbus $49 $591

The cheapest places differ by coverage level. The ten lowest full-coverage ZIP codes cluster in northwest Ohio and along western Lake Erie, from Findlay and Fremont to Oak Harbor and Port Clinton. The lowest liability-only prices turn up elsewhere: Caldwell, McConnelsville, Albany, Barnesville and Newcomerstown, in Noble, Morgan, Athens, Belmont and Tuscarawas counties in eastern and southeastern Ohio. Only one ZIP code, 45885 in Saint Marys, makes both top-ten lists.

At the other end, the three priciest full-coverage ZIP codes are 44104 and 44103 in Cleveland and 43211 in Columbus, and the three priciest for liability only are all in Columbus (43224, 43211 and 43232). The spread across Ohio is $68 a month for full coverage, from 45840 in Findlay to 44104 in Cleveland, and $18 for liability only, from 43724 in Caldwell to 43224 in Columbus.

Check Ohio Car Insurance Prices for Your ZIP Code

Please provide a valid zip code.

What Ohio Law Requires of Drivers

Ohio ties driving to proof of financial responsibility, which for most drivers means a car insurance policy. These are the rules that shape what you buy and what happens if coverage lapses.

  • Required liability limits: $25,000 for one person hurt or killed, $50,000 when two or more are, and $25,000 for other people’s property, per Ohio Revised Code 4509.51. The BMV lists the same figures.
  • Continuous coverage: the law says to keep proof of financial responsibility in place throughout the registration period, not just on the day you register (ORC 4509.101).
  • Digital proof: you can show proof on a phone or other wireless device instead of paper.
  • Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage: optional. A policy may include it but doesn’t have to (ORC 3937.18), so check whether yours does.
  • Shared fault: Ohio lets you recover damages as long as your share of the fault isn’t greater than the combined fault of everyone else, and it reduces your award by your percentage (ORC 2315.33).

What happens if you can’t show proof of insurance in Ohio

If you can’t show proof at a traffic stop or after a crash, the BMV places a non-compliance suspension on your license. The suspension grows with each offense inside a one-year window.

Ohio BMV non-compliance suspensions for lacking proof of insurance (offenses counted within one year)
Offense Suspension Reinstatement fee
First Lasts until you meet the BMV’s requirements, including an SR-22 certificate or bond held for one year $40
Second One year $300
Third Two years $600
Since April 9, 2025 SR-22 requirement is one year at every level; repeat offenses are counted over one year; plates and registration are no longer impounded Fees unchanged

Ohio also impounds the license itself during a suspension. The April 2025 change shortened what used to be a three-year or five-year SR-22 requirement to one year, so a lapse costs less in paperwork than it once did, yet the fees and the lost driving time still add up.

Ohio rating rules worth knowing before you buy

  • Who sets prices: the Ohio Department of Insurance reviews insurers’ rates but doesn’t set them, and state law says rates can’t be excessive, inadequate or unfairly discriminatory (ORC 3937.02).
  • What insurers look at: the department lists where you live, your age, sex and marital status, your driving record, how you use the car and the car itself, and says some insurers use credit scoring.
  • Credit: insurers may use credit-based insurance scores, but a state rule says credit can’t be the only basis for a rating or underwriting decision (Ohio Administrative Code 3901-1-55).
  • No current policy: an insurer may not count it against you that you have no auto policy when you apply (ORC 3937.021). It can still consider a past involuntary termination.

Sources: Ohio Revised Code 4509.51, 4509.101, 3937.18, 2315.33, 3937.02 and 3937.021; Ohio Administrative Code 3901-1-55; Ohio BMV, insurance non-compliance suspensions and fee schedule; Ohio Department of Insurance, automobile insurance guide.

8 Ways to Find Cheap Auto Insurance in Ohio

  1. Get at least three quotes. Our sample driver’s full coverage runs $92 a month at Progressive and $206 at Allstate. Choosing the wrong company can add more than $1,300 a year.
  2. Put Progressive on the list, then check two more. It was lowest in every ZIP code for our driver, but your profile may reorder things. GEICO and Erie sit $6 a month apart for full coverage.
  3. Quote 25/50/25 or higher. A 15/30/10 quote looks cheaper but isn’t a legal Ohio policy, so it makes an unfair yardstick.
  4. Get a full-coverage quote beside any 50/100/50 quote. In our data the two cost nearly the same, within $3 a month at every insurer, and full coverage priced lower at Erie and Allstate.
  5. Test a second deductible. Our prices assume $500 deductibles on comprehensive and collision. Ask each insurer what a higher deductible would save, then check you could pay it.
  6. Give every insurer the same ZIP code. Location moves prices more in Ohio than you might expect: our cheapest and priciest ZIP codes sit $68 a month apart for full coverage.
  7. Don’t let coverage lapse. A missing policy can bring a license suspension, an SR-22 for a year and reinstatement fees of $40 to $600.
  8. Ask how credit is used. Ohio lets insurers use credit-based scores but not as the sole reason for a rating decision, so ask what else goes into your price.

If a regular insurer turns you down, ask a licensed agent or the Ohio Department of Insurance what options exist before you go without coverage.

Car Insurance Quotes in Ohio: How to Compare Them Fairly

What you see here is one driver in one car. Real Ohio auto insurance quotes reflect your vehicle, your record, everyone on the policy and where the car is parked overnight. To keep the quotes comparable:

  • Give each company the same liability limits, 25/50/25 or higher.
  • Keep comprehensive and collision deductibles identical from quote to quote.
  • Settle on uninsured and underinsured motorist protection before you start, then ask every insurer for the same choice.
  • List the same drivers and vehicles every time.
  • Compare the monthly figure and the total for the policy term, since payment plans can change what you actually pay.

Line Up Ohio Quotes on the Same Limits

Please provide a valid zip code.

Car Insurance Prices in Ohio’s Largest Cities

Cities here follow the mailing city the Postal Service assigns to each ZIP code, so Columbus covers only ZIP codes mailed as Columbus, and suburbs such as Dublin count separately. Prices are averages of the four insurers.

Monthly averages for nine Ohio cities, ordered by full-coverage price, with yearly totals in parentheses
City ZIP codes Full coverage Liability Only 15/30/10
Lima 5 $119 ($1,429) $35
Canton 10 $134 ($1,605) $40
Dayton 25 $134 ($1,612) $40
Youngstown 8 $140 ($1,675) $43
Akron 15 $147 ($1,766) $43
Toledo 13 $150 ($1,805) $45
Cincinnati 42 $152 ($1,827) $46
Cleveland 27 $158 ($1,894) $45
Columbus 28 $161 ($1,928) $47

Columbus is the most expensive of the nine at $161 a month for full coverage, followed by Cleveland ($158) and Cincinnati ($152). Lima is the cheapest at $119, a gap of $42 a month ($499 a year). Progressive is the lowest-priced insurer in every Ohio ZIP code, so it leads in each of these cities too; its own full-coverage average runs from $84 in Lima to $108 in Columbus. Ohio’s smaller markets, such as Findlay ($111, one ZIP code), run cheaper still.

How We Priced Ohio Car Insurance

Quadrant Information Services runs each insurer’s rating rules for a defined driver and records what that company would charge. CheapCarInsurance.net then compares and averages the Ohio results, which here carry a Sept. 30, 2026 date.

  • The driver: an unmarried 40-year-old with good credit, 24 years of licensed driving and a spotless record. His car is a 2024 Toyota Camry LE, owned outright and used only for personal driving.
  • The coverage: three tiers. Liability Only 15/30/10 leaves out comprehensive and collision. The 50/100/50 package adds $500 deductibles on both. Full coverage bundles 100/300/100 liability, 100/300 cover for crashes with uninsured or underinsured drivers, and $500 comprehensive and collision deductibles. The 25/50/25 that Ohio requires is a step above that 15/30/10 tier.
  • The sample: 523 Ohio ZIP codes across 86 counties. All four insurers priced every ZIP code, which gives 2,092 prices per coverage level.
  • The math: inside each ZIP code an insurer is counted a single time, at its cheapest price for our driver. An insurer’s Ohio average is the mean of those ZIP code prices, and a state, county, city or ZIP code average is the mean of every insurer price in the area. Monthly numbers are yearly totals divided by 12, rounded to whole dollars.
  • How we pick the cheapest: a company has to accept every driver and be priced in at least half of Ohio’s ZIP codes to be considered. Any that came within 3% of the lowest yearly price would share the title. Here the runner-up is at least 24.5% higher at every level, so Progressive stands alone.
  • What we left out: nothing from the Ohio data; no insurer, ZIP code or price was removed. Where an insurer returned several prices for one ZIP code, we kept the lowest. Only the county rankings skip anything: the 31 counties with one or two ZIP codes.

All of this describes one driver profile. None of it is a quote, offer or guarantee. Your own price will depend on where you live, what you drive, your record, the coverage you choose and the discounts you earn.

Ohio Car Insurance Questions, Answered

Who has the cheapest car insurance in Ohio right now?

Progressive, among the four insurers in our Ohio data, on rates from Sept. 30, 2026. It prices lowest in all three tiers: $92 a month for full coverage, $89 for 50/100/50 and $23 for Liability Only 15/30/10. GEICO follows at $121 and $120 for the first two, and Erie at $30 for liability only. The $23 tier sits below Ohio’s legal limits.

Is $200 a month a lot for car insurance in Ohio?

Yes, it is well above the Ohio average for full coverage. The four-insurer average is $137 a month, and Progressive’s price in its priciest Ohio ZIP code is only $142. Only Allstate averages above $200, at $206. At $200 you would pay $63 more than the average and $108 more than Progressive’s $92.

Is GEICO or Progressive cheaper in Ohio?

Progressive, at all three levels we priced. For full coverage it charges $92 a month against GEICO’s $121, for 50/100/50 $89 against $120, and for Liability Only 15/30/10 $23 against $40. Progressive also posted the lowest price in every one of the 523 Ohio ZIP codes, so GEICO lands second in our ranking.

How much is car insurance in Ohio per month?

For our sample driver, full coverage averages $137 a month ($1,638 a year) across the four insurers we compared, using rates dated Sept. 30, 2026. The driver is 40 with a clean record. The Liability Only 15/30/10 tier averages $39 a month, yet its limits sit below what Ohio law allows.

What is the minimum car insurance in Ohio?

Ohio’s minimum liability is 25/50/25: $25,000 for one person’s injuries, $50,000 per crash and $25,000 for property damage, under Ohio Revised Code 4509.51. The list of required coverages does not include personal injury protection or uninsured motorist coverage. Our Liability Only 15/30/10 package is below that law, so we never call it the Ohio minimum.

What is the lowest-cost legal car insurance in Ohio?

Legal means at least 25/50/25 liability. That is $25,000 for one person hurt or killed, $50,000 for the whole crash when several people are hurt, and $25,000 for property damage. The liability-only prices in our data assume smaller 15/30/10 limits, which means the $23 figure doesn’t price a legal Ohio policy.

Why does the liability-only price use 15/30/10?

Our rate data builds its liability-only package that way for Ohio. Those limits were never in Ohio law, which required 12,500/25,000/7,500 until Dec. 22, 2013 and has required 25/50/25 since. So the tier is named “Liability Only 15/30/10” and is never described as what Ohio requires.

Why is car insurance so expensive in Ohio?

We can show where Ohio prices run high, but not the reasons. Franklin County averages $157 a month for full coverage and Hamilton County $153, against $115 in Putnam County. Single ZIP codes range from $111 in Findlay to $179 in Cleveland’s 44104, and Allstate’s $206 average is more than double Progressive’s $92.

Is 50/100/50 enough car insurance in Ohio?

We cannot say what is enough for you. The 50/100/50 package lifts injury limits to twice Ohio’s 25/50/25 and property damage to twice its $25,000, and our version adds $500 deductibles on your own car. It averages $137 a month, the same as full coverage, and Progressive is lowest at $89.

How much is full coverage car insurance in Ohio?

Full coverage averages $137 a month, or $1,638 a year, across the four insurers in our Ohio data, and Progressive has the lowest price at $92, or $1,098 a year. The price is for one 40-year-old with a clean record and includes 100/300/100 liability limits plus collision and comprehensive with $500 deductibles.

Is liability coverage full coverage?

No. Liability pays the other party’s bills when you cause a crash. Triple-I (the Insurance Information Institute) notes that “full coverage” is everyday shorthand for adding collision and comprehensive, which fix your own vehicle, to liability. Here, Liability Only 15/30/10 starts at $23 a month with Progressive and averages $39, while full coverage starts at $92 and averages $137.

Where is car insurance cheapest in Ohio?

Among the Ohio counties we can rank, Putnam County has the lowest full-coverage average, $115 a month. Among ZIP codes, 45840 in Findlay is cheapest for full coverage at $111, and 44104 in Cleveland is priciest at $179. For liability only, places such as Caldwell and McConnelsville price lowest.

Does full coverage cost more than 50/100/50 in Ohio?

Barely, if at all, in our data. The four-insurer average was $137 a month for full coverage and $137 for 50/100/50. Progressive charges $3 more a month for full coverage and GEICO $1 more, while Erie and Allstate priced the full package lower. Request both figures together.

Is uninsured motorist coverage required in Ohio?

No. Ohio law lets a policy include uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage but doesn’t make an insurer include it, so it is an option you ask for. It helps if a driver with no insurance, or too little, injures you. Our full-coverage prices include it at 100/300.

What happens if you drive without insurance in Ohio?

If you cannot show proof at a stop or after a crash, the BMV suspends your license: the first time until you meet its conditions (a $40 fee and an SR-22 or bond held one year), the second within a year for one year ($300), the third for two years ($600). Officers may ask for proof during traffic enforcement, under ORC 4509.101.

How do points affect car insurance in Ohio?

The BMV mails a warning letter at 6 points within two years and suspends a license at 12 or more points in two years. Reinstating after a 12-point suspension requires an SR-22 certificate or bond, held for one year when the suspension began after April 9, 2025, per the Ohio BMV. Our prices assume a clean record.

What is the best way to get cheap car insurance quotes in Ohio?

Give every insurer identical limits, 25/50/25 or higher, and identical deductibles. In our data the same driver’s full coverage differed by $114 a month from the cheapest insurer to the priciest, and by $68 a month from ZIP code 45840 to 44104. Then ask each company about the discounts you could get.