Cheap car insurance in Buffalo, NY starts with Progressive, the lowest-priced of the 5 insurers we compared at every coverage level: $73 a month for full coverage. For the cheapest insurance quotes, or auto insurance quotes in Buffalo, begin there and add GEICO at $185; the Buffalo average across the five is $246. Changing companies can move the monthly bill by $309; changing ZIP codes moves the five-insurer average by $81 at most.
How much is car insurance in Buffalo? Averaging five insurers, our sample driver pays $246 a month ($2,947 a year) for full coverage, $233 ($2,793) for 50/100/50 and $136 ($1,627) for Liability Only 25/50/10. Progressive’s prices for those same packages are $73, $72 and $28.
Page updated Nov. 18, 2026. Every price here is modeled for a single driver with Quadrant rate data as of Sept. 30, 2026; they are benchmarks, not quotes. Of the 44 ZIP codes that name Buffalo as their primary city, 25 have prices in our New York data (all in Erie County); the other 19 are not priced, and nothing on this page describes them. Method: how we priced Buffalo car insurance
Cheapest Car Insurance in Buffalo, NY at a Glance: Progressive Leads Every Level
Buffalo’s lowest prices, one name at every level
Full coverage (100/300/100 liability, $500 deductibles)
Progressive
$73/mo
$873 a year. Next: GEICO, $185. Buffalo average: $246.
50/100/50 liability, $500 deductibles
Progressive
$72/mo
$860 a year. Next: GEICO, $171. Buffalo average: $233.
Liability Only 25/50/10
Progressive
$28/mo
$334 a year. Next: GEICO, $67. Buffalo average: $136.
Matches New York’s liability limits
Across the city: for cheapest car insurance Buffalo NY shoppers, the answer does not change by ZIP code, since Progressive has the lowest price in 25 of 25 priced ZIP codes at every level, and GEICO is second-lowest in all 25. No tie to sort out: in every ZIP code the next company is at least $80 a month higher at full coverage, $70 at 50/100/50 and $28 for liability only.
Each figure is a monthly price for one driver and one car. Gaps between companies come from how each one rates that driver; gaps between ZIP codes come from where in the city the car is garaged. The three packages are defined under how we priced Buffalo car insurance.
Average Car Insurance Cost in Buffalo Compared With New York
Buffalo’s averages come in under New York’s at each of the three coverage levels. The New York column uses the same five insurers over all 725 ZIP codes in our statewide data.
| Coverage | Buffalo | New York | Buffalo is lower by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full coverage | $246 [$2,947] | $288 [$3,457] | $42 |
| 50/100/50 | $233 [$2,793] | $271 [$3,256] | $38 |
| Liability Only 25/50/10 | $136 [$1,627] | $152 [$1,820] | $16 |
One company runs the other way. State Farm averages $382 for full coverage in Buffalo against $343 across the state, $39 more, and it is also above its state figure for 50/100/50 and for liability only. The other four are cheaper in Buffalo than they are statewide: Progressive is $73 here against $96 for the state, and GEICO is $185 against $221. Outside Buffalo, the cheap car insurance in New York page covers the rest of our New York prices.
New York’s 25/50/10 Limits, No-Fault Coverage and Our Liability Only Tier
Our cheapest package uses the same liability limits New York sets by law, 25/50/10, so its Buffalo prices are prices for New York’s minimum liability limits. The 50/100/50 package raises the limits on both injuries and property damage.
| Coverage | New York law | Liability Only 25/50/10 | 50/100/50 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bodily injury, each person | $25,000 each | $25,000 each | $50,000 each |
| Bodily injury, per accident | $50,000 total | $50,000 total | $100,000 total |
| Property damage, per accident | $10,000 total | $10,000 total | $50,000 total |
| Liability limits vs the law | The baseline | Same | Higher |
Liability is only part of what the law asks. New York also requires no-fault coverage, known as personal injury protection or PIP, of $50,000 for each injured person; it pays injury-related losses whoever caused the crash, and it pays nothing toward car damage. The request we sent to Quadrant left PIP unspecified, so the results cannot show how much PIP any Buffalo price includes, and a full policy quote from a company may come out different. New York also requires uninsured motorist coverage at 25/50; all three packages carried uninsured and underinsured limits equal to their liability limits.
Where the law comes from: the state insurance regulator’s answer on required coverage and its list of coverages you need and consumer guide to auto insurance.
Cheapest Insurance Quotes in Buffalo: The Lowest Company at Each Coverage Level
All three coverage levels give the same answer in Buffalo. Progressive is lowest for full coverage at $73, for 50/100/50 at $72 and for Liability Only 25/50/10 at $28. The runner-up is GEICO every time, $112, $99 and $39 a month higher. Behind them the order shifts a little: for full coverage and 50/100/50 it runs Allstate, Travelers, State Farm, while for liability only Travelers ($172) is lower than Allstate ($192).
| Package | Lowest-priced insurer | Its monthly price | Mean of the five |
|---|---|---|---|
| Liability Only 25/50/10 | Progressive | $28 | $136 |
| 50/100/50 | Progressive | $72 | $233 |
| Full coverage 100/300/100 | Progressive | $73 | $246 |
See Your Buffalo Car Insurance Prices Side by Side
Buffalo Car Insurance Prices by Company
Each of the five insurers priced all 25 ZIP codes. Rows run from the lowest full-coverage average to the highest.
| Company | Full | 50/100/50 | Liability only |
|---|---|---|---|
| Progressive | $73 [$873] | $72 [$860] | $28 [$334] |
| GEICO | $185 [$2,220] | $171 [$2,055] | $67 [$808] |
| Allstate | $262 [$3,142] | $260 [$3,124] | $192 [$2,306] |
| Travelers | $327 [$3,918] | $296 [$3,552] | $172 [$2,062] |
| State Farm | $382 [$4,580] | $365 [$4,374] | $219 [$2,623] |
| City average, all five | $246 | $233 | $136 |
State Farm is the highest-priced company at all three levels: $382 for full coverage, $365 for 50/100/50 and $219 for liability only. It is the single most expensive of the five in 21 of the 25 ZIP codes at full coverage. Travelers is the highest in the remaining 4. For liability only the top spot goes to State Farm in 17 ZIP codes and to Allstate in the other 8.
How Far Ahead Progressive Is in Buffalo
The gap is wide enough that it shows up ZIP code by ZIP code. At full coverage the next company is never closer than $80 a month, at 14218, and in 14208 the distance reaches $169. Progressive’s highest price in any Buffalo ZIP code, $97 at full coverage, is below the lowest GEICO price anywhere in the city, $146 in 14227. The same holds at 50/100/50 ($95 against $136) and for liability only ($38 against $52).
| Company | Full | 50/100/50 | Liability only |
|---|---|---|---|
| GEICO | $112 | $99 | $39 |
| Allstate | $189 | $188 | $164 |
| Travelers | $254 | $224 | $144 |
| State Farm | $309 | $293 | $191 |
Prices swing by ZIP code at every company, but not equally. At full coverage State Farm ranges from $278 to $485 a month across the 25 ZIP codes, a $207 spread, the widest of the five. GEICO spans $89, Travelers $79, Progressive $40 ($57 to $97) and Allstate $38, the narrowest.
Car Insurance Buffalo NY by ZIP Code: Where Prices Run Lower and Higher
Averaging all five insurers, full coverage costs $211 a month in 14219 and $292 in 14211, an $81 gap that comes to $974 over a year. The five lowest are 14219 ($211), 14226 ($213), 14228 ($216), 14221 ($219) and 14217 ($220). The five highest are 14211 ($292), 14204 ($283), 14201 ($277), 14215 ($276) and 14208 ($273). For Liability Only 25/50/10 the ZIP code averages run from $113 to $160, and for 50/100/50 from $200 to $277.
Car insurance Buffalo ZIP codes that also cover neighboring place names
For 17 of the 25 ZIP codes, USPS lists at least one more place name beside Buffalo, among them Cheektowaga, Amherst, Williamsville, West Seneca, Kenmore and Lackawanna; these ZIP codes also cover addresses with those labels. All five of the cheapest ZIP codes belong to that group. Full coverage averages $238 a month across the 17 labeled ZIP codes and $262 across the 8 that list only Buffalo, a $24 difference; for liability only the figures are $131 and $146. Two of the five priciest ZIP codes, 14211 and 14215, also carry extra labels, so the pattern is a tendency and not a rule.
All 25 priced Buffalo ZIP codes
The first column gives the ZIP code, Buffalo and any further USPS place names. The first two price columns are five-insurer means in monthly dollars, for full coverage and for liability only; the last shows Progressive alone at full coverage. The 50/100/50 means by ZIP code run from $200 to $277.
| ZIP code and city | Full | Liability | Progressive |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14201 – Buffalo | $277 | $152 | $77 |
| 14204 – Buffalo | $283 | $156 | $86 |
| 14206 – Buffalo, Cheektowaga, West Seneca | $242 | $131 | $85 |
| 14207 – Buffalo, Town of Tonawanda | $247 | $135 | $57 |
| 14208 – Buffalo | $273 | $153 | $61 |
| 14209 – Buffalo | $268 | $149 | $78 |
| 14210 – Buffalo, West Seneca | $232 | $127 | $85 |
| 14211 – Buffalo, Cheektowaga | $292 | $160 | $97 |
| 14212 – Buffalo, Sloan | $259 | $140 | $97 |
| 14213 – Buffalo | $268 | $151 | $57 |
| 14214 – Buffalo, University Buffalo | $249 | $138 | $61 |
| 14215 – Buffalo, Cheektowaga, Snyder | $276 | $150 | $93 |
| 14216 – Buffalo | $234 | $131 | $57 |
| 14217 – Buffalo, Kenmore, Tonawanda, Town of Tonawanda | $220 | $120 | $64 |
| 14218 – Buffalo, Lackawanna, West Seneca | $230 | $128 | $81 |
| 14219 – Buffalo, Blasdell | $211 | $113 | $72 |
| 14220 – Buffalo | $225 | $124 | $81 |
| 14221 – Buffalo, Amherst, Williamsville | $219 | $122 | $64 |
| 14222 – Buffalo | $265 | $148 | $78 |
| 14223 – Buffalo, Kenmore, Tonawanda, Town of Tonawanda | $240 | $135 | $65 |
| 14224 – Buffalo, West Seneca | $221 | $119 | $70 |
| 14225 – Buffalo, Cheektowaga | $242 | $137 | $65 |
| 14226 – Buffalo, Amherst, Eggertsville, Snyder, Snyder Square | $213 | $115 | $65 |
| 14227 – Buffalo, Cheektowaga, South Cheektowaga | $239 | $135 | $65 |
| 14228 – Buffalo, Amherst, West Amherst | $216 | $119 | $64 |
| All 25 ZIP codes | $246 | $136 | $73 |
Find Your Buffalo ZIP Code: Cheapest Insurer and Lowest Monthly Price
Search either table by ZIP code or by a neighboring place name such as Amherst or Kenmore, and it narrows to the matching rows. Between them the two tables list all 25 Buffalo ZIP codes in our data. A row gives the lowest-priced of the five insurers for that ZIP code and the monthly price it charges our one sample driver; every one of the five sells to any New York driver.
Progressive is the lowest-priced insurer in all 25 ZIP codes, both for full coverage and for Liability Only 25/50/10, so the Cheapest insurer column reads the same all the way down.
| Position | ZIP code and place | Per month | Per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lowest-priced ZIP code | 14219, Buffalo, Blasdell | $211 | $2,531 |
| Buffalo average, 25 ZIP codes | The 25 Buffalo ZIP codes | $246 | $2,947 |
| Highest-priced ZIP code | 14211, Buffalo, Cheektowaga | $292 | $3,505 |
These are Quadrant rates dated Sept. 30, 2026 for one benchmark driver; How We Priced Buffalo Car Insurance, further down, describes the driver and the three packages. The Place column lists any other place names USPS gives a ZIP code beside Buffalo. Quadrant priced 25 of the 44 ZIP codes that name Buffalo as their primary city, and the tables cover those 25; the other 19 have no prices here and nothing on the page describes them. Every one of the five insurers sells to any New York driver, none asks for a membership, and none was dropped. The request left PIP unspecified, so the results cannot show how much PIP any price includes, and your own price will differ.
Full coverage, ZIP by ZIP
| ZIP code | Place | Cheapest insurer | Lowest monthly price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14201 | Buffalo | Progressive | $77/mo |
| 14204 | Buffalo | Progressive | $86/mo |
| 14206 | Buffalo, Cheektowaga, West Seneca | Progressive | $85/mo |
| 14207 | Buffalo, Town of Tonawanda | Progressive | $57/mo |
| 14208 | Buffalo | Progressive | $61/mo |
| 14209 | Buffalo | Progressive | $78/mo |
| 14210 | Buffalo, West Seneca | Progressive | $85/mo |
| 14211 | Buffalo, Cheektowaga | Progressive | $97/mo |
| 14212 | Buffalo, Sloan | Progressive | $97/mo |
| 14213 | Buffalo | Progressive | $57/mo |
Showing 1–10 of 25
Liability Only 25/50/10, ZIP by ZIP
| ZIP code | Place | Cheapest insurer | Lowest monthly price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14201 | Buffalo | Progressive | $25/mo |
| 14204 | Buffalo | Progressive | $33/mo |
| 14206 | Buffalo, Cheektowaga, West Seneca | Progressive | $28/mo |
| 14207 | Buffalo, Town of Tonawanda | Progressive | $30/mo |
| 14208 | Buffalo | Progressive | $30/mo |
| 14209 | Buffalo | Progressive | $25/mo |
| 14210 | Buffalo, West Seneca | Progressive | $28/mo |
| 14211 | Buffalo, Cheektowaga | Progressive | $38/mo |
| 14212 | Buffalo, Sloan | Progressive | $38/mo |
| 14213 | Buffalo | Progressive | $30/mo |
Showing 1–10 of 25
Enter a Buffalo ZIP Code to See Who Is Cheapest There
Buffalo NY Car Insurance Packages: What Changes as You Step Up From Liability Only
Adding protection for your own car is where the bill grows. In the city average, Liability Only 25/50/10 ($136) to 50/100/50 ($233) adds $97 a month, and 50/100/50 to full coverage adds only $13 more. At Progressive the steps are $44 and then $1, so full coverage ($73) costs $45 more than liability only ($28) and one dollar more than 50/100/50 ($72). At GEICO the steps are $104 and $14.
What liability only leaves out
Liability Only 25/50/10 pays for injuries and property damage you cause, up to $25,000 a person and $50,000 an accident for injuries and $10,000 for property. It does not pay to fix your own car, and because the request left PIP unspecified, we cannot say whether any price includes the $50,000 no-fault benefit New York requires. If you finance or lease the car, read the agreement for the coverage it demands.
What the bigger packages add
Both larger packages add collision and comprehensive with $500 deductibles on each, plus higher liability limits; full coverage goes to 100/300/100. In Buffalo the difference between the two is small in our data, $13 a month on the city average, so it is worth pricing both side by side.
Why Prices Run High or Low in Buffalo
Our rate data shows what each company charges and says nothing about why. The two New York points below are background for readers, and neither accounts for any single Buffalo price.
- Young drivers: the DMV’s Graduated License Law applies to drivers under 18. In the upstate part of the state, which includes Buffalo, a junior license holder with no supervising driver may drive only between 5 a.m. and 9 p.m., except for trips straight between home and work or a school course. A junior driver may also carry only one passenger under 21 unless the others are immediate family.
- Uninsured drivers: Triple-I publishes an Insurance Research Council study that estimates 8.6 percent of New York drivers had no insurance in 2023. The figure is derived from uninsured-motorist claim ratios, so it describes the state and not Buffalo.
- Your ZIP code: across the Buffalo ZIP codes in our data, the mean full-coverage price climbs from $211 a month in 14219 (Buffalo, Blasdell) to $292 in 14211 (Buffalo, Cheektowaga), a gap of $81 a month.
| Subject | Source summary | Year | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Younger-driver licensing rules | Drivers under 18 fall under the Graduated License Law; upstate, a junior-license driver with no supervising driver may drive from 5 a.m. to 9 p.m. only, with exceptions for trips between home and work or a school course; in New York City junior-license holders may not drive | Current | New York State DMV |
| Share of New York drivers with no insurance | About 8.6 percent, an estimate | 2023 | Insurance Research Council 2025 study |
Sources: New York State DMV, Graduated License Law rules for younger drivers; Insurance Research Council 2025 study, Triple-I uninsured motorist statistics. Checked 2026-11-17.
Six Ways to Lower Your Buffalo Car Insurance Bill
- Start with Progressive and GEICO. They were the two lowest-priced companies in every Buffalo ZIP code at every coverage level we priced.
- Still get a quote from the other three. Allstate, Travelers and State Farm charged $189 to $309 a month more than Progressive at full coverage on the city average, but a single driver’s record can change that order.
- Price 50/100/50 and full coverage together. The city average moves only $13 a month between them, and Progressive moves $1.
- Enter your own ZIP code, not just “Buffalo.” Five-insurer averages run from $211 to $292 a month at full coverage across the ZIP codes we priced.
- Ask each company for its no-fault amount. New York requires $50,000 of no-fault coverage per injured person; because the request left PIP unspecified, the prices here do not show how much of it is included. Compare total quotes, not the base liability figure alone.
- Take a defensive driving course. New York’s Point and Insurance Reduction Program lowers the base rate of your premium each year for three years after an approved course; the DMV page has the details.
Getting Buffalo Car Insurance Quotes You Can Compare
You are not our sample driver, so your own quotes will differ. A fair side-by-side needs identical inputs:
- Matching liability limits from every company.
- Matching collision and comprehensive deductibles.
- No-fault coverage built into each quote, so you are comparing whole New York policies.
- The same household drivers and vehicles.
- The ZIP code of the garage or street spot, since Buffalo prices shift from one ZIP code to the next.
Begin Your Buffalo Quote Comparison
More New York Car Insurance Prices
Prices for the whole state, county by county, are on our cheap car insurance in New York page. It also names Progressive at every level, at $96 for full coverage, $94 for 50/100/50 and $38 for liability only. Buffalo’s Progressive prices of $73, $72 and $28 are $23, $22 and $10 a month under those state figures.
How We Priced Buffalo Car Insurance
Quadrant Information Services takes each company’s filed rating plan, enters one fixed set of driver and vehicle details, and returns the premium that company would charge. The Buffalo results below reflect the rates that applied on Sept. 30, 2026, ranked and averaged by us.
- Driver and vehicle: a single driver aged 40 whose license is 24 years old, rated with good credit and no violations or at-fault claims. The car, a 2024 Toyota Camry LE, is owned free and clear and driven for personal reasons only.
- The three packages: Liability Only 25/50/10 pays for harm to others and nothing for the Camry. 50/100/50 gives $50,000 per injured person and $100,000 per accident, with $50,000 of property damage cover; it also covers the Camry itself through collision and comprehensive, carrying $500 deductibles. Full coverage moves liability up to 100/300/100 and keeps the $500 deductibles. Each package carried uninsured and underinsured motorist limits equal to its liability limits, with medical payments and PIP left unspecified in the request, so the results cannot show how much of the $50,000 no-fault benefit New York requires any price includes.
- How much of Buffalo is covered: 44 ZIP codes name Buffalo as the USPS primary city. Our New York data prices 25 of them, all in Erie County, and leaves 19 without prices. This is a partial sample, so each Buffalo number speaks for those 25 ZIP codes and not for the whole city. A ZIP code whose primary city is a neighboring town is out of scope, even when a Buffalo ZIP code lists that town as an extra name.
- Which insurers: Progressive, GEICO, Allstate, Travelers and State Farm all returned a price for every one of the 25 ZIP codes, which makes 125 prices at each coverage level, and no insurer was set aside. Quadrant sent back no USAA, Auto Club (AAA) or other membership-only company for these ZIP codes, and none of the five asks for a membership. In each ZIP code and package GEICO answered through three GEICO companies and Progressive through two; we take the lowest, which leaves 150 of GEICO’s 225 Buffalo quotes and 75 of Progressive’s 150 unused. The data provider noted that State Farm’s New York quotes omit a line item called the marginal acquisition expense adjustment. Those prices stay in every table and average here, so a quote straight from State Farm might not match.
- Averaging: each ZIP code gets the mean of the five insurers’ prices, and Buffalo gets the mean of those 25 ZIP code means. A single insurer’s Buffalo price is the mean of the 25 prices it returned. Monthly prices divide each yearly price by 12 and round to whole dollars; when this page quotes a gap, it subtracts one whole-dollar monthly price from another.
- Naming a company: the name goes to the lowest price, as long as the company returned prices for at least half of the ZIP codes (all five returned all 25). A ZIP code win goes to the lowest yearly price. The cheapest-price-per-ZIP counts in the FAQ take the lowest of the five prices in each ZIP code.
These are modeled figures for a single driver. A real quote reflects your own vehicle, driving record, chosen coverage and discounts, and nothing on this page is an offer of insurance.
Rates as of Sept. 30, 2026
Quadrant Information Services supplied the rates (bundle 845), and this page was refreshed on . Each Buffalo number is a benchmark for one modeled driver, not a quote or an offer.
More New York car insurance prices
The New York statewide average is $288 a month; see insurer and county prices on our New York rates page.
Compare all 50 states: Cheap Car Insurance by State.
Questions Shoppers Ask About Car Insurance in Buffalo
Is $200 a month a lot for car insurance in Buffalo?
Not for full coverage: $200 a month is under the $246 Buffalo average, though it is $127 more than Progressive’s $73. At least one insurer quotes full coverage under $200 a month in 25 of the 25 priced ZIP codes, and under $100 in 25 of 25; the priciest of those lowest quotes is $97. That is the lowest price within reach in each ZIP code, not an everyday average.
Who has the cheapest car insurance in Buffalo right now?
Rates as of Sept. 30, 2026 put Progressive lowest at every level among the 5 insurers we compared: $73 a month for full coverage, $72 at 50/100/50 and $28 at Liability Only 25/50/10. GEICO is second at $185, $171 and $67.
How do I get auto insurance quotes in Buffalo, NY?
To make quotes comparable, give each company identical bodily injury and property damage limits, uninsured motorist coverage, a PIP amount, deductibles and garaging ZIP code. The prices on this page are sample figures for a single driver and not quotes, so treat them as a guide to whom to contact first: in every Buffalo ZIP code we priced, Progressive and GEICO came out lowest.
Is GEICO or Progressive cheaper in Buffalo?
Progressive, at every level: $73 against $185 for full coverage, $72 against $171 for 50/100/50 and $28 against $67 for Liability Only 25/50/10. Progressive had the lower price in 25 of 25 ZIP codes at each level, and GEICO was second-lowest in all 25.
Why is car insurance so expensive in Buffalo?
Our data points to the company more than the place. Full coverage runs from $73 at Progressive to $382 at State Farm, a $309 range, while ZIP code averages run only from $211 to $292. The Buffalo average of $246 is $42 below New York’s $288. New York law also requires no-fault coverage on top of 25/50/10 liability; the request we sent left PIP unspecified, so the results cannot show how much PIP any price includes.
What is the minimum car insurance in New York?
New York sets its liability floor at 25/50/10: bodily injury of $25,000 for each person and $50,000 for each accident, and $10,000 of property damage. New York also requires no-fault, or personal injury protection, coverage of $50,000 for each injured person, and uninsured motorist coverage at 25/50. Our Liability Only 25/50/10 package matches the liability floor, but the request left PIP unspecified, so the results cannot show how much PIP any price on this page includes.
How much does car insurance cost on average in Buffalo, NY?
Averaging the five insurers, full coverage costs $246 a month in Buffalo ($2,947 a year), against $288 ($3,457) across New York. For 50/100/50 the Buffalo figure is $233 against $271, and for Liability Only 25/50/10 it is $136 against $152.
Is 50/100/50 enough car insurance in Buffalo?
Set against New York’s 25/50/10 limits, the 50/100/50 package pays out more on every liability line: $50,000 a person and $100,000 an accident for injuries, $50,000 for property. Unlike liability only, it also pays for your own car through collision and comprehensive, at $500 deductibles. The Buffalo average is $233 a month against $136 for Liability Only 25/50/10 and $246 for full coverage.
Is liability coverage full coverage?
No. The liability portion of a policy answers for what you do to other drivers and their property; it leaves your own car out. “Full coverage” is informal wording that Triple-I (the Insurance Information Institute) ties to liability combined with collision and comprehensive on the vehicle you own. In Buffalo we price Liability Only 25/50/10 at $28 a month with Progressive against $73 for full coverage, and $136 against $246 on the five-insurer averages.
Which Buffalo ZIP codes have the cheapest car insurance?
By the five-insurer average for full coverage, 14219 is lowest at $211 a month, then 14226 ($213), 14228 ($216), 14221 and 14217. The highest are 14211 at $292, then 14204 and 14201. Progressive is the cheapest company in every one of them.
Are Cheektowaga, Amherst, Williamsville, Hamburg and North Tonawanda prices on this page?
Not on their own. Every price comes from the 25 ZIP codes where USPS names Buffalo as the primary city. A few also cover addresses labeled Cheektowaga, Amherst or West Seneca, and 14221 also covers addresses labeled Williamsville (five-insurer full-coverage mean $219 a month, Progressive $64). A ZIP code that names Williamsville, Cheektowaga, Hamburg, North Tonawanda or another town as its primary city is not among the 25, so no price here describes it.
What are the cheapest car insurance rates in Buffalo?
Rates as of Sept. 30, 2026 are lowest at Progressive: $73 a month for full coverage, $72 at 50/100/50 and $28 at Liability Only 25/50/10, among the 5 insurers we compared. We rank on price alone, so these are the lowest rates we found, not a judgment of service or claims handling. GEICO has the next-lowest rates at $185, $171 and $67.
Is no-fault coverage in these car insurance Buffalo NY prices?
We cannot tell. New York requires no-fault coverage of $50,000 for each injured person, but the request left PIP unspecified in all three packages, so the data does not show how much PIP any Buffalo price includes. A complete quote for car insurance in Buffalo with the PIP amount you choose may differ from the figures here.
