Cheap Car Insurance in New Haven, CT

GEICO is cheapest of the 3 insurers we compared in New Haven: $190/mo full coverage, $73 liability only. 4 ZIPs priced (Sept. 2026 rates).

The cheapest car insurance in New Haven, CT comes from GEICO at all three coverage levels we priced, among the 3 insurers we compared, starting at $190 a month for full coverage. Allstate follows at $325 and Progressive at $354. GEICO’s Liability Only 20/40/10 price is $73 a month, but those limits sit under Connecticut’s 25/50/25 rule.

How much is car insurance in New Haven? The three-insurer mean is $290 a month ($3,474 a year) for full coverage, $67 above Connecticut’s $223. What stands out here is the reach of one company: GEICO is lowest in all 4 ZIP codes at every level, $135 a month under Allstate on full coverage, and three of the 4 ZIP codes carry exactly the same prices.

Small sample: 26 ZIP codes list New Haven as their USPS primary city and only 4 of them (06511, 06513, 06515 and 06519) have prices in our Connecticut data. Every figure below describes those 4 ZIP codes and nothing wider. Page updated Nov. 18, 2026. Rates date from Sept. 30, 2026 and come from Quadrant Information Services; each price is for one modeled driver, which makes them benchmarks, not quotes. Our New Haven method

Cheap Car Insurance in New Haven: GEICO Leads at Every Level

Lowest New Haven prices across three insurers

Top package: full coverage with 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles

GEICO

$190/mo

$2,276 a year. Next: Allstate, $325.

50/100/50 limits, $500 deductibles

GEICO

$185/mo

$2,217 a year. Next: Allstate, $306.

Liability Only 20/40/10

GEICO

$73/mo

$873 a year. Next: Allstate, $137.

Below Connecticut’s 25/50/25 rule

Why GEICO stands alone: its lead over the next company is $64 to $135 a month depending on the level, far more than the few dollars that would make us name a second company. GEICO is also the lowest price in 4 of 4 ZIP codes at each level.

Amica is shown, not ranked: Quadrant’s status for every Amica price in Connecticut is NotAcceptable, with a prior-insurance condition attached. We cannot show our sample driver clears it, so Amica gets a row without a rank and stays out of the averages; the reasoning is below.

Average Car Insurance Cost in New Haven vs. Connecticut

New Haven’s 4 priced ZIP codes run above the Connecticut average at every coverage level. Connecticut’s numbers average the same three insurers over all 184 ZIP codes we priced in the state.

Average monthly price across the three insurers in New Haven and in Connecticut, yearly total in brackets
Coverage New Haven Connecticut New Haven is higher by
Full coverage $290 [$3,474] $223 [$2,670] $67
50/100/50 $272 [$3,262] $212 [$2,542] $60
Liability Only 20/40/10 $121 [$1,456] $90 [$1,077] $31

The three companies are not affected equally. At full coverage GEICO is $40 a month above its Connecticut average, Allstate $60 above and Progressive $101 above. That is why the order below GEICO changes: statewide, Progressive ($253) is second to GEICO ($150) and Allstate ($265) third; in New Haven Allstate ($325) is second and Progressive ($354) third.

Connecticut’s 25/50/25 Rule and the 20/40/10 Tier We Priced

GEICO’s $73 Liability Only price does not buy a policy that meets Connecticut’s rule

Our bare-liability package carries 20/40/10 limits. Connecticut requires 25/50/25 plus uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage of 25/50, so a policy that satisfies the law carries higher limits and would not cost exactly $73. Ask for 25/50/25 or more when you compare New Haven quotes.

Every line of the Liability Only tier falls short of the rule: injury limits by $5,000 and $10,000, property damage by $15,000, and uninsured motorist limits of 20/40 against 25/50. The 20/40/10 mix was Connecticut’s requirement until Jan. 1, 2018.

Limits in the Liability Only tier we priced, set against the Connecticut rule
Limit Tier we priced (20/40/10) Connecticut rule (25/50/25)
Injury cover, one person $20,000 $25,000
Injury cover, whole crash $40,000 $50,000
Damage to others’ property $10,000 $25,000
Cover if the other driver is uninsured or underinsured, one person / whole crash $20,000 / $40,000 $25,000 / $50,000
Origin Quadrant State rule

Where the rule is published: Insurance Department Bulletin PC-86 and the department’s auto insurance page.

The liability limits of our 50/100/50 package are above 25/50/25 on all three lines, so it is the lowest-priced of our packages whose liability limits meet or exceed the rule. At GEICO that is $185 a month in New Haven; at Allstate $306; at Progressive $325. We still price Liability Only 20/40/10 to show what bare liability costs, and we label it that way everywhere.

Car Insurance Quotes in New Haven: The Cheapest Company at Each Level

One name, three times. GEICO is lowest for full coverage ($190), for 50/100/50 ($185) and for Liability Only 20/40/10 ($73). The distance to second place is $135, $121 and $64 a month, and to Progressive $164, $140 and $82. Because no company is within a few dollars a month of GEICO, nobody shares the name with it at any level.

Lowest monthly price by coverage level in New HavenBar chart of the lowest monthly price among the three insurers at each coverage level in New Haven. Liability Only 20/40/10 GEICO $73; 50/100/50 GEICO $185; Full coverage 100/300/100 GEICO $190.Liability Only 20/40/10$7350/100/50$185Full coverage 100/300/100$190
The lowest-priced insurer in New Haven at each of three coverage levels, shown for a single sample driver on Sept. 30, 2026 rates.
What the lowest-priced New Haven insurer charges at each level, beside the mean of all three
Coverage level Lowest-priced insurer Price a month Three-insurer mean
Liability Only 20/40/10 GEICO $73 $121
50/100/50 GEICO $185 $272
Full coverage 100/300/100 GEICO $190 $290

Compare New Haven Car Insurance Quotes by ZIP Code

Please provide a valid zip code.

Car Insurance New Haven CT: Prices by Company

All three insurers were priced in all 4 ZIP codes. Each row is that company’s New Haven average, cheapest first.

Monthly full-coverage price by insurer in New Haven, lowest firstBar chart of New Haven full-coverage monthly prices, lowest first. GEICO $190, Allstate $325, Progressive $354.GEICO$190Allstate$325Progressive$354
Each bar is one insurer’s New Haven average for full coverage (100/300/100 liability, $500 deductibles); a longer bar means a higher bill. The three-insurer mean is $290 a month.
What each company charges in New Haven per month, with the yearly figure in brackets; the last column is the 20/40/10 tier; the Amica row is unranked and outside the average
Company Full 50/100/50 Liability only
GEICO $190 [$2,276] $185 [$2,217] $73 [$873]
Allstate $325 [$3,898] $306 [$3,673] $137 [$1,640]
Progressive $354 [$4,249] $325 [$3,897] $155 [$1,855]
Amica (unranked; excluded from the average, see the Amica note below) $335 [$4,024] $334 [$4,009] $119 [$1,433]
City average, three ranked insurers $290 $272 $121

Allstate second, Progressive third

Allstate is the second-cheapest at every level, and it is cheaper than Progressive in all 4 ZIP codes at every level. The margin is $29 a month at full coverage, $19 at 50/100/50 and $18 for Liability Only 20/40/10. Statewide it is the other way round, with Progressive second.

How we handled Amica in New Haven

All 4 New Haven ZIP codes returned an Amica price, as did the other Connecticut ZIP codes we priced (184 in all). Each one carries Quadrant’s NotAcceptable status and a remark about prior insurance: three or more years insured and a prior liability limit of 1/300 or better. The sample driver has 24 years of continuous insurance, which covers the first half. The second half is where our request cannot prove anything: we set the prior liability limit to match each package, so it reads 100/300 for full coverage, 50/100 for 50/100/50 and 20/40 for the Liability Only tier. Because Quadrant still reports NotAcceptable on every row, we do not treat Amica as available to the driver we modeled. Amica therefore sits in the company table without a rank and is excluded from every average, ranking, cheapest-company statement, ZIP pick and chart. In New Haven its prices run $335 a month ($4,024 a year) at full coverage, $334 ($4,009) at 50/100/50 and $119 ($1,433) for Liability Only 20/40/10. Someone with long continuous coverage at high limits can ask Amica for a quote of their own.

Car Insurance in New Haven, CT by ZIP Code: Three Priced Alike, One Cheaper

The 4 ZIP codes fall into two groups. 06511, 06515, and 06519 carry identical prices from all three insurers at every coverage level. The fourth, 06513, is cheaper for every company at every level. That is why these figures read as a small-sample snapshot.

Full-coverage monthly price in each priced New Haven ZIP code, by insurer (any other names USPS lists follow the dash)
ZIP code and city GEICO Allstate Progressive
06511 – Hamden $194 $347 $361
06513 – East Haven, Fair Haven, North Haven $177 $260 $333
06515 – North Haven, Westville $194 $347 $361
06519 – North Haven $194 $347 $361
All 4 ZIP codes $190 $325 $354

In 06513 the gap to the other three ZIP codes is $17 a month for GEICO, $28 for Progressive and $87 for Allstate. So where you park changes the Allstate bill roughly five times as much as the GEICO bill, and GEICO is still the lowest in every ZIP code.

GEICO monthly price by New Haven ZIP code and coverage level
ZIP code and city Full 50/100/50 Liability only
06511 – Hamden $194 $189 $74
06513 – East Haven, Fair Haven, North Haven $177 $173 $70
06515 – North Haven, Westville $194 $189 $74
06519 – North Haven $194 $189 $74
All 4 ZIP codes $190 $185 $73

Labels USPS attaches to these ZIP codes

USPS lists other place names for these ZIP codes. 06513 also covers addresses labeled East Haven, Fair Haven, and North Haven. 06511 adds Hamden; 06515 adds North Haven and Westville; 06519 adds North Haven. A label shows which addresses a ZIP code carries, not where a boundary falls; the prices describe the ZIP codes.

Where a full-coverage price falls under $200 a month

Pick the lowest company in each ZIP code and all 4 ZIP codes come in below $200 a month for full coverage: $194 in 06511, 06515 and 06519, $177 in 06513. None reaches $150. GEICO supplies that lowest price in every ZIP code; the next company down charges $260 to $347, and the three-insurer city average is $290.

New Haven ZIP Code Prices: The Cheapest Insurer in Each One

Type a ZIP code or a nearby name such as Hamden or Westville into the search box over either table to filter it. The two tables between them cover all 4 New Haven ZIP codes we priced; each row gives the cheapest of our three insurers there and what it charges a month for the sample driver. Amica is shown unranked in the insurer table and is not part of these picks.

GEICO is the lowest-priced insurer in all 4 ZIP codes for full coverage and in all 4 for Liability Only 20/40/10.

New Haven ZIP code spread, full coverage per monthBar chart. The cheapest New Haven ZIP code, 06513 (New Haven, also East Haven, Fair Haven, North Haven), averages $257 a month for full coverage. The New Haven average across 4 ZIP codes is $290. The priciest, 06511 (New Haven, also Hamden), is $301.Cheapest ZIP (06513)$257New Haven average$290Priciest ZIP (06511)$301
The two outer bars are single ZIP codes, the middle bar is the whole city, and every bar is the three-insurer full-coverage mean.
Where New Haven sits on full coverage: lowest ZIP code, city mean and highest ZIP code, all three insurers
Position Place Monthly Annual
Lowest ZIP code 06513, New Haven, also East Haven, Fair Haven, North Haven $257 $3,080
New Haven average, 4 ZIP codes All New Haven $290 $3,474
Highest ZIP code 06511, New Haven, also Hamden $301 $3,606

Both tables use Quadrant rates dated Sept. 30, 2026 for one modeled driver, as described under How We Priced New Haven Car Insurance. The Place column adds any other USPS name a ZIP code carries (New Haven, also, then the label); those are mailing names, not city limits. Only the 4 ZIP codes Quadrant priced are listed: 22 more ZIP codes name New Haven as their primary city but have no price in our Connecticut data. Every row draws on GEICO, Allstate and Progressive. Amica is priced too but unranked and outside every pick on this page (see the Amica note above). No PIP amount was part of our request, and Connecticut does not require PIP. A price you are quoted will differ.

Full coverage in each ZIP code

ZIP codePlaceCheapest insurerLowest monthly price
06511New Haven, also HamdenGEICO$194/mo
06513New Haven, also East Haven, Fair Haven, North HavenGEICO$177/mo
06515New Haven, also North Haven, WestvilleGEICO$194/mo
06519New Haven, also North HavenGEICO$194/mo

Liability Only 20/40/10 in each ZIP code (below Connecticut’s 25/50/25 rule)

ZIP codePlaceCheapest insurerLowest monthly price
06511New Haven, also HamdenGEICO$74/mo
06513New Haven, also East Haven, Fair Haven, North HavenGEICO$70/mo
06515New Haven, also North Haven, WestvilleGEICO$74/mo
06519New Haven, also North HavenGEICO$74/mo

See What GEICO, Allstate and Progressive Charge at Your New Haven Address

Please provide a valid zip code.

Liability Only, 50/100/50 or Full Coverage in New Haven

The big step is the first one. In the city average, moving from Liability Only 20/40/10 ($121) to 50/100/50 ($272) adds $151 a month, because 50/100/50 also brings collision and comprehensive with $500 deductibles and higher liability limits. The final step, up to full coverage, adds just $18.

Company by company the steps are $112 then $5 at GEICO, $169 then $19 at Allstate, and $170 then $29 at Progressive. At GEICO full coverage costs $5 a month more than 50/100/50 in New Haven, while across Connecticut its two prices are both $150.

Bare liability suits a car that is old, owned outright and replaceable from savings, but the 20/40/10 package does not meet Connecticut’s rule, so price 25/50/25 or more; GEICO’s $185 for 50/100/50 shows the scale. Lenders and lessors usually ask for collision and comprehensive, and full coverage here also lifts liability to 100/300/100. Liability only pays other people’s losses and nothing for your own car.

What Connecticut Law Requires of New Haven Drivers

  • Liability: every policy carries injury cover of $25,000 for each person, a crash-wide ceiling of $50,000, and $25,000 for damaged property. The standard took effect Jan. 1, 2018 (see Bulletin PC-86 from the Insurance Department).
  • Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage: 25/50 at a minimum ($25,000 a person, $50,000 a crash), set equal to your liability limits unless you request lower ones in writing and sign a consent form (Bulletin PC-65).
  • PIP: not required. Connecticut’s no-fault system ended Jan. 1, 1994 (Connecticut Insurance Department).
  • Lapses: a lapse longer than 14 days prompts the Connecticut DMV to mail a registration suspension notice and bill a $200 fine.

Why Prices Run High or Low in New Haven

Quadrant gives us prices, not causes. The Connecticut items below are context only, and none of them accounts for a figure in our tables.

  • Teen drivers: a Connecticut driver under 18 works under a graduated license. For the first six months passengers are limited to a driving instructor, a parent or another qualified trainer, and after that siblings may ride too. Night driving between 11 p.m. and 5 a.m. is barred unless the trip is for work, school, a religious activity or a medical reason, and the teen may not use a cell phone at all, hands-free included.
  • Drivers 60 and older: Connecticut law makes insurers discount the premium, by at least 5 percent, for a driver aged 60 or over who completes an approved safe-driving course. Our sample driver is 40, so no such discount sits inside any New Haven price here.
  • Uninsured drivers: about 11.8 percent of Connecticut drivers were uninsured in 2023, according to the Insurance Research Council’s 2025 study as republished by Triple-I. The figure is derived from uninsured-motorist claims and speaks for the whole state, not for New Haven.
  • Your ZIP code: inside New Haven the three-insurer full-coverage mean is $257 a month in 06513 and $301 in 06511, 06515 and 06519, a spread of $44 a month.
Connecticut background items, with the New Haven ZIP code spread added
Item What the source says Year Link
Teen driver licensing rules Under 18: first 6 months passengers limited to instructor, parent or qualified trainer, then siblings too; no driving 11 p.m.-5 a.m. (work, school, religious, medical exceptions); no cell use incl. hands-free Current Connecticut DMV
Mature driver discount Connecticut statute requires an insurer discount (at least 5 percent) for drivers 60+ who complete an approved course Current Connecticut General Assembly, chapter 701
Drivers without insurance 11.8 percent (study figure, derived from uninsured-motorist claims) 2023 IRC 2025 uninsured motorist study, as summarized by Triple-I

Sources: Connecticut DMV, Driver restrictions for teens; Connecticut General Assembly, chapter 701, Chapter 701 of the Connecticut General Statutes; IRC 2025 uninsured motorist study, as summarized by Triple-I, Uninsured motorists. Checked 2026-11-18.

Six Ways to Lower Your New Haven Car Insurance Bill

  1. Quote GEICO first. It was lowest in all 4 ZIP codes at all three levels, $83 to $153 a month under the next company at full coverage depending on the ZIP code.
  2. Get Allstate before Progressive. In New Haven Allstate is the cheaper of the two at every level, the reverse of the state average at full coverage.
  3. Enter the ZIP code where the car sleeps. 06513 costs less than 06511, 06515, and 06519 with every company, by $17 to $87 a month at full coverage.
  4. Hold every quote to 25/50/25 or more. A quote at 20/40/10 can look lower than the rest while still falling short of Connecticut’s rule.
  5. Price 50/100/50 against full coverage. In New Haven the two differ by $5 a month at GEICO, $19 at Allstate and $29 at Progressive.
  6. Keep coverage continuous. A gap of more than 14 days brings a DMV suspension notice and a $200 fine, so line up the start date of the new policy with the end of the old one.

Connecticut’s insurance regulator also publishes a consumer guide: the auto insurance guide from the Connecticut Insurance Department.

Getting New Haven Quotes You Can Compare

Our modeled driver is not you, so two quotes only line up when these inputs are identical:

  • Liability limits, at 25/50/25 or above.
  • Uninsured and underinsured motorist limits.
  • Collision and comprehensive deductibles.
  • The drivers and vehicles listed.
  • The garaging ZIP code, since neighboring New Haven ZIP codes can price differently.
  • The full-year cost, not just the monthly payment.

Start Your New Haven Car Insurance Quote

Please provide a valid zip code.

New Haven vs. the Connecticut Cheapest: GEICO $190 Here, $150 Statewide

GEICO is the cheapest name on both maps. Our cheap car insurance in Connecticut page prices 184 ZIP codes, and GEICO’s statewide averages there are $150 for full coverage, $150 at 50/100/50 and $55 for Liability Only 20/40/10; the three-insurer full-coverage average is $223. A New Haven address costs more with every company:

Full-coverage monthly price by company, Connecticut and New Haven
Company Connecticut New Haven Difference
GEICO $150 $190 $40
Allstate $265 $325 $60
Progressive $253 $354 $101
All three $223 $290 $67

Cheap Car Insurance Connecticut Shoppers Find Statewide

The statewide order is GEICO ($150), Progressive ($253) and Allstate ($265). New Haven keeps GEICO first and swaps the other two. Regions, other cities and the cheapest ZIP codes are on the Connecticut page.

Cheap Auto Insurance Connecticut Headlines vs. a New Haven Address

A statewide price is a floor, not a promise for your street. GEICO’s New Haven ZIP codes run $177 to $194 a month for full coverage, against $150 statewide.

Car Insurance Quotes Connecticut Drivers Can Compare

From the state page or this one, quote GEICO, Allstate and Progressive at the same limits, 25/50/25 or more, and compare against the $223 state and $290 New Haven averages.

How We Priced New Haven Car Insurance

Quadrant Information Services is a rate-data vendor. For each insurer it takes the filed rating plan, enters one fixed driver and vehicle, and logs the premium returned. This page compares and averages those New Haven results, for rates in effect Sept. 30, 2026.

  • Our sample driver: a 40-year-old single man with strong credit, 24 years of licensed driving and a clean record (no tickets, no at-fault claims), who drives a 2024 Toyota Camry LE for personal use only.
  • The packages: Liability Only 20/40/10 covers harm to other people and nothing on your own car. The 50/100/50 tier adds collision and comprehensive with $500 deductibles. The top tier raises liability to 100/300/100 and keeps the $500 deductibles. Our request named no PIP amount and no medical-payments limit; Connecticut does not require PIP. We cannot tell how much of either is inside any price.
  • Small sample: 26 ZIP codes list New Haven as their USPS primary city and 4 of them have prices in our Connecticut data: 06511, 06513, 06515 and 06519. The other 22 are not priced, so each New Haven figure describes these 4 and says nothing about the 22. In Quadrant’s Connecticut data all 4 sit in the South Central planning region, a label Quadrant uses in place of a county. Three of the 4 have identical prices, which leaves the city with two distinct price sets.
  • The insurers: GEICO, Allstate and Progressive each returned a price in all 4 ZIP codes, so 12 ranked prices stand behind each level and none was set aside. Amica returned 12 quotes as well (4 ZIP codes by three packages), with the prior-insurance remark and the NotAcceptable status; they appear unranked and feed no average. No other insurer returned New Haven prices.
  • The averages: each company has one price per ZIP code, and its city figure is the plain mean of those 4. The city average then takes the mean of the three company figures, and the Connecticut numbers follow the same recipe across 184 ZIP codes. For monthly figures a yearly price is split into twelve and rounded to whole dollars; gaps between companies compare those rounded figures.
  • Who is named: the cheapest company at each level gets the name, and a company only a few dollars a month above it would be named too. No one came close here. A company must also have prices in at least half of the ZIP codes to be named; GEICO, Allstate and Progressive had them in all 4.
  • What we left out: Amica’s 12 New Haven quotes are the only prices held apart. They come back NotAcceptable with a prior-insurance condition our request does not show the driver meeting, so they are listed without a rank and counted in no average, ranking, cheapest-company statement, ZIP pick or chart. Nothing else was removed, and every priced ZIP code stayed in. Quadrant’s New Haven output includes no USAA, Auto Club (AAA) or other insurer that needs a membership.

Your own premium will turn on your vehicle, driving record, limits and discounts. The figures here are benchmarks, and none of them is a quote or an offer.

Rates as of Sept. 30, 2026

Quadrant Information Services (bundle 845) supplied these New Haven rates; this page was last refreshed . A figure here describes one modeled driver, so treat it as a sample price rather than a quote or offer.

More Connecticut car insurance prices

The Connecticut statewide average is $223 a month; see insurer and county prices on our Connecticut car insurance page.

Compare all 50 states: Cheap Car Insurance by State.

New Haven Car Insurance Questions Answered

Is $200 a month a lot for car insurance in New Haven?

Against the three-insurer average, no: $200 is $90 under the $290 full-coverage average in our New Haven ZIP codes, and $10 above GEICO’s $190. Across the 4 ZIP codes priced, the lowest full-coverage quote in each is under $200 a month. That marks the floor a careful shopper can reach, not a typical bill.

Who has the cheapest car insurance in New Haven right now?

GEICO, among the 3 insurers we compared, at every level we priced (rates as of Sept. 30, 2026). It averages $190 a month for full coverage, $185 for 50/100/50 and $73 for Liability Only 20/40/10, and it is lowest in all 4 ZIP codes at every level.

Who has the best car insurance in New Haven?

Our data measures price, not claims service or customer satisfaction, so it can say who charges least but not who is best. In New Haven that is GEICO at all three levels, $190 a month for full coverage, $185 for 50/100/50 and $73 for Liability Only 20/40/10, among the 3 insurers we compared. Collect quotes from GEICO, Allstate and Progressive at identical limits, then weigh service and claims handling yourself.

Is GEICO or Progressive cheaper in New Haven?

GEICO, at all three levels and in all 4 ZIP codes: $190 against $354 for full coverage, $185 against $325 at 50/100/50, and $73 against $155 for Liability Only 20/40/10. Allstate is the second-cheapest at each level ($325, $306 and $137), ahead of Progressive.

Why is car insurance so expensive in New Haven?

Our data shows how much, not why. The three-insurer full-coverage average is $290 a month, $67 above Connecticut’s $223. Inside the city, Allstate’s full-coverage price is $347 in three ZIP codes and $260 in 06513. Connecticut also requires 25/50/25 liability and 25/50 uninsured motorist coverage.

What is the minimum car insurance in Connecticut?

Connecticut’s rule is 25/50/25 on every policy: a $25,000 ceiling for any one person’s injuries, $50,000 for the crash overall and $25,000 for property damage, plus uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage of 25/50. Our Liability Only 20/40/10 package falls below that; 50/100/50 is above it.

How much is car insurance in New Haven, CT?

Full coverage averages $290 a month ($3,474 a year) across the three insurers in the 4 New Haven ZIP codes we priced. The 50/100/50 package averages $272 and Liability Only 20/40/10 averages $121. GEICO’s city figures are $190, $185 and $73.

Is 50/100/50 car insurance enough in New Haven?

We can only compare prices and limits. 50/100/50 sits above Connecticut’s 25/50/25 on every line, and GEICO prices it at $185 a month, $5 below its $190 full-coverage price. Whether it fits you depends on your car, assets and lender.

Is liability coverage full coverage?

No, the two are different things. Liability pays other people for harm you cause. Triple-I, the Insurance Information Institute, describes “full coverage” as everyday shorthand for liability paired with collision and comprehensive protection for the car you drive. For New Haven, GEICO’s Liability Only 20/40/10 costs $73 a month versus $190 for full coverage, and the three-insurer averages are $121 and $290.

Is Amica included in your New Haven comparison?

Amica is priced but not ranked. Every New Haven ZIP code has an Amica price, and Quadrant marks each one NotAcceptable with a prior-insurance condition that our request does not show the sample driver meets. That keeps Amica out of the averages and rankings. Its New Haven prices are $335 a month for full coverage, $334 for 50/100/50 and $119 for Liability Only 20/40/10; a driver with long coverage at high limits should ask Amica directly.

How does cheap car insurance CT-wide compare with New Haven?

GEICO is the cheapest of the 3 insurers we compared in both places: $150 a month for full coverage across Connecticut and $190 in New Haven. The three-insurer full-coverage average is $223 statewide against $290 in New Haven.

Which company gives the cheapest car insurance quotes in New Haven?

Start with GEICO: $190 a month for full coverage, $185 at 50/100/50 and $73 for Liability Only 20/40/10. Then quote Allstate ($325) and Progressive ($354) at the same limits. Ask for 25/50/25 or more, because the $73 tier is below Connecticut’s rule.

Are these prices for New Haven County insurance?

Shoppers do search for New Haven County, but our data does not use that name. Quadrant labels these 4 ZIP codes with the Connecticut region South Central Ct, and the prices cover only the 4 New Haven ZIP codes we priced, not a whole county or region.

What if I want affordable insurance New Haven County-wide?

Our data cannot price a whole county. For the 4 New Haven ZIP codes priced, GEICO is lowest at $190 a month for full coverage, against $150 for GEICO across Connecticut. The Connecticut page covers the state’s regions.