Lease vs. Owned Cars: How Does Car Insurance Rates Compare?

If you’re debating between leasing or buying your next car, you’re probably asking: Which one costs more to insure? Spoiler alert: leasing usually comes with higher insurance premiums. But there’s a good reason why.

In this guide, we’ll break down the true cost of car insurance for leased and owned vehicles, help you understand why those costs differ, and show you how to get the best possible rate no matter which route you take.

---

Leased vs. Owned Car Insurance Cost Comparison

Let’s start with a quick side-by-side look at how insurance requirements and costs compare between leased and owned vehicles:

Insurance Factor	Leased Car	Owned Car
Required Coverage	Full coverage + gap + higher limits	Liability minimums or full coverage optional
Average Annual Insurance Cost	$1,800 – $2,500	$1,200 – $1,800
Flexibility in Coverage	Limited (based on lease terms)	Full control
Who Owns the Car?	Leasing company	You
Can You Drop Comp/Collision?	No	Yes (if paid off and older)

Key takeaway: Leasing typically costs more to insure because the leasing company sets strict coverage requirements to protect their investment.

---

Why Insurance Is More Expensive for Leased Cars

🌟 Full Coverage Is Usually Required

Leased vehicles almost always require:

• Comprehensive coverage (protects against theft, vandalism, natural disasters)
• Collision coverage (covers repair costs after an accident)
• High liability limits (e.g., 100/300/50 minimums)

This ensures the leasing company gets paid even if the car is totaled or stolen. As a result, you pay more in premiums.

💸 Gap Insurance Might Be Mandatory

Many leasing contracts require gap insurance, which covers the difference between your car’s depreciated value and what you still owe on the lease if the car is totaled. This adds another layer of cost that isn’t always needed with owned cars.

🌊 Less Flexibility = Higher Costs

You don’t get to choose minimum coverage when leasing. Your policy must meet the leasing company’s standards, often at a higher level than state minimums.

---

Benefits of Owning When It Comes to Insurance

When you own your car outright:

• You can choose liability-only coverage if your car is older or low in value
• You can raise your deductible to lower premiums
• You decide when and how to insure based on your risk tolerance

Owning your car gives you total control over your insurance costs, which is why premiums for owned vehicles are often lower.

---

What Insurance Do You Need for a Leased Car?

If you’re leasing, expect your leasing company to require:

• Liability coverage: At least 100/300/50
• Comprehensive & collision coverage: With deductibles under $1,000
• Gap insurance: Often included in lease but sometimes separate

Some lenders may also require OEM parts coverage (original manufacturer parts), which adds to the cost.

---

Insurance Requirements for Owned Vehicles

If you own your car (paid in full):

• You’re only legally required to carry state minimum liability
• Collision and comprehensive are optional, based on your needs
• Gap insurance is not required but may still be smart for financed vehicles

Owning gives you flexibility to customize your coverage to your budget and driving habits.

---

When Leasing Might Still Make Sense

Even though insurance costs are higher for leased vehicles, leasing can still be a great option if:

• You want a new car every 2-3 years
• You like lower monthly payments
• You don’t drive high mileage

Just make sure you factor insurance into your total cost of ownership before signing the lease.

---

Tips to Save on Insurance for Leased and Owned Cars

🌐 Compare Quotes Across Insurers

Use comparison tools like CheapCarInsurance.net to check multiple carriers at once. Rates can vary by hundreds of dollars.

✉️ Ask About These Discounts:

• Multi-policy (home + auto)
• Safe driver
• Good credit
• Anti-theft devices
• Telematics programs

📆 Consider a Higher Deductible

If allowed under your lease, increasing your deductible can lower your monthly premiums.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it cheaper to insure a leased or owned car?

Owned cars are usually cheaper to insure because you have more flexibility and fewer mandatory coverages.

Can I choose my insurer with a leased car?

Yes, but your policy must meet your leasing company’s specific requirements.

Do I need gap insurance on a leased car?

Most leases require it. If it’s not included in the lease, you can purchase it separately.

---

The Bottom Line: Leasing vs. Owning and Your Insurance Costs

• Leased cars cost more to insure due to stricter coverage requirements and the need for gap insurance.
• Owned vehicles offer more freedom, allowing you to tailor your coverage to your budget.
• Either way, the best way to save is to shop around, compare rates, and ask about discounts.

---

⭐ Get a Free Quote and Compare Rates Now ⭐

No matter what you drive, CheapCarInsurance.net helps you find the best deal on coverage. Save money today by comparing policies from top providers.