Farmers Mutual of Nebraska and Progressive have the lowest full-coverage prices in South Dakota among the five insurers we compared, at $138 and $140 a month. Progressive is also the cheapest for state minimum liability (25/50/25) at $16 a month and for 50/100/50 at $128. On average our sample driver spends $194 a month on full coverage and $29 on state minimum liability. Which leader wins on full coverage depends on the ZIP code, and so does the size of the bill: our cheapest and priciest South Dakota ZIP codes sit $94 a month apart.
Every price here is a model run for one sample driver, built on Quadrant Information Services rate data for South Dakota as of Sept. 30, 2026. None is a quote or an offer, and we priced 34 South Dakota ZIP codes rather than the whole state. Page updated Nov. 16, 2026. Method and sources for these prices
Cheapest Car Insurance in South Dakota at a Glance
Where the lowest monthly prices land, by coverage level
Full coverage package: liability limits 100/300/100, deductibles $500
Farmers Mutual of Nebraska and Progressive
$138 to $140/mo
Farmers Mutual of Nebraska $138 ($1,658 a year), Progressive $140 ($1,681 a year).
State minimum liability (25/50/25)
Progressive
$16/mo
$190 a year. Next lowest: Farmers Mutual of Nebraska at $24.
Same liability limits South Dakota law sets
Middle option: 50/100/50, $500 deductibles
Progressive
$128/mo
$1,541 a year. Close behind: Farmers Mutual of Nebraska, $135.
What Is the Average Cost of Car Insurance in South Dakota?
What does car insurance cost on average in South Dakota? Taking the five companies in our comparison together, the sample driver pays $194 a month ($2,323 a year) for full coverage, $188 ($2,258) for 50/100/50 and $29 ($342) for state minimum liability. Our data covers only 34 South Dakota ZIP codes, so these averages describe a small and uneven set of places rather than one uniform price. Choosing either full-coverage leader puts the monthly bill $54 to $56 below the state average, and Progressive’s liability price is $13 under the liability average.
Why Farmers Mutual of Nebraska and Progressive Share the Cheapest Full-Coverage Spot
Our naming rule is simple: when yearly averages are within 3% of each other, the companies are named together. In South Dakota, full coverage produces a pair. Farmers Mutual of Nebraska comes in at $1,658 a year and Progressive at $1,681, so $2 a month ($23 a year) separates them. State Farm is the third-cheapest company, and it sits $496 a year above the leader.
| Insurer | Per month | Per year | Gap per year vs. leader |
|---|---|---|---|
| Farmers Mutual of Nebraska | $138 | $1,658 | None (lowest) |
| Progressive | $140 | $1,681 | +$23 |
| Next lowest: State Farm | $180 | $2,154 | +$496 |
A $2 monthly difference is smaller than what a different address, car or driving record does to any single quote, so ask both companies for a price. The ZIP code you live in matters more than the statewide ranking, as the next section shows.
Which leader is cheaper depends on where you live
At the state level the two sit $2 apart, but ZIP code by ZIP code one of them always comes out lower. Progressive has the lower full-coverage price in 21 of the 34 ZIP codes: all seven Sioux Falls ZIP codes plus Brandon, Brookings, Dell Rapids, Harrisburg, Hartford, Madison, North Sioux City, Tea, Vermillion, Yankton, Watertown, Sisseton, Huron and Aberdeen. Farmers Mutual of Nebraska is lower in the other 13: Mitchell, Pierre and the eleven western ZIP codes in Rapid City, Box Elder, Black Hawk, Sturgis, Spearfish, Belle Fourche, Custer, Hot Springs and Pine Ridge.
| Insurer | Where Progressive is lower (21 ZIPs) | Where Farmers Mutual is lower (13 ZIPs) |
|---|---|---|
| Progressive | $117/mo | $178/mo |
| Farmers Mutual of Nebraska | $139/mo | $137/mo |
Farmers Mutual of Nebraska barely changes from place to place, at $139 a month in the first group and $137 in the second. Progressive moves a lot: $117 where it wins and $178 where it does not, a swing of $61 a month. Liability-only pricing is simpler: Progressive undercuts every other insurer in all 34 ZIP codes.
Cheapest Insurer at Each Coverage Level in South Dakota
Progressive takes two of the three levels by itself. On full coverage, the lead is a matter of dollars a year rather than dollars a month, and it belongs to Farmers Mutual of Nebraska and Progressive together.
| Coverage level | Cheapest insurer | SD price a month | SD average |
|---|---|---|---|
| State Minimum Liability 25/50/25 | Progressive | $16 | $29 |
| 50/100/50, $500 deductibles | Progressive | $128 | $188 |
| Full coverage 100/300/100 | Farmers Mutual of Nebraska and Progressive | $138 to $140 | $194 |
Step 1: Liability only
State minimum liability, 25/50/25
Lowest: Progressive $16/mo ($190/yr)
South Dakota average: $29/mo. Pays for injuries and damage you cause to other people. It never pays to fix your own vehicle.
Step 2: Middle package
50/100/50 with $500 deductibles
Lowest: Progressive $128/mo ($1,541/yr)
Close behind: Farmers Mutual of Nebraska, $135/mo ($1,619/yr). South Dakota average: $188/mo.
Step 3: Your own car, too
Full coverage package
Lowest: Farmers Mutual of Nebraska $138/mo and Progressive $140/mo
Statewide average: $194/mo. Built from 100/300/100 liability, 100/300 limits against uninsured and underinsured drivers, and $500 deductibles.
On state minimum liability, Progressive’s $190 a year sits $95 below Farmers Mutual of Nebraska’s $285, too wide a gap for a shared title. North Star and State Farm both average $29 a month at that level, and American Family averages $44. At 50/100/50, Progressive’s $1,541 a year is $78 under Farmers Mutual of Nebraska’s $1,619 ($7 a month). That lands outside the 3% band, so Progressive is named alone, and Farmers Mutual of Nebraska is the close second. Farmers Mutual of Nebraska is still the lower of the two in 12 ZIP codes at this level, including Pierre and all eleven western ZIP codes.
Compare South Dakota Auto Insurance Quotes for Your ZIP Code
Farmers Mutual of Nebraska, Progressive, State Farm, North Star and American Family Compared
All five insurers returned a price in every one of the 34 South Dakota ZIP codes we priced. In the chart, a shorter bar means a lower price. Each bar is one insurer’s average monthly cost for the same full-coverage package, the same driver and the same car.
| Insurer | Liability | 50/100/50 | Full |
|---|---|---|---|
| Farmers Mutual of Nebraska | $24 | $135 | $138 |
| Progressive | $16 | $128 | $140 |
| State Farm | $29 | $175 | $180 |
| North Star | $29 | $235 | $238 |
| American Family | $44 | $267 | $272 |
| All five | $29 | $188 | $194 |
American Family charges $134 a month more than Farmers Mutual of Nebraska for the identical full-coverage package, which comes to $1,605 a year. It is the most expensive of the five in 27 of 34 ZIP codes. North Star is next at $238 a month, and State Farm at $180 sits in the middle. Their prices pull the $194 state average above both leaders.
No insurer is cheapest everywhere. Progressive leads on liability and on 50/100/50, yet in Rapid City its full-coverage price ($178 a month on average across three ZIP codes) trails both Farmers Mutual of Nebraska ($142) and State Farm ($162). Look at the range each company charges before you trust its average:
| Insurer | Lowest ZIP | Highest ZIP | Spread |
|---|---|---|---|
| Farmers Mutual of Nebraska | $132 | $146 | $14 |
| Progressive | $107 | $231 | $124 |
| State Farm | $153 | $264 | $111 |
| North Star | $190 | $322 | $132 |
| American Family | $215 | $336 | $121 |
Farmers Mutual of Nebraska keeps its full-coverage price within a $14 band, from $132 to $146, across the whole state. Progressive runs from $107 to $231. North Star used only four different yearly prices in all 34 ZIP codes: $2,274 in 16 of them, $3,862 in the eleven western ZIP codes, $2,620 in six Sioux Falls-area ZIP codes and $2,586 in Pierre.
Why only five insurers? Five companies gave Quadrant-modeled South Dakota prices that fit our method, which adds up to 170 prices at each coverage level. Other insurers sell policies here, and one of them could undercut every figure on this page. Two items deserve a flag. First, Quadrant also priced Farmers Insurance, but only through its Smart Plan Auto program, which our method does not count, so that company is absent. It is a separate company from Farmers Mutual of Nebraska, which is included. Second, Quadrant attaches a note to State Farm’s results saying its premiums omit a marginal acquisition expense adjustment. We left those prices as reported, so a real State Farm quote could come in higher.
What Each Step Up in Coverage Costs in South Dakota
State minimum liability averages $29 a month and full coverage $194, a difference of $165 a month ($1,981 a year). Almost all of it arrives in one step. Going from 25/50/25 to 50/100/50 adds $159 a month ($1,916 a year). Going on to full coverage adds only $6 a month ($65 a year).
Doubling liability limits cannot explain a $159 jump when an entire minimum-liability policy costs $29. The 50/100/50 package is priced with $500 deductibles, the same as full coverage, so the step points to paying for damage to your own vehicle rather than to larger limits for other people’s losses.
Minimum liability can work when
- The car is paid off and the vehicle is worth little.
- Savings would pay for a repair or a replacement vehicle.
- You understand that 25/50/25 stops paying other people’s claims at those limits, and anything beyond them is yours to pay.
Step up to higher limits or full coverage when
- A hail storm, a deer or a crash that is your fault would leave you without a working car.
- A lender or leasing company requires collision and comprehensive.
- Your income, home or savings could be pursued after a serious injury claim that exceeds your limits.
Price the top rung before you settle. Progressive charges $12 a month ($140 a year) to go from 50/100/50 to full coverage, and Farmers Mutual of Nebraska charges $3. For that modest sum, liability climbs to 100/300/100 and the policy gains 100/300 limits against uninsured and underinsured drivers. If you are weighing 50/100/50, request a full-coverage price during that same conversation.
South Dakota’s Cheapest Counties and ZIP Codes
Our data is shallow in most of South Dakota, so we rank a county only when three or more of its ZIP codes were priced. Just 3 of the 20 counties in our data qualify: Minnehaha (9 ZIP codes), Pennington (4) and Lincoln (3). The last two, marked †, rest on three or four ZIP codes, so treat their figures as rough guides.
The three South Dakota counties we can rank
| County | ZIPs in data | Full coverage, per month | Liability 25/50/25, per month |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lincoln County† | 3 | $172 | $30 |
| Minnehaha County | 9 | $180 | $32 |
| Pennington County† | 4 | $226 | $32 |
| South Dakota, all ZIP codes | 34 | $194 | $29 |
† Three or four ZIP codes only. Small samples can shift when one price changes.
Lincoln County, made up of Harrisburg, Tea and one Sioux Falls ZIP code, is the cheapest of the three for both coverage levels: $172 a month for full coverage ($2,064 a year) and $30 for state minimum liability. Minnehaha County, which holds most of Sioux Falls along with Brandon, Dell Rapids and Hartford, averages $180 for full coverage and $389 a year for liability. Pennington County, home to Rapid City and Box Elder, costs $226 a month for full coverage, which is $46 more than Minnehaha ($552 a year). On state minimum liability the two are even at $32 a month, although Pennington’s $378 a year runs slightly under Minnehaha’s $389.
The other 17 counties appear through one or two ZIP codes each (18 ZIP codes in all), too few to rank: Beadle, Brookings, Brown, Butte, Clay, Codington, Custer, Davison, Fall River, Hughes, Lake, Lawrence, Meade, Oglala Lakota, Roberts, Union and Yankton. Their ZIP codes still count toward the state averages and show up in the table below.
Every South Dakota ZIP code we priced
Cheapest ZIP, full coverage
$159/mo
57006, Brookings
Priciest ZIP, full coverage
$253/mo
57770, Pine Ridge
Gap between them
$94/mo
$1,121 a year
Cheapest ZIP, state minimum
$23/mo
57262, Sisseton
Priciest ZIP, state minimum
$38/mo
57104, Sioux Falls
| ZIP code and city | Full, per month | Liability, per month |
|---|---|---|
| 57006, Brookings | $159 | $25 |
| 57201, Watertown | $166 | $23 |
| 57108, Sioux Falls | $170 | $32 |
| 57069, Vermillion | $170 | $25 |
| 57005, Brandon | $172 | $28 |
| 57032, Harrisburg | $173 | $30 |
| 57049, North Sioux City | $173 | $27 |
| 57064, Tea | $173 | $29 |
| 57401, Aberdeen | $174 | $29 |
| 57106, Sioux Falls | $177 | $35 |
| 57033, Hartford | $177 | $27 |
| 57301, Mitchell | $178 | $25 |
| 57262, Sisseton | $178 | $23 |
| 57110, Sioux Falls | $179 | $33 |
| 57103, Sioux Falls | $179 | $35 |
| 57107, Sioux Falls | $181 | $33 |
| 57042, Madison | $182 | $25 |
| 57022, Dell Rapids | $183 | $26 |
| 57350, Huron | $184 | $26 |
| 57105, Sioux Falls | $186 | $37 |
| 57078, Yankton | $188 | $25 |
| 57104, Sioux Falls | $188 | $38 |
| 57501, Pierre | $188 | $25 |
| 57783, Spearfish | $219 | $26 |
| 57785, Sturgis | $220 | $27 |
| 57703, Rapid City | $222 | $31 |
| 57718, Black Hawk | $223 | $30 |
| 57747, Hot Springs | $223 | $25 |
| 57701, Rapid City | $226 | $32 |
| 57719, Box Elder | $227 | $32 |
| 57717, Belle Fourche | $228 | $25 |
| 57702, Rapid City | $230 | $31 |
| 57730, Custer | $232 | $25 |
| 57770, Pine Ridge | $253 | $25 |
| All 34 ZIP codes | $194 | $29 |
Brookings (57006) has the lowest full-coverage average at $159 a month, with Watertown (57201) at $166 and Sioux Falls ZIP code 57108 at $170 close behind. The Rapid City ZIP codes run from $222 to $230, and Pine Ridge (57770) tops the list at $253. For state minimum liability, Sisseton (57262) and Watertown (57201) both come in at $23 a month, while Sioux Falls ZIP code 57104 is highest at $38. Sioux Falls itself spans $170 to $188 for full coverage depending on the ZIP code.
Western ZIP codes cost more, and three insurers account for it
Split the 34 ZIP codes into the eleven western ones (Rapid City, Box Elder, Black Hawk, Sturgis, Spearfish, Belle Fourche, Custer, Hot Springs and Pine Ridge) and the other 23. Across all five insurers, full coverage averages $227 a month in the west and $177 elsewhere. Liability-only barely differs, at $28 in the west and $29 elsewhere, so the regional gap shows up in full coverage rather than in liability.
| Insurer | Western 11 | Other 23 |
|---|---|---|
| Farmers Mutual of Nebraska | $138 | $138 |
| Progressive | $185 | $119 |
| State Farm | $183 | $178 |
| North Star | $322 | $198 |
| American Family | $311 | $253 |
| All five insurers | $227 | $177 |
North Star adds $124 a month in the west, American Family $58 and Progressive $66. State Farm adds $5. Farmers Mutual of Nebraska’s price does not move at all, so it overtakes Progressive and is the cheapest of the five in all eleven western ZIP codes. Insurers set their own territory prices, so a move between Sioux Falls and Rapid City can change which company is cheapest, not only how much you pay.
Search 34 South Dakota ZIP Codes for the Cheapest Insurer
Where in South Dakota do you park the car? The tables below list 34 SD ZIP codes with the lowest-priced insurer for each, and a search box over each table finds your ZIP code or town. Prices are monthly figures for a single benchmark driver, and the five companies compared all accept any South Dakota driver.
At full coverage, Progressive has the lowest price in 21 ZIP codes and Farmers Mutual of Nebraska in 13. On State Minimum Liability 25/50/25, Progressive has the lowest price in 34 ZIP codes.
| Measure | ZIP code | Per month | Per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cheapest SD ZIP code | 57006, Brookings | $159 | $1,913 |
| South Dakota average, 34 ZIP codes | All South Dakota | $194 | $2,323 |
| Priciest SD ZIP code | 57770, Pine Ridge | $253 | $3,034 |
Each price is a Quadrant rate for one benchmark driver, dated Sept. 30, 2026 (method: How We Priced South Dakota Car Insurance). Only 34 South Dakota ZIP codes were priced, so a ZIP code missing from the tables has no price here. The five insurers all sell to any South Dakota driver, and your own quote will differ.
Full-coverage prices for every ZIP code
| ZIP code | Place | Cheapest insurer | Lowest monthly price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 57005 | Brandon | Progressive | $113/mo |
| 57006 | Brookings | Progressive | $107/mo |
| 57022 | Dell Rapids | Progressive | $126/mo |
| 57032 | Harrisburg | Progressive | $112/mo |
| 57033 | Hartford | Progressive | $120/mo |
| 57042 | Madison | Progressive | $120/mo |
| 57049 | North Sioux City | Progressive | $114/mo |
| 57064 | Tea | Progressive | $124/mo |
| 57069 | Vermillion | Progressive | $122/mo |
| 57078 | Yankton | Progressive | $128/mo |
Showing 1–10 of 34
State Minimum Liability 25/50/25 by ZIP code
| ZIP code | Place | Cheapest insurer | Lowest monthly price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 57005 | Brandon | Progressive | $17/mo |
| 57006 | Brookings | Progressive | $14/mo |
| 57022 | Dell Rapids | Progressive | $14/mo |
| 57032 | Harrisburg | Progressive | $16/mo |
| 57033 | Hartford | Progressive | $15/mo |
| 57042 | Madison | Progressive | $14/mo |
| 57049 | North Sioux City | Progressive | $15/mo |
| 57064 | Tea | Progressive | $16/mo |
| 57069 | Vermillion | Progressive | $14/mo |
| 57078 | Yankton | Progressive | $14/mo |
Showing 1–10 of 34
Check Car Insurance Prices in Your South Dakota ZIP Code
What South Dakota Law Requires
South Dakota requires every policy to carry liability coverage of at least 25/50/25, and it also requires uninsured motorist coverage that matches the bodily injury limits (25/50 at the minimum). Our state minimum liability tier prices the same 25/50/25 liability limits, so the $16 to $44 prices above are for the limits the law sets. Make sure uninsured motorist coverage appears on any quote you hold up against them.
| Coverage | Required amount | What it pays for |
|---|---|---|
| Injury, one person | $25,000 | Bills for one person you hurt |
| Injury, one crash | $50,000 | Bills for everyone you hurt in one crash |
| Property damage | $25,000 | Other people’s cars and property |
| Uninsured motorist | Required, matching your injury limits | Your injuries if the other driver lacks coverage |
| Extras | Your choice | Collision and comprehensive for your own vehicle |
Sources: South Dakota Division of Insurance and South Dakota Codified Laws.
Why Prices Run High or Low in South Dakota
A price table gives numbers and no reasons. For context, these sourced facts describe driving in South Dakota; they are not proof of why any SD driver pays what they pay.
- Uninsured drivers: Triple-I, the insurance industry’s research group, reports the Insurance Research Council’s 2025 estimate that 9.4 percent of South Dakota drivers had no insurance in 2023.
- ZIP code gap: Pine Ridge (57770) averages $253 a month for full coverage and Brookings (57006) averages $159, a difference of $94 a month from location alone in our South Dakota data.
| Fact | Number | Year | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Drivers without insurance | 9.4 percent | 2023 | Insurance Research Council, via Triple-I (2025 study) |
Sources: Insurance Research Council, via Triple-I (2025 study), Triple-I uninsured motorist statistics. Checked 2026-11-16.
Cheap Auto Insurance in South Dakota: 8 Ways to Pay Less
- Quote both full-coverage leaders. Farmers Mutual of Nebraska and Progressive are $2 a month apart on average, but in 13 ZIP codes the lower of the two is Farmers Mutual of Nebraska and in 21 it is Progressive. Only a quote for your address settles it.
- Compare at least five companies. The same full-coverage package costs $138 a month at Farmers Mutual of Nebraska and $272 at American Family, a difference of $1,605 a year.
- Price three levels in one call. Our averages rise by $159 a month from state minimum to 50/100/50, then by just $6 more to full coverage. The last step is the cheapest one.
- Test a $1,000 deductible. The prices above all assume $500. Ask each insurer what a higher deductible saves, and only choose it if you could pay that amount on short notice.
- Re-quote when you move across the state. Full coverage averages $227 a month in the eleven western ZIP codes and $177 in the rest of South Dakota, so a move between Sioux Falls and Rapid City changes your bill and may change the winner.
- Shop even inside one city. The seven Sioux Falls ZIP codes range from $170 to $188 a month for full coverage ($170 in 57108 and $188 in 57104).
- Choose liability-only only on purpose. Progressive’s $16 a month for 25/50/25 is the lowest price in our data, but it pays nothing toward your own car. Keep uninsured motorist coverage, which South Dakota requires, on the policy.
- Ask about discounts that fit your life. Our prices describe one sample driver. Bundling with home or renters insurance, insuring more than one car or keeping a clean record may lower your own quote, and each company applies those differently.
Read the South Dakota Division of Insurance auto insurance page for how South Dakota’s own regulator describes auto coverage.
South Dakota Auto Insurance Quotes: How to Compare Them
Our prices describe one driver in one kind of car. Real South Dakota quotes will reflect your vehicle, your ticket and claim history, the other drivers in your household and where the car sleeps. These habits keep competing quotes on equal footing:
- Request identical liability limits from each company, starting at 25/50/25.
- Keep deductibles identical on each quote so a lower price does not simply reflect higher out-of-pocket costs.
- Confirm that uninsured motorist coverage, which South Dakota requires, appears on every quote.
- List the same drivers and vehicles with each company.
- Ask each company how the price changes when you add comprehensive and collision.
Put South Dakota Quotes Side by Side
Sioux Falls, Rapid City and the Rest of South Dakota
Sioux Falls is the state’s largest market in our data, with seven ZIP codes across Minnehaha and Lincoln counties. Across the five insurers, full coverage averages $180 a month there and state minimum liability $35. Progressive is the cheapest in all seven at $111 a month on average for full coverage, followed by Farmers Mutual of Nebraska at $143. State Farm averages $176 and American Family $256.
Rapid City reverses the order. Its three ZIP codes average $226 for full coverage and $31 for state minimum liability. Farmers Mutual of Nebraska is cheapest there at $142 a month, State Farm is next at $162, and Progressive follows at $178. North Star ($322) and American Family ($325) are the most expensive. Rapid City drivers who pick Progressive because of its statewide ranking would pay about $36 a month more, on average, than they would with Farmers Mutual of Nebraska.
Smaller markets lean east. Watertown (57201), Brookings (57006), Aberdeen (57401) and Vermillion (57069) all price full coverage between $159 and $174 a month, below the $194 state average, with Progressive the cheapest insurer in each. Pierre and Mitchell are the exceptions in the middle of the state: both favor Farmers Mutual of Nebraska. Huron ($184) and Yankton ($188) sit a little higher, though still under that average.
How We Priced South Dakota Car Insurance
Quadrant Information Services supplies the prices. Its software applies each insurer’s filed rates and rating rules to a driver profile we choose. We take the South Dakota results, compare them and compute the averages shown here, all as of Sept. 30, 2026.
- The driver: Quadrant priced one profile throughout: an unmarried man aged 40 whose credit is good, who has held a license for 24 years and has no claims or tickets. His vehicle is a paid-for 2024 Toyota Camry LE, driven for personal errands only.
- The coverage: three packages. The first is liability at 25/50/25, the limits written into South Dakota law, with nothing for your own car. The second is 50/100/50 liability with $500 deductibles. The third is full coverage: 100/300/100 liability, 100/300 limits against uninsured and underinsured drivers, and $500 deductibles on collision and comprehensive.
- The sample: 34 ZIP codes in 20 counties. Farmers Mutual of Nebraska, Progressive, State Farm, North Star and American Family each returned a price in all 34, which makes 170 prices for each coverage level. Where a company returned more than one price for a ZIP code (Progressive returned two in every one), we used the lowest.
- The math: each state, county or ZIP code average takes the insurer prices inside that area and averages them, counting every insurer once per ZIP code. We divide yearly prices by twelve and round to the dollar for monthly figures, and each monthly gap is the difference between two rounded numbers.
- Who gets named: to be named, an insurer has to sell to all drivers and have prices in at least half the ZIP codes. All five clear both bars with 34 of 34. We name together any insurers whose yearly averages are within 3% of the lowest. Full coverage puts Farmers Mutual of Nebraska ($1,658) and Progressive ($1,681) in one band. For 50/100/50 and state minimum liability, Progressive sits outside that band and is named alone.
- What was left out: Farmers Insurance was priced in all 34 ZIP codes at all three levels, but only through its Smart Plan Auto program, which our method excludes. We skip any county that shows up through just one or two ZIP codes. State Farm’s prices stay in the averages with the Quadrant note described above. Quadrant returned no South Dakota prices for Auto Club (AAA), USAA or Farm Bureau companies, so none of them was left out of an average or ranking. Nothing else was removed.
Your own number will reflect your ZIP code, your car, your history, the limits you choose and the discounts you earn. Nothing on this page is a quote, an offer or a promise of a price.
Rates in effect Sept. 30, 2026
Rate data: Quadrant Information Services, bundle 845, as of Sept. 30, 2026. Page refreshed . A South Dakota price here is what one modeled driver would be charged, and no insurer has committed to it.
Compare nearby states
Average monthly price for full coverage in nearby states, compared with the South Dakota average of $194 a month. Same Quadrant Information Services rates (as of Sept. 30, 2026).
- Wyoming rates: $161 a month, $33 less than the South Dakota average
- North Dakota: $164 a month, $30 less than the South Dakota average
- Montana: $178 a month, $16 less than the South Dakota average
- Iowa rates: $184 a month, $10 less than the South Dakota average
- Nebraska rates: $199 a month, $5 more than the South Dakota average
- Minnesota: $221 a month, $27 more than the South Dakota average
See prices for every state: Cheap Car Insurance by State.
Your South Dakota Car Insurance Questions
Who has the cheapest car insurance in South Dakota right now?
Farmers Mutual of Nebraska and Progressive share the lowest full-coverage price, $138 and $140 a month, among the five insurers we priced. Progressive is lowest alone at 50/100/50 ($128) and for state minimum liability 25/50/25 ($16). All figures use Sept. 30, 2026 rates; Farmers Insurance is not counted because Quadrant priced it only through its Smart Plan Auto program.
Is $200 a month a lot for car insurance in South Dakota?
For full coverage, yes. The five-insurer average is $194 a month, and Farmers Mutual of Nebraska’s price tops out at $146 in all 34 ZIP codes we priced, so the cheapest price in every one of them is under $200. Progressive runs from $107 to $231, and ZIP-code averages range from $159 in Brookings to $253 in Pine Ridge.
Is Progressive or Farmers Mutual of Nebraska cheaper in South Dakota?
Progressive is cheaper for state minimum liability, $16 a month against $24, and for 50/100/50, $128 against $135. Farmers Mutual of Nebraska is cheaper for full coverage, $138 against $140. By ZIP code, Progressive has the lower full-coverage price in 21 of the 34, so the answer depends on where you live.
What is the average cost of car insurance in South Dakota?
A 40-year-old driver with no claims or tickets pays an average of $194 a month ($2,323 a year) for full coverage in South Dakota, counting the five insurers we compared and rates in effect Sept. 30, 2026. Dropping to state minimum liability brings the average to $29 a month ($342 a year).
What is the minimum car insurance in South Dakota?
South Dakota requires 25/50/25 liability: meaning $25,000 toward one person’s injuries, $50,000 toward everyone hurt in a single crash and $25,000 toward property damage, under SDCL 32-35-70. Uninsured motorist coverage is also required, matching your bodily injury limits, and personal injury protection is not. Our minimum-liability tier uses those exact limits.
How little can you pay for legal car insurance in South Dakota?
The cheapest compliant policy carries 25/50/25 liability plus uninsured motorist coverage, and our lowest-limit tier uses those same liability limits. Progressive averages $16 a month ($190 a year) and Farmers Mutual of Nebraska $24. Compare it with quotes that include uninsured motorist coverage, since our liability prices do not itemize it.
Why is car insurance different in Rapid City than in Sioux Falls?
In our data, full coverage averages $226 a month across three Rapid City ZIP codes and $180 across seven Sioux Falls ZIP codes. North Star, American Family and Progressive charge more in Rapid City, while Farmers Mutual of Nebraska’s price stays the same. That makes Farmers Mutual of Nebraska the cheapest in Rapid City and Progressive the cheapest in Sioux Falls.
Which South Dakota ZIP code has the cheapest car insurance?
For full coverage, Brookings (57006) is cheapest at $159 a month. For state minimum liability, Sisseton (57262) is cheapest at $23 a month. Pine Ridge (57770) has the highest full-coverage price at $253.
Why is car insurance so expensive in South Dakota?
Our South Dakota data shows how prices differ, not what causes them. Pennington County averages $226 a month for full coverage against $172 in Lincoln County, and ZIP-code averages stretch from $159 to $253. Insurers differ too: American Family averages $272 for full coverage, almost twice Farmers Mutual of Nebraska’s $138.
Is 50/100/50 enough car insurance in South Dakota?
That depends on your situation, so we do not advise. The 50/100/50 package gives double the required 25/50 injury limits and $50,000 of property damage, plus $500 deductibles for your own car. It averages $188 a month, $6 under full coverage, with Progressive lowest at $128. Liability limits pay other people; deductibles apply to your car.
How much is full coverage car insurance in South Dakota?
Full coverage averages $194 a month ($2,323 a year) for our sample driver. Farmers Mutual of Nebraska is cheapest at $138 ($1,658 a year), with Progressive at $140 ($1,681 a year). The package is 100/300/100 liability, 100/300 uninsured and underinsured limits with $500 deductibles on collision and comprehensive.
Is liability coverage full coverage?
No. Liability only pays for harm you cause others. The term “full coverage,” per Triple-I (the Insurance Information Institute), means the bigger package that also repairs your own vehicle through collision and comprehensive. Our South Dakota prices: state minimum liability 25/50/25 is $16 a month at the lowest and $29 on average, against $138 and $194 for full coverage.
Why is Farmers Insurance missing from the comparison?
Quadrant priced Farmers Insurance in South Dakota only through its Smart Plan Auto program, which our method does not count. Farmers Mutual of Nebraska, a separate company, is included and shares the lowest full-coverage price with Progressive.
What is the best way to compare South Dakota auto insurance quotes?
Hold limits and deductibles constant across every quote, and start at 25/50/25. Prices vary widely: for one driver, the full-coverage bill moves $134 a month from the lowest-priced insurer to the highest, and $94 a month from the lowest-priced ZIP code to the highest. Finish by asking each company about discounts.
How much is car insurance in Sioux Falls, South Dakota?
For our sample driver, the seven Sioux Falls ZIP codes average $180 a month ($2,160 a year) for full coverage and $35 a month for state minimum liability across the five insurers we compared. Progressive is the lowest-priced insurer in all seven, at $111 a month on average for full coverage. Farmers Mutual of Nebraska averages $143, State Farm $176 and American Family $256. The ZIP code tables above show the lowest price for any of the seven.
How much is car insurance in Brookings, South Dakota?
Brookings (57006) is the cheapest of the 34 South Dakota ZIP codes we priced for full coverage, at an average of $159 a month ($1,913 a year) across the five insurers we compared. Progressive is the lowest-priced insurer there at $107 a month for full coverage and $14 a month for state minimum liability. Farmers Mutual of Nebraska is next at $133.
