Progressive has the cheapest car insurance in Indiana among the three insurers we compared, and it holds that spot in every one of the 299 ZIP codes we priced: $105 a month for full coverage, $99 for 50/100/50 and $28 for Liability Only 25/50/10. For cheap auto insurance Indiana shoppers should start with Progressive’s $99 for 50/100/50, the lowest price we found for a policy that meets Indiana’s liability limits.
Indiana is a one-winner state in our rate data. Auto-Owners Insurance Co is second at $162 for full coverage, $168 for 50/100/50 and $38 for liability only, Allstate is third, and neither has the lowest price in any ZIP code at any level. Only three insurers made our ranking, so read it as a short list rather than the whole market. A fourth company, United Farm Bureau of Indiana, was priced in all 299 ZIP codes but sits outside the ranking and the averages. GEICO is not in our Indiana data.
At the county level, which of the three insurers you pick moves the bill more than where you live, with one big exception. Lake County, in the northwest corner, averages $221 a month for full coverage across 25 ZIP codes, and no other Indiana county averages more than $185. Hamilton County, north of Indianapolis, averages $149. Package, county and ZIP code each get their own section below.
Page updated Nov. 15, 2026. Every Indiana figure here rests on rates from Quadrant Information Services as of Sept. 30, 2026, run for a sample driver; treat them as reference points, not offers. How we priced Indiana car insurance
Cheap Car Insurance in Indiana at a Glance
Cheapest monthly price in each package
Full coverage (100/300/100, $500 deductibles)
Progressive
$105/mo
$1,260 a year. Runner-up: Auto-Owners, $162.
50/100/50, $500 deductibles
Progressive
$99/mo
$1,193 a year. Runner-up: Auto-Owners, $168.
Meets Indiana’s liability limits
Liability Only 25/50/10
Progressive
$28/mo
$331 a year. Runner-up: Auto-Owners, $38.
Below Indiana’s property damage limit
How Much Is Car Insurance in Indiana? Average Indiana Car Insurance Costs
Blend Progressive, Auto-Owners Insurance Co and Allstate and our sample driver pays $167 a month ($1,999 a year) for full coverage, $169 ($2,023) for the 50/100/50 package and $49 ($592) for Liability Only 25/50/10. The blend lands above the cheapest price because Allstate’s prices are the highest of the three. Against the $167 full-coverage average, Progressive is $62 a month lower, Auto-Owners is $5 lower and Allstate is $66 higher. Choosing among the three moves the full-coverage bill by as much as $128 a month.
The $28 Liability Only 25/50/10 price is below Indiana’s property damage limit
Indiana’s liability limits are 25/50/25, and the last number means $25,000 of property damage coverage. The liability-only package we priced stops at $10,000. The lowest price we found for a policy that meets Indiana’s limits is Progressive’s 50/100/50 package at $99 a month. None of our prices include personal injury protection or medical payments coverage.
Indiana’s 25/50/25 Limits vs Our Liability Only 25/50/10 Prices
The Indiana BMV sets Indiana’s liability limits at 25/50/25. In dollars, that is up to $25,000 toward one injured person, up to $50,000 toward every injury from one crash and up to $25,000 toward damage to other people’s property. Both injury limits in our Liability Only 25/50/10 package match those figures, so the whole shortfall is property damage: $10,000 against $25,000. Our 50/100/50 package is at or above all three limits.
| What it pays toward | Indiana law | Our Liability Only 25/50/10 | Our 50/100/50 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Per injured person | $25,000 | $25,000 | $50,000 |
| Injuries, whole crash | $50,000 | $50,000 | $100,000 |
| Damage to others’ property | $25,000 | $10,000 | $50,000 |
| Clears the law? | Baseline | No | Yes |
Indiana has a second rule. The Indiana Department of Insurance states that every newly written Indiana auto liability policy has to include uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage unless the buyer rejects it in writing. It lists uninsured motorist bodily injury at 25/50, uninsured motorist property damage at $25,000 and underinsured motorist bodily injury at $50,000. This page does not break that coverage out inside our packages, so ask each company what its quote carries for it.
United Farm Bureau of Indiana: shown separately
Quadrant returned prices for United Farm Bureau of IN Group in all 299 ZIP codes. Farm Bureau companies are kept out of every ranking, average, county table and ZIP table on this site, so the only place to see its prices is this box: $220 a month ($2,640 a year) for full coverage, $213 ($2,560) for 50/100/50 and $48 ($571) for Liability Only 25/50/10. None of those figures undercuts a price we name: Progressive charges $105, $99 and $28 for the same three packages. Ask the company directly what a quote would be for you.
Cheap Auto Insurance Indiana Shoppers Can Compare: Cheapest at Each Level
Progressive is first for every package, Auto-Owners second, Allstate third. How far ahead Progressive sits depends on the package: $57 a month at full coverage, $69 at 50/100/50 and $10 for Liability Only 25/50/10.
Lowest sticker price
Liability Only 25/50/10
Cheapest of the three: Progressive, $28/mo ($331/yr)
Indiana average: $49/mo. Auto-Owners costs $10 a month more and Allstate $55 more. This package sits under the property damage limit in the law.
Clears Indiana’s limits
50/100/50 liability with $500 deductibles
Cheapest of the three: Progressive, $99/mo ($1,193/yr)
Indiana average: $169/mo. Auto-Owners costs $69 more and Allstate $139 more. Collision and comprehensive on your own car come with it.
Widest protection
Full-coverage package: 100/300/100 liability, $500 deductibles
Cheapest of the three: Progressive, $105/mo ($1,260/yr)
Indiana average: $167/mo. Auto-Owners costs $57 more and Allstate $128 more.
Progressive has the lowest price in all 299 ZIP codes for every package, while Auto-Owners and Allstate win none. Your ZIP code never changes who is cheapest, only by how much. The narrowest gap anywhere is $10 a month on Liability Only 25/50/10, so an Auto-Owners quote is the one most likely to land near Progressive’s if liability is all you want.
Price an Indiana Policy That Clears the 25/50/25 Limits
Auto Insurance in Indiana by Company: Progressive, Auto-Owners and Allstate
Three insurers are in the Indiana ranking, and each returned a price in all 299 ZIP codes, which puts 897 prices behind every package. In the bars below, a shorter bar means a cheaper insurer. Each bar is that company’s average monthly price for the full-coverage package, same driver and same car.
Auto-Owners Insurance Co$162
Allstate$233
The chart uses the full-coverage package (100/300/100 liability, $500 deductibles). The three-insurer average is $167 a month. United Farm Bureau of Indiana is not charted; its prices are in the box higher up.
| Insurer | Full coverage | 50/100/50 | Liability Only 25/50/10 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Progressive | $105 [$1,260] | $99 [$1,193] | $28 [$331] |
| Auto-Owners Insurance Co | $162 [$1,944] | $168 [$2,019] | $38 [$454] |
| Allstate | $233 [$2,794] | $238 [$2,856] | $83 [$990] |
| Indiana average | $167 | $169 | $49 |
Stretched over twelve months, the three-insurer averages are $1,999 for full coverage, $2,023 for 50/100/50 and $592 for Liability Only 25/50/10. Allstate costs $128 a month more than Progressive on the full-coverage package, $1,534 over a year, and Auto-Owners lands in the middle at $57 above Progressive.
What a three-insurer market means for your quote
Three companies make a short comparison. Other insurers write policies in Indiana, and one we did not price could come in above or below these figures. GEICO is not in our Indiana data, so we cannot say where it would land. With so few names in the ranking, a quote from any insurer you already know is worth adding before you decide.
Three Indiana Packages Side by Side: What Each One Adds
Most of the price difference between packages is one step, the move from Liability Only 25/50/10 up to 50/100/50. Averaged across the three insurers it lifts the monthly price from $49 to $169, which is $120 a month and $1,431 a year. Two changes arrive in that one step: limits that clear Indiana’s rule, and damage coverage for your own car at a $500 deductible. We never priced a 50/100/50 policy without that damage coverage, so the jump cannot be divided between the two. Moving on to full coverage changes little. Its average of $167 is $2 a month under the 50/100/50 average of $169.
Liability only can be enough if
- You own the vehicle free and clear, and no lienholder requires damage coverage.
- Savings could absorb a repair or a replacement vehicle.
- The policy you buy still reaches 25/50/25. The liability-only package we priced does not.
Full coverage fits better if
- Your financing agreement requires collision and comprehensive.
- Paying for your own car out of pocket would hurt. Liability pays the other side; collision and comprehensive pay for yours.
- You want injury limits far above the law. Our full-coverage package uses 100/300/100.
Have each company quote both. Progressive’s full coverage costs $6 a month more than its 50/100/50 ($67 a year). At Auto-Owners the order reverses: full coverage is $6 a month cheaper ($75 a year), and at Allstate it is $5 cheaper ($62 a year). Quadrant returned those figures as shown, and one quote alone can hide the cheaper package.
Cheap Car Insurance in Indiana, County by County
Indiana has 92 counties, and our data reaches 86 of them through 299 ZIP codes. A county gets a rank once the data holds at least three of its ZIP codes, and 29 counties clear that bar. The other 57 contribute one or two ZIP codes each and get a plain list at the end of this section. A dagger (†) flags the 15 ranked counties built on just three or four ZIP codes. Every county figure is an average of the three ranked insurers.
The 29 ranked Indiana counties, lowest full-coverage average first
| County (ZIPs) | Full coverage | Liability Only 25/50/10 |
|---|---|---|
| Tippecanoe County† (4) | $148 | $46 |
| Delaware County† (4) | $149 | $46 |
| Hamilton County (10) | $149 | $50 |
| Boone County† (3) | $150 | $48 |
| Madison County (8) | $151 | $48 |
| Howard County† (3) | $153 | $48 |
| Allen County (19) | $153 | $50 |
| Johnson County (6) | $153 | $50 |
| Grant County† (4) | $154 | $44 |
| Elkhart County (8) | $155 | $47 |
| St. Joseph County (15) | $155 | $49 |
| Hancock County† (4) | $157 | $51 |
| Hendricks County (6) | $158 | $49 |
| Vanderburgh County (8) | $159 | $52 |
| Kosciusko County (6) | $159 | $45 |
| Morgan County† (3) | $161 | $50 |
| Warrick County† (3) | $161 | $49 |
| Monroe County (6) | $161 | $47 |
| Clark County† (4) | $163 | $54 |
| La Porte County† (4) | $163 | $48 |
| Noble County† (3) | $164 | $44 |
| Porter County (5) | $164 | $53 |
| LaGrange County† (4) | $167 | $44 |
| Marion County (35) | $168 | $54 |
| Floyd County† (4) | $169 | $53 |
| Vigo County (6) | $173 | $48 |
| Jasper County† (3) | $175 | $47 |
| Dearborn County† (3) | $177 | $46 |
| Lake County (25) | $221 | $62 |
| Indiana (299) | $167 | $49 |
† The county has just three or four ZIP codes in the data, so treat its figures as a rough read.
Tippecanoe County† posts the lowest full-coverage average among ranked counties, $148 a month ($1,775 a year) on 4 ZIP codes. Delaware County† and Hamilton County both round to $149. Restrict the view to counties with at least five priced ZIP codes and Hamilton County leads at $149 on 10. Lake County is the priciest at $221 ($2,651) on 25 ZIP codes, $73 a month and $876 a year above Tippecanoe County.
Lake stands alone. The other 28 ranked counties fall inside a $29-a-month band, from Tippecanoe County† at $148 up to Dearborn County† at $177, while Lake County sits $44 above Dearborn. It also tops the other packages, at $224 for 50/100/50 and $62 for Liability Only 25/50/10. On Liability Only 25/50/10, LaGrange County†, Noble County† and Grant County† round to the same lowest figure, $44 a month, with Kosciusko County next at $45.
Indianapolis and Marion County
Marion County, home of Indianapolis, supplies 35 of our 299 ZIP codes, more than any other county, and averages $168 a month for full coverage, a dollar over the Indiana average of $167. Liability only is where it looks pricier. Marion’s Liability Only 25/50/10 average of $54 trails only Lake County’s $62 and sits above the Indiana average of $49, while its 50/100/50 average of $169 matches the state’s. None of its ZIP codes makes the cheapest ten for full coverage, 50/100/50 or Liability Only 25/50/10.
Hamilton County and the suburbs around Indianapolis
The state’s lowest full-coverage ZIP codes cluster just north of Marion County. Hamilton County holds 5 of the cheapest ten: Carmel (46032 and 46033), Noblesville (46062 and 46060) and Westfield (46074). Lebanon, in Boone County (46052), ranks fourth. Carmel’s 46032 is the lowest in Indiana at $143 a month. Johnson County averages $153 and Hendricks County $158.
Northwest Indiana: Lake County, Gary and East Chicago
Every one of the highest-priced ZIP codes in the data sits in Lake County. For full coverage the top three are 46402 in Gary at $293 a month, 46409 in Gary at $289 and 46312 in East Chicago at $285. For Liability Only 25/50/10 all three leaders are in Gary, led by 46402 at $71. Two counties along the same lakeshore price near the state average instead: Porter County averages $164 and La Porte County† $163 for full coverage.
Fort Wayne, South Bend and the northern tier
Allen County, home of Fort Wayne, averages $153 a month on 19 ZIP codes, and Fort Wayne’s 46835 comes in at $148, thirteenth lowest of 299 for full coverage. St. Joseph County, home of South Bend, and Elkhart County each average $155, on 15 and 8 ZIP codes. Granger’s 46530, in St. Joseph County, is $149. All three counties average less than the state’s $167: by $14 for Allen and $12 for the other two.
Evansville, Lafayette and Muncie
Vanderburgh County, home of Evansville, averages $159 a month for full coverage and $52 for Liability Only 25/50/10, on 8 ZIP codes. Lafayette’s 47904 ($146) and Muncie’s 47304 ($146) rank fifth and sixth in the state for full coverage, and Tippecanoe and Delaware counties, four ZIP codes each, are the two lowest-priced counties we ranked.
The 57 Indiana counties we did not rank
Each entry below gives a county’s average monthly full-coverage price, followed in parentheses by the ZIP codes that feed it. That is too thin a base to rank a county or to call it cheapest or priciest. Still, the spread is informative: the highest, Orange County at $185, is $36 under Lake County, and the lowest, Clinton County at $148, equals Tippecanoe County†, the lowest ranked county. For your own address, enter your ZIP code in a quote rather than leaning on a county number.
Adams (2) $150; Bartholomew (2) $159; Blackford (1) $154; Brown (2) $168; Carroll (1) $166; Cass (1) $168; Clay (1) $175; Clinton (1) $148; Daviess (2) $170; Decatur (1) $154; DeKalb (2) $159; Dubois (2) $160; Fayette (1) $159; Fountain (2) $168; Franklin (2) $174; Fulton (1) $168; Gibson (1) $165; Greene (2) $176; Harrison (1) $179; Henry (2) $152; Huntington (2) $155; Jackson (2) $170; Jay (1) $156; Jefferson (2) $178; Jennings (1) $170; Knox (1) $165; Lawrence (2) $177; Marshall (2) $164; Martin (1) $168; Miami (1) $165; Montgomery (1) $158; Ohio (1) $183; Orange (2) $185; Owen (1) $172; Parke (1) $184; Perry (1) $171; Pike (1) $168; Posey (1) $163; Pulaski (1) $176; Putnam (2) $174; Randolph (1) $150; Ripley (2) $179; Rush (1) $153; Scott (2) $177; Shelby (1) $150; Spencer (1) $167; Starke (2) $181; Steuben (2) $170; Sullivan (1) $182; Tipton (1) $148; Vermillion (1) $180; Wabash (2) $168; Washington (2) $181; Wayne (2) $149; Wells (2) $152; White (1) $174; Whitley (2) $157.
Cheapest and priciest Indiana ZIP codes
The ZIP tables use the average of the three ranked insurers for each ZIP code, which runs above Progressive’s own price. Progressive’s full-coverage price spans $82 a month in its cheapest ZIP code to $144 in its dearest, a $62 range, while the three-insurer average swings $150 between Carmel’s 46032 and Gary’s 46402. On average, then, the other two insurers’ prices move with the map more than Progressive’s do.
| ZIP code and city | County | Per month | Per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| 46032 Carmel | Hamilton County | $143 | $1,721 |
| 46062 Noblesville | Hamilton County | $144 | $1,730 |
| 46033 Carmel | Hamilton County | $145 | $1,745 |
| 46052 Lebanon | Boone County | $146 | $1,746 |
| 47304 Muncie | Delaware County | $146 | $1,749 |
| 47904 Lafayette | Tippecanoe County | $146 | $1,750 |
| 46074 Westfield | Hamilton County | $147 | $1,765 |
| 47909 Lafayette | Tippecanoe County | $147 | $1,766 |
| 47302 Muncie | Delaware County | $148 | $1,771 |
| 46060 Noblesville | Hamilton County | $148 | $1,772 |
| Dearest three | 46402 Gary, $293/mo ($3,510/yr); 46409 Gary, $289/mo ($3,464/yr); 46312 East Chicago, $285/mo ($3,418/yr) | ||
| ZIP code and city | County | Per month | Per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| 46737 Fremont | Steuben County | $42 | $503 |
| 47558 Montgomery | Daviess County | $42 | $505 |
| 47932 Covington | Fountain County | $42 | $505 |
| 47006 Batesville | Franklin County | $42 | $508 |
| 46703 Angola | Steuben County | $42 | $509 |
| 47240 Greensburg | Decatur County | $43 | $510 |
| 47371 Portland | Jay County | $43 | $510 |
| 47553 Loogootee | Martin County | $43 | $510 |
| 47567 Petersburg | Pike County | $43 | $510 |
| 46711 Berne | Adams County | $43 | $511 |
| Dearest three | 46402 Gary, $71/mo ($857/yr); 46409 Gary, $71/mo ($857/yr); 46407 Gary, $71/mo ($854/yr) | ||
Which ZIP code is cheapest depends on the package. The lowest full-coverage and 50/100/50 ZIP codes gather around Carmel, Noblesville, Lebanon, Muncie and Lafayette. The cheapest ten for Liability Only 25/50/10 are scattered over 9 counties and are mostly small towns, led by Fremont’s 46737 in Steuben County at $42 a month. Carmel’s 46032, first for full coverage and for 50/100/50, is only 208th lowest of 299 on Liability Only 25/50/10.
At the other extreme, Gary’s 46402 heads every list. Its full-coverage average is $293 a month ($3,510 a year), $126 over the Indiana average and $150 over Carmel’s 46032, with the driver, car and coverage held constant.
Get Indiana Car Insurance Quotes for Your ZIP Code
Indiana’s Liability Limits in Plain Words
Think of 25/50/25 as three caps on payouts: each injured person is capped at $25,000, everyone hurt in one crash shares a $50,000 cap, and the property you damage is capped at $25,000. Neither your own vehicle nor your own medical bills fall under any of them. The uninsured and underinsured motorist rule described above sits on top, and nothing on this page prices a rejection of that coverage, so check what each real quote carries for it.
| Company | Per month | Per year |
|---|---|---|
| Progressive | $99 | $1,193 |
| Auto-Owners Insurance Co | $168 | $2,019 |
| Allstate | $238 | $2,856 |
| Indiana average | $169 | $2,023 |
Full coverage clears all three limits as well, but no priced option at or above the law costs less than Progressive’s $99. A policy at exactly 25/50/25 would shed the collision and comprehensive coverage that comes with 50/100/50; if that is the policy you want, name it when you request quotes.
7 Ways to Lower Your Indiana Car Insurance Bill
- Quote Progressive and Auto-Owners together. Progressive leads in all 299 ZIP codes, but its lead ranges from $10 a month on Liability Only 25/50/10 to $69 on 50/100/50.
- Buy the package that meets the law, not the smallest number. The $28 Liability Only 25/50/10 price stops short on property damage, whereas Progressive’s 50/100/50 package costs $99.
- Get 50/100/50 and full coverage priced together. Progressive charges $6 a month extra for full coverage; Auto-Owners charges $6 less.
- Use the garaging ZIP code. The three-insurer average moves $150 a month between Carmel and Gary. Enter the ZIP code where the car is garaged at night rather than an employer’s or a relative’s.
- In Lake County, price every company. The county averages $221 for full coverage, $54 above the Indiana average, and statewide Allstate’s full-coverage price runs $128 a month over Progressive’s.
- Ask what each quote carries for uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage. Indiana builds it into new liability policies unless you reject it in writing.
- Raise the discounts question with every company. A higher collision and comprehensive deductible, a bundled policy or paying annually may change a quote. We priced $500 deductibles.
Car Insurance Indiana Quotes: What to Match Before You Compare
The prices above fit a single modeled driver. A real quote moves with your car, your driving record, who else lives in the household and where the car is kept overnight. A few habits keep several quotes on equal footing:
- Give every company identical liability limits, 25/50/25 or higher.
- Settle on one collision and comprehensive deductible and ask for it everywhere.
- Find out what every quote includes for uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage.
- Enter drivers, vehicle and garaging address identically on every form.
- Look at packages before prices: a $28 Liability Only 25/50/10 quote drops collision and comprehensive and carries $10,000 of property damage, while a $99 50/100/50 quote carries $50,000.
Line Up Indiana Quotes With Identical Limits and Deductibles
How We Priced Indiana Car Insurance
Quadrant Information Services is the source of every price. It applies each insurer’s filed rate tables and rating rules to one defined driver and vehicle and returns the premium; we compare and average the Indiana results. The rate date is Sept. 30, 2026.
- Driver profile: one 40-year-old man who is single, with 24 years behind the wheel, good credit and no accidents or violations. Vehicle: a 2024 Toyota Camry LE he owns, used for personal driving only. He is the sole driver, so teen, added and occasional drivers are not priced.
- Coverage packages: Liability Only 25/50/10 omits damage coverage for the driver’s own car. The 50/100/50 package pairs $50,000 and $100,000 injury caps with a $50,000 property cap, and collision and comprehensive each carry a $500 deductible. Full coverage moves liability to 100/300/100 and leaves the deductibles alone. Our packages were built without medical payments or personal injury protection coverage, so the prices exclude both. Indiana’s liability limits are 25/50/25, which puts Liability Only 25/50/10 short on property damage and 50/100/50 at or above every limit.
- The sample: 299 Indiana ZIP codes across 86 counties. Each of the three ranked insurers has a price in every one of them, which gives 897 prices behind each package.
- The math: Where Quadrant gives an insurer two prices for the same ZIP code, the lower one is used. State, county and ZIP figures weight the three insurers equally. A monthly figure is the annual premium over 12, rounded to whole dollars, and gaps between monthly figures use the rounded values.
- The naming rule: an insurer needs a price in at least half the state’s ZIP codes to be named. Farm Bureau companies and insurers restricted to certain customers are never named, and an insurer priced close to the lowest, a few dollars a month away, is named alongside it. In Indiana nobody is that close to Progressive, so each package has one named company.
- The exclusion: United Farm Bureau of IN Group, the name Quadrant uses, which is priced in all 299 ZIP codes. As a Farm Bureau company it appears only in its own box, not in rankings, averages or the county and ZIP tables. Nothing else was dropped, whether insurer, ZIP code or county. The 57 unranked counties still count toward the statewide averages.
- A thin market: three ranked insurers is a short list. Other companies sell car insurance in Indiana, and GEICO is not in our Indiana data.
A single modeled driver cannot predict your own price. Your address, car, record, coverage and discounts decide that.
Cities in Indiana
Average monthly price for full coverage in each Indiana city we cover, compared with the Indiana average of $167 a month. Prices use the same Quadrant Information Services rates (as of Sept. 30, 2026) as the rest of this page.
- Evansville car insurance: $159 a month, $8 less than the Indiana average
Compare nearby states
Average monthly price for full coverage in nearby states, compared with the Indiana average of $167 a month. Same Quadrant Information Services rates (as of Sept. 30, 2026).
- Ohio: $137 a month, $30 less than the Indiana average
- Illinois: $200 a month, $33 more than the Indiana average
- Kentucky car insurance: $225 a month, $58 more than the Indiana average
- Michigan rates: $361 a month, $194 more than the Indiana average
See prices for every state: Cheap Car Insurance by State.
Indiana Car Insurance FAQ: Prices, Limits and Rates
Is $200 a month a lot for car insurance in Indiana?
For our sample driver, $200 a month is more than the cheapest full-coverage price in every Indiana ZIP code we priced: among the three insurers we compared, the lowest full-coverage price is under $200 a month in 299 of 299 ZIP codes and under $150 in 299 of 299. That lowest price is Progressive’s and ranges from $82 to $144 a month by ZIP code. The three-insurer average is $167, so $200 is $33 above it, though Allstate’s $233 average is higher than $200. Those lowest prices show the cheapest option in a given ZIP code among the compared insurers, not the typical bill.
Who has the cheapest car insurance in Indiana right now?
Progressive, among the three insurers we compared, at all three coverage levels, using rates as of Sept. 30, 2026: $105 a month for full coverage, $99 for 50/100/50 and $28 for Liability Only 25/50/10. Auto-Owners Insurance Co is next at $162, $168 and $38. Progressive has the lowest price in all 299 ZIP codes at every level. United Farm Bureau of Indiana is priced but shown separately.
Which is cheaper in Indiana, Progressive or Auto-Owners?
Progressive, at every level and in every ZIP code we priced. For full coverage Progressive is $105 a month and Auto-Owners $162, a $57 gap. At 50/100/50 it is $99 against $168 ($69), and for Liability Only 25/50/10 $28 against $38 ($10). Progressive wins 299 of 299 ZIP codes at each level, Auto-Owners none. These are the two cheapest insurers we priced; GEICO is not in our Indiana data.
Why is car insurance so expensive in Indiana?
In our data the three-insurer average for full coverage is $167 a month, $62 above Progressive’s $105, and Allstate’s $233 pulls that average up. Place adds to it in Lake County, which averages $221 a month, and in Gary’s 46402 at $293, $150 above Carmel’s 46032. On the legal side, Indiana’s liability limits are 25/50/25, and new liability policies must include uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage unless you reject it in writing. We do not guess at causes.
What is the minimum car insurance required in Indiana?
Indiana’s liability limits are 25/50/25, according to the Indiana BMV: a $25,000 cap per injured person, a $50,000 cap across all injuries from one crash and a $25,000 cap for property damage. The Indiana Department of Insurance adds that each newly written auto liability policy must include uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage unless you reject it in writing. The liability-only package we priced carries just $10,000 of property damage, so it falls below the law; 50/100/50 is at or above all three limits.
How much does car insurance cost in Indiana?
Averaging Progressive, Auto-Owners Insurance Co and Allstate, our sample driver pays $167 a month ($1,999 a year) for full coverage and $169 for 50/100/50, while Liability Only 25/50/10 averages $49. The lowest price we found is Progressive’s $105 a month for full coverage. The rates date from Sept. 30, 2026, and your own quote will differ with your vehicle, history and address.
What is the average cost of car insurance in Indiana?
In our data the average cost of car insurance in Indiana is $167 a month, or $1,999 a year, for the full-coverage package of 100/300/100 liability with $500 deductibles. Liability Only 25/50/10 averages $49 ($592) and the 50/100/50 package $169 ($2,023). Each average blends three insurers: Progressive is $62 a month below the full-coverage average and Allstate $66 above it.
How much is full coverage car insurance in Indiana?
The full-coverage package is 100/300/100 liability plus $500 deductibles on collision and comprehensive. Progressive is cheapest at $105 a month ($1,260 a year), Auto-Owners is $162 ($1,944) and Allstate $233 ($2,794). The three-insurer average is $167 a month. These prices do not include personal injury protection or medical payments coverage.
Does 50/100/50 meet Indiana’s liability limits?
Yes. Indiana’s limits are 25/50/25, and 50/100/50 sits above them: 50/100 for injuries against 25/50, and property damage of $50,000 versus the law’s $25,000. Progressive has the lowest 50/100/50 price at $99 a month ($1,193 a year), with Auto-Owners at $168 and Allstate at $238. Full coverage costs $6 a month more than 50/100/50 at Progressive and $6 less at Auto-Owners.
What is United Farm Bureau of Indiana’s price, and why is it shown separately?
United Farm Bureau of IN Group is a Farm Bureau company, and Farm Bureau companies never enter our rankings, averages or county and ZIP tables. We print its prices so nothing is hidden: $220 a month for full coverage, $213 for 50/100/50 and $48 for Liability Only 25/50/10, priced in all 299 ZIP codes. None of those figures undercuts the cheapest insurer named for the same package.
Why does the Liability Only 25/50/10 package fall short of Indiana’s limits?
We took that package from Quadrant’s liability-only tier for Indiana. Its 25/50 injury limits match the law, but its $10,000 of property damage is under the $25,000 in Indiana’s 25/50/25 limits. Progressive’s $28 price shows what a barebones package costs for our driver, and it is not a policy that clears Indiana’s limits. The lowest price we found for one that does is Progressive’s 50/100/50, at $99 a month.
Where do I find the cheapest car insurance quotes for Indiana?
Among the three insurers we compared, Progressive gives the cheapest Indiana price at every level: $105 a month for full coverage, $99 for 50/100/50 and $28 for Liability Only 25/50/10, with $162, $168 and $38 at Auto-Owners Insurance Co. The quote boxes on this page start a real request; ask each company for identical limits and deductibles so the answers compare cleanly.
How do I get an Indiana car insurance quote?
Type your ZIP code into a quote box above, or call insurers yourself. Ask for matching liability limits (25/50/25 or higher), a single deductible choice and an identical driver and car on each request. Progressive led all 299 ZIP codes we priced, so it belongs in every comparison, and Auto-Owners Insurance Co is the other insurer worth pricing.
Is liability coverage full coverage in Indiana?
No. In Indiana, liability only answers for the crash damage you cause somebody else; your own car’s repairs fall under collision and comprehensive, so Triple-I (the Insurance Information Institute) uses “full coverage” as everyday shorthand for all three together. Priced for our driver, Liability Only 25/50/10 is $28 a month at Progressive, $49 across the three insurers, and full coverage is $105 and $167 on those same measures.
Does credit score affect car insurance in Indiana?
Yes, with restrictions. Under IC 27-2-21, an Indiana insurer cannot deny or cancel a policy solely on credit, and renewal rates cannot rest solely on credit. Having no credit history cannot be the basis for a higher rate, and scores are refreshed every 36 months. The rule is outlined in the NAIC model-law chart on credit scoring.
What happens if you drive without insurance in Indiana?
The Indiana BMV can suspend your driving privileges and impose financial penalties; its page gives no dollar amounts. The BMV checks coverage electronically through insurer-filed Certificates of Compliance and may ask for proof after a crash or a pointable violation. If it has no proof within 90 days of its request, your privileges are suspended. See the Indiana BMV.
When does Indiana require an SR22?
The Indiana BMV may require an SR22 after court-related offenses or insurance violations. For an insurance-related suspension it must be kept for 180 consecutive days, and in other cases the period may be 3 or 5 years. The BMV page does not state fees. Details are on the Indiana BMV proof of financial responsibility page.
