Progressive has the cheapest car insurance in Tennessee among the three insurers we compared, at every coverage level: $123 a month for full coverage, $108 for 50/100/50 and $28 for Liability Only 25/50/15. GEICO is next on full coverage at $169, so Progressive sits $46 a month lower. Only three companies were priced in all 301 Tennessee ZIP codes, so read these as the low end of a short list, not the whole market.
Two things set cheap car insurance in TN apart in our data. The insurer list is short, and the liability-only tier we priced falls short of the law. That tier carries $15,000 of property damage coverage, Tennessee has required $25,000 since a 2022 law change, and so the $28 policy is not a legal one. The cheapest priced tier that does meet the law is 50/100/50, and Progressive prices it at $108 a month.
Where you live moves the bill, too. Shelby County, home of Memphis, averages $264 a month for full coverage. Sullivan County in the northeast corner averages $151. Below: the lowest price at each coverage level, the gap between our liability-only tier and the law, county and ZIP code rankings, and a way to line up car insurance quotes in TN so the comparison is fair.
Data: Quadrant Information Services, Tennessee rates as of Sept. 30, 2026, for one sample driver. Every price is modeled for that one profile and binds no insurer. Page updated Nov. 18, 2026. Read the pricing method.
Cheapest Car Insurance in Tennessee: Progressive Wins All Three Tiers
Cheapest monthly price in our three-insurer comparison
Full coverage: 100/300/100 liability, $500 deductibles
Progressive
$123/mo
$1,480 a year. Next: GEICO, $169.
50/100/50 liability, $500 deductibles
Progressive
$108/mo
$1,300 a year. Next: GEICO, $177.
Cheapest priced tier that meets the 25/50/25 law
Liability Only 25/50/15
Progressive
$28/mo
$341 a year. Next: GEICO, $52.
Below Tennessee’s 25/50/25 legal minimum
The legal-limit answer: $28 for Liability Only 25/50/15 is the lowest price we have, but it does not buy a policy that satisfies Tennessee law. The cheapest priced tier that does is 50/100/50 at $108 a month ($1,300 a year), and that tier also covers damage to your own car above a $500 deductible. We did not price a bare 25/50/25 liability policy.
Short list: Progressive, GEICO and Allstate are the only insurers priced in every ZIP code. A fourth company could beat any figure here, so quote more than the three we show.
How much is car insurance in Tennessee? Across the three insurers, our sample driver pays an average of $187 a month ($2,238 a year) for full coverage, $183 a month ($2,199 a year) for 50/100/50 and $56 a month ($666 a year) for Liability Only 25/50/15. Allstate’s $267 full-coverage average pulls the statewide figures up. Progressive and GEICO both land below the $187 average.
The $28 price is not a legal Tennessee policy
Quadrant’s liability-only package for Tennessee pays up to $15,000 for property damage to other people. Tennessee asks for $25,000, and proof of coverage at that amount has applied since the start of 2023. A policy that meets the law carries a higher property damage limit, so its price can differ from the $28 shown here.
Tennessee’s 25/50/25 Requirement and Our 25/50/15 Liability-Only Tier
Two of the three limits in our liability-only tier match the law. The third does not. We priced $25,000 for one injured person and $50,000 for everyone hurt in a crash, which is what Tennessee requires, but only $15,000 for property damage against the $25,000 the law now asks for. That $15,000 figure was the old Tennessee property damage amount; Public Chapter 860 of the 2022 Acts raised it. Our 50/100/50 tier carries $50,000 for one injured person, $100,000 per crash and $50,000 for property damage, so it clears every line.
| Limit | Our Liability Only 25/50/15 tier | Tennessee law, 25/50/25 |
|---|---|---|
| Injury to one person | $25,000 | $25,000 |
| Injury to everyone hurt in one crash | $50,000 | $50,000 |
| Damage to other people’s property | $15,000 | $25,000 |
| Meets the law? | No: property damage falls $10,000 short | Required |
We keep the 25/50/15 prices because they show the cheapest bare-liability option and how steeply the bill rises as protection grows. Every mention on this page carries the label “Liability Only 25/50/15”, and none calls it a Tennessee minimum policy. For a policy that does meet the law, shop 25/50/25 or higher and compare each company’s quote line by line.
Sources: Public Chapter 860, Acts of 2022 (Tennessee Secretary of State); Tennessee Department of Revenue, why you should have insurance.
Cheap Auto Insurance in Tennessee: The Lowest Price at Each Coverage Level
Progressive tops the list three times, so the useful question is how much the answer costs you at each step. The three tiers below climb from a bare liability policy that falls short of the law to a package with $500 deductibles and then to 100/300/100 liability.
| Coverage level | Cheapest insurer | TN price a month | TN average |
|---|---|---|---|
| Liability Only 25/50/15 | Progressive | $28 | $56 |
| 50/100/50, $500 deductibles | Progressive | $108 | $183 |
| Full coverage 100/300/100 | Progressive | $123 | $187 |
Tier 1: Liability only, short of the law
Liability Only 25/50/15
Cheapest: Progressive, $28/mo ($341/yr)
Tennessee average: $56/mo. GEICO is $52 and Allstate $86. Its property damage limit is $10,000 below the law’s.
Tier 2: Meets the law
50/100/50 liability, $500 deductibles
Cheapest: Progressive, $108/mo ($1,300/yr)
Tennessee average: $183/mo. GEICO is $177 and Allstate $265. Double the required injury limits.
Tier 3: Full coverage
100/300/100 liability, $500 deductibles
Cheapest: Progressive, $123/mo ($1,480/yr)
Tennessee average: $187/mo. GEICO is $169 and Allstate $267. Four times the required limit for one injured person.
Progressive’s lead is wide and nearly universal. It has the lowest full-coverage average in 300 of our 301 ZIP codes, and GEICO has it in the other one. For liability only and for 50/100/50, Progressive is lowest in all 301. The dollar gaps to GEICO are $46 a month on full coverage, $69 on 50/100/50 and $24 on liability only. Allstate sits well above both: $144 a month over Progressive on full coverage, which is $1,719 a year.
Because one company wins almost everywhere, shopping in Tennessee is less about hunting for the winner and more about checking the gap. If Progressive’s quote comes back near the figures here, a GEICO quote tells you whether your own driving record or car narrows the $46 difference. If Progressive declines you or prices high, GEICO is the next place to look.
Check Tennessee Prices Against the 25/50/25 Law
The next section puts all three insurers in one view, so you can see how far each sits from the leader.
Tennessee Car Insurance Prices Compared: Progressive, GEICO and Allstate
The chart compares monthly full-coverage prices with the driver and vehicle held constant, so bar length reflects only the insurer. Bills shrink as the bar does. All three insurers have a price in each of the 301 ZIP codes.
| Insurer | Liability Only 25/50/15 | 50/100/50 | Full coverage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Progressive | $28 ($341) | $108 ($1,300) | $123 ($1,480) |
| GEICO | $52 ($629) | $177 ($2,119) | $169 ($2,033) |
| Allstate | $86 ($1,030) | $265 ($3,179) | $267 ($3,199) |
| Tennessee average | $56 | $183 | $187 |
Over a full year the three insurers average $666 for liability only, $2,199 for 50/100/50 and $2,238 for full coverage. Progressive’s full-coverage price is $553 below GEICO’s and $1,719 below Allstate’s for the same driver and car, and Progressive was the lowest of the three in 300 of 301 ZIP codes.
Why this comparison has only three insurers
Quadrant returned usable Tennessee prices from Progressive, GEICO and Allstate in all 301 ZIP codes. Other companies sell car insurance in Tennessee, but they are not in our data, so each “cheapest” claim here is limited to these three. A shopper who stops at three quotes may miss a lower one, because a regional or smaller company may price a given driver below all three. Treat our numbers as a benchmark to beat.
Why Tennessee Farmers is missing
Tennessee Farmers appears in the Quadrant output, but every one of its quotes in all 301 ZIP codes carries a note that Farm Bureau membership is required to be insured by the company. Most drivers cannot simply buy that policy, so we kept it out of the rankings and the averages, and we list it here so nothing disappears quietly. If you belong to Farm Bureau, or would join, request a Tennessee Farmers quote as well. We cannot say how its price compares with the three companies above.
Liability Only 25/50/15, 50/100/50 or Full Coverage: What Each Costs in Tennessee
The big jump comes between the first and second tiers. Across Tennessee, 50/100/50 averages $127 a month more than Liability Only 25/50/15 ($183 against $56), or $1,533 a year. The next step is almost free: full coverage averages $187, only $4 a month above 50/100/50, and $39 a year.
Part of that first jump is the property damage limit, which goes from $15,000 to $50,000. The rest comes from adding coverage for your own car above a $500 deductible and doubling the injury limits. Because the 50/100/50 tier is the cheapest one we priced that meets Tennessee law, it is the better starting point for a legal comparison than the $56 figure.
A thinner policy can fit if
- Nobody holds a lien or lease on the car, so collision and comprehensive are your call.
- You could pay to fix or replace the car from savings.
- You buy liability at 25/50/25 or higher. Our 25/50/15 tier is below that.
- You are comfortable relying on your own health coverage for your medical bills after a crash.
Full coverage makes more sense if
- A loan or lease contract requires collision and comprehensive on the car.
- A repair bill after a crash would strain your budget.
- You want liability well above the law: 100/300/100 is four times the required amount for one injured person.
- You have assets a lawsuit could reach and want more room above the legal limits.
Ask for both packages side by side. Progressive’s full-coverage quote runs $15 a month above its 50/100/50 quote ($180 a year), and Allstate’s runs $2 above ($20 a year). GEICO reverses the pattern: its full-coverage quote sits $8 a month below 50/100/50 ($86 a year). Pricing only one package can hide the cheaper one.
Where Car Insurance Costs the Least in Tennessee
Tennessee has 89 counties in our data and 37 of them have at least three priced ZIP codes, and those 37 get ranked. The other 52 (38 with one ZIP code and 14 with two) are too thin to call, so they are listed after the table, and their ZIP codes still appear in the ZIP tables. A † beside a county means its average rests on three or four ZIP codes, so it is a rough guide. 23 of the ranked counties carry one.
Tennessee counties by full-coverage price, lowest first
| County | ZIP codes | Full coverage | Liability Only 25/50/15 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sullivan County | 7 | $151 ($1,806) |
$47 ($561) |
| Washington County | 5 | $154 ($1,847) |
$47 ($569) |
| Hawkins County† | 3 | $157 ($1,882) |
$47 ($565) |
| Cumberland County† | 4 | $164 ($1,962) |
$47 ($563) |
| Blount County | 6 | $164 ($1,969) |
$51 ($613) |
| Hamblen County† | 3 | $165 ($1,976) |
$50 ($594) |
| Greene County | 6 | $165 ($1,982) |
$48 ($571) |
| Monroe County† | 4 | $166 ($1,989) |
$48 ($574) |
| McMinn County† | 4 | $166 ($1,995) |
$49 ($584) |
| Putnam County† | 4 | $167 ($2,006) |
$48 ($574) |
| Jefferson County† | 4 | $168 ($2,018) |
$51 ($608) |
| Loudon County† | 4 | $169 ($2,023) |
$51 ($606) |
| Claiborne County† | 3 | $169 ($2,030) |
$50 ($599) |
| Sevier County | 5 | $170 ($2,038) |
$51 ($616) |
| Anderson County† | 4 | $171 ($2,048) |
$51 ($617) |
| Marion County† | 3 | $172 ($2,060) |
$50 ($602) |
| Maury County† | 3 | $173 ($2,070) |
$51 ($616) |
| Bradley County† | 4 | $173 ($2,071) |
$54 ($647) |
| Roane County† | 4 | $173 ($2,074) |
$50 ($596) |
| Knox County | 20 | $173 ($2,075) |
$56 ($669) |
| Williamson County | 8 | $174 ($2,084) |
$54 ($648) |
| Sumner County | 6 | $174 ($2,086) |
$55 ($658) |
| Rutherford County | 9 | $174 ($2,093) |
$57 ($678) |
| Hamilton County | 17 | $175 ($2,097) |
$56 ($670) |
| Wilson County† | 4 | $175 ($2,102) |
$56 ($671) |
| Franklin County† | 3 | $175 ($2,103) |
$50 ($596) |
| Gibson County† | 4 | $181 ($2,175) |
$50 ($598) |
| Robertson County | 5 | $184 ($2,211) |
$55 ($665) |
| Hickman County† | 3 | $187 ($2,239) |
$50 ($596) |
| Lawrence County† | 3 | $189 ($2,266) |
$49 ($584) |
| Dickson County† | 4 | $189 ($2,266) |
$52 ($624) |
| Cheatham County† | 3 | $191 ($2,288) |
$56 ($675) |
| Montgomery County† | 3 | $191 ($2,296) |
$60 ($716) |
| Davidson County | 23 | $193 ($2,317) |
$61 ($735) |
| Tipton County | 5 | $228 ($2,733) |
$67 ($798) |
| Fayette County† | 3 | $231 ($2,773) |
$69 ($822) |
| Shelby County | 32 | $264 ($3,169) |
$80 ($959) |
| Tennessee, all ZIP codes | 301 | $187 ($2,238) |
$56 ($666) |
† Three- or four-ZIP county, rough guide only. Counties left unranked for having under three priced ZIP codes: Bedford, Benton, Bledsoe, Campbell, Cannon, Carroll, Carter, Chester, Cocke, Coffee, Crockett, DeKalb, Decatur, Dyer, Fentress, Giles, Grainger, Hancock, Hardeman, Hardin, Haywood, Henderson, Henry, Houston, Humphreys, Jackson, Johnson, Lauderdale, Lewis, Lincoln, Macon, Madison, Marshall, McNairy, Meigs, Morgan, Obion, Overton, Perry, Polk, Rhea, Scott, Sequatchie, Smith, Stewart, Trousdale, Unicoi, Union, Warren, Wayne, Weakley, White.
Sullivan County, in the northeast corner, has the lowest averages among the ranked counties on both lists: $151 a month for full coverage and $47 for liability only. Shelby County at the other end has the highest: $264 and $80. That is a $113 monthly difference on full coverage and $33 on liability only. Shelby holds 32 of the state’s 301 ZIP codes, so it pulls the statewide figure up; the other 269 ZIP codes average $177 a month for full coverage.
The Memphis area is the most expensive part of Tennessee
The three priciest ranked counties for full coverage are Shelby ($264), Fayette ($231) and Tipton ($228). The same three top the liability-only list too, with Davidson County fourth. Every other ranked county averages $193 a month or less on full coverage. Fayette has three ZIP codes, so its figure is a small sample, but Shelby and Tipton are not.
Cheapest Tennessee ZIP codes
Cheapest ZIP, full coverage
$146/mo
37620, Bristol
Priciest ZIP, full coverage
$310/mo
38126, Memphis
Gap between them
$164/mo
$1,963 a year
| ZIP, city and county | Monthly | Yearly |
|---|---|---|
| 37620 Bristol, Sullivan | $146 | $1,752 |
| 37643 Elizabethton, Carter | $148 | $1,781 |
| 37615 Johnson City, Washington | $149 | $1,785 |
| 37686 Piney Flats, Sullivan | $150 | $1,796 |
| 37617 Blountville, Sullivan | $150 | $1,798 |
| 37601 Johnson City, Washington | $150 | $1,800 |
| 37618 Bluff City, Sullivan | $150 | $1,802 |
| 37604 Johnson City, Washington | $151 | $1,815 |
| 37664 Kingsport, Sullivan | $152 | $1,819 |
| 37659 Jonesborough, Washington | $153 | $1,831 |
| Priciest ZIP | 38126 Memphis, Shelby County: $310 a month ($3,715 a year) | |
| ZIP, city and county | Monthly | Yearly |
|---|---|---|
| 37166 Smithville, DeKalb | $44 | $532 |
| 37683 Mountain City, Johnson | $45 | $542 |
| 37367 Pikeville, Bledsoe | $45 | $543 |
| 37620 Bristol, Sullivan | $45 | $543 |
| 38583 Sparta, White | $46 | $547 |
| 37096 Linden, Perry | $46 | $548 |
| 37681 Limestone, Washington | $46 | $549 |
| 37617 Blountville, Sullivan | $46 | $550 |
| 37618 Bluff City, Sullivan | $46 | $550 |
| 37643 Elizabethton, Carter | $46 | $550 |
| Priciest ZIP | 38105 Memphis, Shelby County: $89 a month ($1,071 a year) | |
All ten of the cheapest full-coverage ZIP codes sit in three counties in the northeast corner: 5 in Sullivan, 4 in Washington and one in Carter. Bristol’s 37620 is first at $146 a month. Memphis holds the other end of the range, with 38126 at $310, 38114 at $299 and 38118 at $295. The $164 monthly gap between Bristol and 38126 comes to $1,963 a year.
The liability-only ranking is less concentrated. Six of its ten cheapest ZIP codes are in Sullivan, Washington, Carter or Johnson counties. The other four are Smithville in DeKalb County, Pikeville in Bledsoe County, Sparta in White County and Linden in Perry County. Smithville ($44 a month) sits at the bottom of the scale and Memphis’s 38105 at the top ($89). Bristol is on both lists.
Cheapest Car Insurance by Tennessee ZIP Code: Search All 301
Looking for your own corner of Tennessee? Both tables list all 301 ZIP codes we priced, and the search box filters them by ZIP code or place name. You get the lowest-priced company among the three we compared (none requires a membership) and its monthly price for one benchmark driver.
At full coverage, Progressive has the lowest price in 300 ZIP codes and GEICO in 1. On Liability Only 25/50/15, Progressive has the lowest price in 301 ZIP codes.
| Measure | ZIP code | Per month | Per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cheapest TN ZIP code | 37620, Bristol | $146 | $1,752 |
| Tennessee average, 301 ZIP codes | All Tennessee | $187 | $2,238 |
| Priciest TN ZIP code | 38126, Memphis | $310 | $3,715 |
Prices come from Sept. 30, 2026 Quadrant rate data for one benchmark driver (details in How We Priced Tennessee Car Insurance). Tennessee Farmers is left out because its quotes require Farm Bureau membership, and your own price will differ.
Full coverage by ZIP code
| ZIP code | Place | Cheapest insurer | Lowest monthly price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 37010 | Adams | Progressive | $130/mo |
| 37013 | Antioch | Progressive | $162/mo |
| 37015 | Ashland City | Progressive | $124/mo |
| 37022 | Bethpage | Progressive | $124/mo |
| 37025 | Bon Aqua | Progressive | $126/mo |
| 37027 | Brentwood | Progressive | $124/mo |
| 37029 | Burns | Progressive | $119/mo |
| 37030 | Carthage | Progressive | $120/mo |
| 37032 | Cedar Hill | Progressive | $134/mo |
| 37033 | Centerville | Progressive | $138/mo |
Showing 1–10 of 301
Liability Only 25/50/15 by ZIP code
| ZIP code | Place | Cheapest insurer | Lowest monthly price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 37010 | Adams | Progressive | $26/mo |
| 37013 | Antioch | Progressive | $44/mo |
| 37015 | Ashland City | Progressive | $28/mo |
| 37022 | Bethpage | Progressive | $28/mo |
| 37025 | Bon Aqua | Progressive | $25/mo |
| 37027 | Brentwood | Progressive | $32/mo |
| 37029 | Burns | Progressive | $28/mo |
| 37030 | Carthage | Progressive | $25/mo |
| 37032 | Cedar Hill | Progressive | $27/mo |
| 37033 | Centerville | Progressive | $22/mo |
Showing 1–10 of 301
See What Your Tennessee ZIP Code Costs
County and ZIP averages are a guide to the pattern, not a prediction for one street, so the metro figures below use the same caution.
Memphis, Nashville, Knoxville and Chattanooga: Car Insurance by County
Our data is built by ZIP code and rolled up to counties, not cities, so the figures below are county averages. Each county contains the city named beside it, along with its suburbs and rural areas.
Shelby County (Memphis), 32 ZIP codes
$264/mo
full coverage; $80/mo Liability Only 25/50/15
Davidson County (Nashville), 23 ZIP codes
$193/mo
full coverage; $61/mo Liability Only 25/50/15
Knox County (Knoxville), 20 ZIP codes
$173/mo
full coverage; $56/mo Liability Only 25/50/15
Hamilton County (Chattanooga), 17 ZIP codes
$175/mo
full coverage; $56/mo Liability Only 25/50/15
Memphis (Shelby County). The highest averages in the state: $264 a month for full coverage and $80 for liability only. Shelby is also the largest county in our data, with 32 ZIP codes, so its average rests on a large sample.
Nashville (Davidson County). Full coverage averages $193 a month, which is $6 above the Tennessee average of $187 but well below Memphis. The liability-only average, $61, is higher than every ranked county except the three around Memphis. In other words, Davidson County looks moderate on full coverage and expensive on bare liability, so compare both tiers there.
Knoxville (Knox County) and Chattanooga (Hamilton County). Knox averages $173 a month for full coverage across 20 ZIP codes and Hamilton $175 across 17. Both sit $18 to $20 a month below Davidson. Sumner, Rutherford and Williamson counties, all next to Davidson, land in the same $173 to $175 band as Knox and Hamilton. In our data, the extra cost shows up in Davidson County itself.
Why Prices Run High or Low in Tennessee
The rates we priced tell you what Tennessee drivers are quoted, not the reason behind it. A few public facts about Tennessee follow, offered as background rather than proof of what drives any single TN price.
- Young drivers: Tennessee issues a learner permit at 15 and an intermediate restricted license at 16, after 180 days with the permit and 50 supervised driving hours, 10 of them at night.
- Uninsured drivers: Triple-I, the insurance industry’s research group, reports an Insurance Research Council estimate that 21.3 percent of Tennessee drivers had no insurance in 2023.
- Location: Bristol (37620) is the cheapest Tennessee ZIP code in our data at $146 a month for full coverage, and Memphis (38126) the priciest at $310, so where you park the car is worth $164 a month.
| Fact | Number | Year | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Teen driver licensing steps | Permit at 15; restricted license at 16 after 180 days and 50 supervised hours | Current | Tennessee Department of Safety |
| Drivers without insurance | 21.3 percent | 2023 | Insurance Research Council 2025 study |
Sources: Tennessee Department of Safety, Teen driver license steps; Insurance Research Council 2025 study, Uninsured motorists. Checked 2026-11-05.
8 Ways to Pay Less for Cheap Auto Insurance in TN
- Quote Progressive first, then GEICO. Progressive had the lowest full-coverage average in 300 of 301 ZIP codes. GEICO’s average is $46 a month higher, so its quote shows whether your own profile closes the gap.
- Do not stop at the companies we priced. Only three insurers are in this comparison. If you can join Farm Bureau, get a Tennessee Farmers quote, and ask an independent agent about regional companies.
- Shop liability at 25/50/25 or higher. A 25/50/15 quote may look cheaper, but it leaves $10,000 of property damage coverage off the amount Tennessee requires.
- Quote 50/100/50 next to full coverage. At GEICO the fuller package is $8 a month cheaper. At Progressive it is $15 dearer.
- Test your deductible. We priced $500 deductibles. Ask each company what a higher one saves per month, then decide whether you could cover it from savings.
- Check the garaging ZIP code. Where the car sleeps is part of the price. Between our cheapest and priciest Tennessee ZIP codes, the full-coverage bill differs by $164 a month.
- Ask which discounts apply. Multi-car, multi-policy, safe-driver and paid-in-full discounts differ by company and are not in our sample price, so ask for each one by name.
- Shop again at renewal. Rates change, and our figures carry a Sept. 30, 2026 date. A quote taken a year ago may no longer be the lowest.
Want a neutral second opinion? Tennessee’s insurance department explains how auto coverage works in the Tennessee Auto Insurance 101 page from the Department of Commerce & Insurance.
How to Compare Car Insurance Quotes in Tennessee
The prices on this page come from a single driver profile. Your own Tennessee quotes will move with your vehicle, driving history, household and ZIP code. A fair side-by-side needs these matched:
- Identical liability limits, at 25/50/25 or above.
- Identical collision and comprehensive deductibles.
- The uninsured motorist line: ask each company how it treats it, then compare like with like.
- The same drivers, vehicle and garaging address.
- The same payment plan, including any fee for paying monthly.
- A written note of the quote date, since rates and discounts change.
Compare Tennessee Quotes on Equal Terms
Everything that follows explains where our numbers come from and what we left out.
How We Priced Tennessee Car Insurance
Quadrant Information Services supplies the numbers. It feeds a fixed driver and vehicle profile into each insurer’s rate filings and records the result. CheapCarInsurance.net then ranks and averages what comes back for Tennessee. The rates come from Quadrant bundle 845 and are dated Sept. 30, 2026.
- Driver profile: single, male, 40, good credit, no tickets or claims, licensed for 24 years, and a 2024 Toyota Camry LE that he drives for personal errands.
- Coverage tiers: we priced three. Liability Only 25/50/15 leaves out collision and comprehensive. In the middle tier, bodily injury is capped at $50,000 a person and $100,000 a crash, property damage at $50,000, and your own car carries $500 deductibles. Full coverage carries 100/300/100 liability with $500 collision and comprehensive deductibles. Quadrant built all three packages with uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage that matches the injury limits.
- The sample: 301 ZIP codes across 89 counties. All three insurers returned a result in every one, which gives 903 results for each coverage tier.
- The arithmetic: an insurer can return several results for one ZIP code, and we use its cheapest for our driver. Every statewide, county and ZIP average is a simple mean across the three insurers. We round each monthly figure first and then subtract, so a stated gap always equals the difference you can see on the page.
- Who gets named: open to all drivers, a price in half or more of the ZIP codes, and the lowest figure or one within 3% of it. Progressive’s lead is much wider than 3% at each tier, so no one shares its title.
- Excluded: Tennessee Farmers, because Quadrant notes that Farm Bureau membership is required to be insured by the company, in all 301 ZIP codes. Counties with only one or two priced ZIP codes are unranked, though their ZIP codes stay in the data and can appear in the ZIP tables. We left out no other insurer.
- The law: Tennessee’s 25/50/25 requirement comes from the sources linked above. Quadrant is used only to price the packages, not to define what the law requires.
Use the figures as a yardstick for one profile. What you pay will differ with your ZIP code, vehicle, record, chosen coverage and eligible discounts, and nothing here binds any insurer to a price.
Rates in effect Sept. 30, 2026
Rate source: Quadrant bundle 845. Last page update: . The Tennessee prices here come from a sample profile and are neither TN quotes nor offers.
Compare nearby states
Average monthly price for full coverage in nearby states, compared with the Tennessee average of $187 a month. Same Quadrant Information Services rates (as of Sept. 30, 2026).
- North Carolina rates: $153 a month, $34 less than the Tennessee average
- Alabama car insurance: $179 a month, $8 less than the Tennessee average
- Mississippi: $183 a month, $4 less than the Tennessee average
- Arkansas rates: $206 a month, $19 more than the Tennessee average
- Georgia: $218 a month, $31 more than the Tennessee average
- Kentucky rates: $225 a month, $38 more than the Tennessee average
See prices for every state: Cheap Car Insurance by State.
Tennessee Car Insurance FAQ: Prices, Limits and Quotes
Who has the cheapest car insurance in Tennessee right now?
Progressive, among the three insurers we compared (Progressive, GEICO and Allstate), on Sept. 30, 2026 rates. It is lowest at every level: $123 a month for full coverage, $108 for 50/100/50 and $28 for Liability Only 25/50/15, a tier below Tennessee’s legal limits. GEICO is next at $169, $177 and $52. Tennessee Farmers is shown separately because it needs Farm Bureau membership.
Is $200 a month a lot for car insurance in Tennessee?
For full coverage it is a little above the $187 three-insurer average and $77 over Progressive’s $123. Only Allstate averages above $200, at $267. By county, only Tipton ($228), Fayette ($231) and Shelby ($264) among the 37 ranked counties average more than $200, while Sullivan County averages $151.
Is GEICO or Progressive cheaper in Tennessee?
Progressive, at all three levels. Full coverage is $123 a month against GEICO’s $169, 50/100/50 is $108 against $177, and Liability Only 25/50/15 is $28 against $52. Of the 301 ZIP codes, Progressive is lowest for full coverage in 300 and GEICO in just one.
How much does car insurance cost in Tennessee per month?
For our 40-year-old sample driver with a clean record, full coverage averages $187 a month ($2,238 a year) over the three companies, using Sept. 30, 2026 rates. The 50/100/50 tier averages $183 and Liability Only 25/50/15 averages $56. Allstate’s higher prices lift every average.
What does the cheapest legal car insurance in Tennessee cost?
Tennessee requires 25/50/25 liability: $25,000 for one injured person, $50,000 per crash and $25,000 for property damage. Our Liability Only 25/50/15 price of $28 covers only $15,000 of property damage, so it is not a legal policy. The cheapest priced tier that meets the law is 50/100/50, at $108 a month from Progressive. We did not price a bare 25/50/25 policy.
Why is your liability-only tier built on 25/50/15?
That is how Quadrant defines its liability-only package for Tennessee. The $15,000 property damage amount matches what Tennessee required before Public Chapter 860 of 2022 raised it to $25,000. So we label the tier “Liability Only 25/50/15” and never describe it as a Tennessee minimum policy.
What is the minimum car insurance in Tennessee?
Tennessee’s liability floor is 25/50/25, meaning $25,000 for an injured person, $50,000 for all those hurt in one crash and $25,000 for damaged property. Public Chapter 860 of 2022 raised property damage from $15,000, and proof at the new amount has applied since the start of 2023, per the Tennessee Secretary of State. Our Liability Only 25/50/15 tier falls below that.
Why does your Tennessee comparison include only three insurers?
Quadrant priced Progressive, GEICO and Allstate in all 301 ZIP codes, and those are the only insurers we compared. Other companies sell in Tennessee but are not in our data, so a quote from one of them could be lower. Our claims about the cheapest insurer apply only to these three.
Why isn’t Tennessee Farmers in your comparison?
Quadrant marks every Tennessee Farmers quote, in all 301 ZIP codes, with a note that Farm Bureau membership is required to be insured by the company. Most drivers cannot buy the policy as quoted, so we left it out of the rankings and averages. If you are a Farm Bureau member, request a quote from it directly.
Why is car insurance so expensive in Tennessee?
Our Tennessee data shows where prices run high, not the reasons. Shelby County, with Memphis, averages $264 a month for full coverage against $151 in Sullivan County, and ZIP-code averages run from $146 in Bristol to $310 in Memphis’s 38126. Shelby’s 32 ZIP codes lift the state figure; the other 269 average $177.
Where is car insurance cheapest in Tennessee?
Northeast Tennessee. Among the ranked counties, Sullivan County has the lowest averages: $151 a month for full coverage and $47 for liability only. By ZIP code, 37620 in Bristol is cheapest for full coverage at $146 a month. All ten of the cheapest full-coverage ZIP codes are in Sullivan, Washington or Carter counties.
Is car insurance more expensive in Memphis than in Nashville?
Yes. Shelby County, which includes Memphis, averages $264 a month for full coverage, against $193 in Davidson County, which includes Nashville. For liability only the averages are $80 and $61. The most expensive ZIP code for full coverage is 38126 in Memphis, at $310 a month.
Is Progressive the cheapest in every Tennessee ZIP code?
Nearly. Progressive had the lowest full-coverage average in 300 of our 301 ZIP codes and GEICO in the other one. For liability only and for 50/100/50, Progressive was lowest in all 301. Your own quote can differ, because driving record, vehicle and discounts change each company’s price.
Is 50/100/50 enough car insurance in Tennessee?
Only you can weigh that. The 50/100/50 package doubles the injury limits Tennessee asks for and lifts property damage to $50,000 from $25,000, and it adds your own car’s coverage above a $500 deductible. It averages $183 a month, $4 under full coverage, and Progressive’s $108 is the lowest. It is the cheapest tier we priced that meets Tennessee’s limits.
How much is full coverage car insurance in Tennessee?
Full coverage averages $187 a month, or $2,238 a year, across the three insurers in our comparison. Progressive has the lowest price at $123 ($1,480 a year) and GEICO charges $169. Each quote assumes 100/300/100 liability and $500 deductibles for one 40-year-old driver with a clean record.
Is liability coverage full coverage?
No. Liability pays what you owe other drivers. According to Triple-I, the Insurance Information Institute, “full coverage” is the everyday label for a policy that pairs liability with collision and comprehensive cover for your own car. In Tennessee, Liability Only 25/50/15 costs $28 a month at Progressive and $56 on average, against $123 and $187 for full coverage.
What is the best way to compare car insurance quotes in TN?
Ask each insurer for the same limits, at 25/50/25 or higher, and the same deductibles. Include Progressive and GEICO, because Progressive was lowest in nearly every ZIP code and GEICO is the closest alternative, $46 a month higher on full coverage. If you belong to Farm Bureau, add a Tennessee Farmers quote.
