Cheap car insurance in Chicago, IL starts with Progressive: among the 4 insurers we compared, it charges the least for full coverage ($134 a month) and for 50/100/50 ($138). At Liability Only 20/40/15 it shares the name with GEICO, $69 against $70. Country Financial is next for full coverage at $201, then GEICO at $238 and Allstate at $422.
How much is car insurance in Chicago? Averaged across the four insurers, our sample driver pays $249 a month ($2,983 a year) for full coverage, $239 ($2,871) for 50/100/50 and $82 ($982) for Liability Only 20/40/15. That runs $49 above the Illinois full-coverage average of $200. Even so, a shopper can reach full coverage for less than $200 a month in all 52 Chicago ZIP codes we priced, and for less than $150 in 39. The wide gap is between companies: Allstate’s full-coverage average sits $288 a month above Progressive’s.
Scope: 84 ZIP codes carry Chicago as their USPS primary city; 52 of them are priced in our Illinois data, all in Cook County, and the other 32 have no quote in our data and are not described here. Page updated Nov. 2, 2026. Prices come from Quadrant Information Services and reflect rates on Sept. 30, 2026 for one modeled driver, so read them as benchmarks. How we priced Chicago
Cheap Car Insurance in Chicago, IL: Progressive Leads, GEICO Joins It at Liability Only
Lowest Chicago prices across four insurers
Full coverage: 100/300/100 limits, $500 deductibles
Progressive
$134/mo
$1,603 a year. Next: Country Financial, $201.
50/100/50 limits, $500 deductibles
Progressive
$138/mo
$1,658 a year. Next: Country Financial, $183.
Liability Only 20/40/15
Progressive and GEICO
$69 and $70/mo
$825 and $836 a year. Next: Country Financial, $76.
Below Illinois’ 25/50/20 requirement
Progressive stands alone at full coverage and 50/100/50: Country Financial, the next company, is $67 a month higher at full coverage and $45 at 50/100/50, nowhere near the few dollars that would bring in a second name. Progressive also posts the lowest full-coverage price in 52 of 52 ZIP codes.
Two names at Liability Only: Progressive and GEICO are $1 a month apart, inside the few-dollar band, so both are named. The ZIP codes split three ways: Progressive is lowest in 26, GEICO in 21 and Country Financial in 5.
Who was priced: Allstate, Country Financial, GEICO and Progressive, each in all 52 ZIP codes. State Farm is not in our Illinois data.
Chicago vs. Illinois: Progressive $134 Here, $113 Statewide
Every Chicago average runs above the Illinois figure. The Illinois column covers the same four insurers across the 475 ZIP codes behind our cheap car insurance in Illinois page, where the counties and the rest of the state are laid out.
| Coverage | Chicago | Illinois | Chicago is higher by |
|---|---|---|---|
| Full coverage | $249 [$2,983] | $200 [$2,394] | $49 |
| 50/100/50 | $239 [$2,871] | $193 [$2,321] | $46 |
| Liability Only 20/40/15 | $82 [$982] | $69 [$827] | $13 |
The gap is not the same for every company. Against its own statewide full-coverage price, Progressive costs $21 more a month in Chicago, Country Financial $28, GEICO $60 and Allstate $87.
| Company | Illinois | Chicago | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Progressive | $113 | $134 | $21 |
| Country Financial | $173 | $201 | $28 |
| GEICO | $178 | $238 | $60 |
| Allstate | $335 | $422 | $87 |
| All four | $200 | $249 | $49 |
Those uneven jumps reshape the margins beneath the leader. Country Financial undercuts GEICO at full coverage in both places ($173 against $178 statewide, $201 against $238 in Chicago), but its edge widens from $5 to $37 a month. Liability Only 20/40/15 shifts more: GEICO leads alone statewide at $57 (Country Financial $62, Progressive $63), while Chicago puts Progressive at $69 and GEICO at $70 together, with Country Financial at $76.
Illinois’ 25/50/20 Requirement and the 20/40/15 Tier We Priced
The $69 and $70 Liability Only prices do not buy a policy that meets Illinois’ requirement
Our bare-liability package uses 20/40/15 limits, while Illinois sets 25/50/20. A compliant policy needs higher limits and would be priced differently from $69 or $70. Ask for 25/50/20 or more on every Chicago quote.
Each of the three limits in that tier is below the requirement: bodily injury by $5,000 per person and $10,000 per crash, property damage by $5,000. The 50/100/50 and full-coverage packages are above all three.
| Limit | Tier we priced (20/40/15) | Illinois requirement (25/50/20) |
|---|---|---|
| Bodily injury, per person | $20,000 | $25,000 |
| Bodily injury, per crash | $40,000 | $50,000 |
| Property damage | $15,000 | $20,000 |
| Compared with the requirement | Below on all three | The baseline |
Where the requirement is published: the Illinois Department of Insurance’s auto insurance page.
Both bigger packages clear the requirement. At Progressive the order is unusual: 50/100/50 costs $138 a month in Chicago and full coverage $134. Liability Only 20/40/15 stays on this page to show what the thinnest package costs, and every mention carries its limits.
Chicago Car Insurance Quotes by Coverage Level: The Lowest Company at Each
Progressive owns two levels and shares the third. It is lowest for full coverage ($134) and 50/100/50 ($138); at Liability Only 20/40/15 it and GEICO sit at $69 and $70. Country Financial runs second at the two larger packages, $67 and $45 a month above Progressive, and third at Liability Only 20/40/15 with $76. Allstate is the most expensive company at every level, in every ZIP code priced.
Compare Chicago Car Insurance Quotes by ZIP Code
What Each Insurer Charges in Chicago
All four insurers returned prices for all 52 ZIP codes. Rows are ordered by full-coverage average, lowest first.
| Company | Full | 50/100/50 | Liability only |
|---|---|---|---|
| Progressive | $134 [$1,603] | $138 [$1,658] | $69 [$825] |
| Country Financial | $201 [$2,412] | $183 [$2,196] | $76 [$916] |
| GEICO | $238 [$2,854] | $235 [$2,815] | $70 [$836] |
| Allstate | $422 [$5,063] | $401 [$4,816] | $113 [$1,352] |
| City average, all four | $249 | $239 | $82 |
How far ahead Progressive is
ZIP code by ZIP code, the story holds. At full coverage Progressive is the lowest of the four in 52 of 52; its margin over the next-lowest company is smallest in 60644 ($23 a month) and largest in 60660 ($85). Its priciest Chicago ZIP code, 60621 at $182, is still under the cheapest Country Financial price anywhere in the city, $186. At 50/100/50 Progressive wins 49 ZIP codes outright and Country Financial wins 2; in 60621 the two match exactly. On the city average Progressive’s full coverage costs $4 a month under its 50/100/50, and the same is true in every one of the 52 ZIP codes.
Prices swing by ZIP code, but not equally
At full coverage Allstate ranges from $328 to $542 a month across the 52 ZIP codes, a $214 spread and the widest of the four. GEICO spans $139 ($177 to $316), Progressive $83 ($99 to $182) and Country Financial only $29 ($186 to $215). A Country Financial quote barely changes from one Chicago ZIP code to the next; an Allstate quote changes a great deal. Allstate is also the most expensive of the four in all 52 ZIP codes at all three levels, and its lowest full-coverage ZIP price ($328) is above the highest of GEICO ($316) and of Progressive ($182).
Car Insurance in Chicago by ZIP Code: All 52 We Priced
Averaging all four insurers, full coverage costs $201 a month in 60657 (Graceland) and 60614 (Lincoln Park), and $304 in 60624: a $103 gap that adds up to $1,236 over a year. The five lowest ZIP codes are 60657 (Graceland) $201, 60614 (Lincoln Park) $201, 60661 $205, 60601 $207, 60654 (Merchandise Mart) $211. The five highest are 60624 $304, 60644 $302, 60623 $300, 60621 (Englewood) $299, 60651 $298. For Liability Only 20/40/15 the four-insurer averages run from $74 to $89.
How many Chicago ZIP codes have a lowest price under $200?
Look at the lowest of the four companies in each ZIP code: 52 of 52 come in under $200 a month for full coverage and 39 under $150. The range runs from $99 in 60657 to $182 in 60621, or $1,191 to $2,178 a year, and Progressive supplies that lowest price in every ZIP code. It is the cheapest price a shopper could pick in a ZIP code among these four insurers, not a typical bill; the city average across all four is $249.
All 52 priced Chicago ZIP codes
Each row shows the ZIP code, Chicago and any other place names USPS lists for it. The first price column is the average of all four insurers for full coverage; the second is Progressive alone, the lowest price in every ZIP code.
| ZIP code and city | Full, all four | Full, Progressive |
|---|---|---|
| 60601 – Chicago | $207 | $120 |
| 60605 – Chicago | $218 | $117 |
| 60607 – Chicago | $229 | $116 |
| 60608 – Chicago, Pilsen | $240 | $125 |
| 60609 – Chicago, Stock Yards | $270 | $142 |
| 60610 – Chicago, Chestnut Street, Fort Dearborn | $212 | $109 |
| 60611 – Chicago, Fort Dearborn | $212 | $108 |
| 60612 – Chicago | $266 | $147 |
| 60613 – Chicago, Lakeview | $220 | $107 |
| 60614 – Chicago, Lincoln Park | $201 | $100 |
| 60615 – Chicago | $225 | $141 |
| 60616 – Chicago, Twenty Second Street | $238 | $132 |
| 60617 – Chicago | $278 | $155 |
| 60618 – Chicago | $221 | $114 |
| 60619 – Chicago, Grand Crossing | $281 | $172 |
| 60620 – Chicago | $289 | $172 |
| 60621 – Chicago, Englewood | $299 | $182 |
| 60622 – Chicago | $231 | $113 |
| 60623 – Chicago | $300 | $158 |
| 60624 – Chicago | $304 | $174 |
| 60625 – Chicago, Ravenswood | $233 | $117 |
| 60626 – Chicago, Rogers Park | $240 | $126 |
| 60628 – Chicago, Roseland | $288 | $164 |
| 60629 – Chicago, Chicago Lawn | $265 | $146 |
| 60630 – Chicago, Jefferson, Jefferson Park | $235 | $119 |
| 60631 – Chicago, Norwood Park | $229 | $114 |
| 60632 – Chicago, Elsdon | $251 | $138 |
| 60633 – Chicago, Burnham, Hegewisch | $272 | $148 |
| 60634 – Chicago | $240 | $126 |
| 60636 – Chicago, Ogden Park | $298 | $170 |
| 60637 – Chicago, Jackson Park | $285 | $169 |
| 60638 – Chicago, Bedford Park, Clearing, Forest View, Stickney | $234 | $126 |
| 60639 – Chicago, Cragin | $288 | $141 |
| 60640 – Chicago | $226 | $113 |
| 60641 – Chicago | $236 | $120 |
| 60642 – Chicago | $232 | $118 |
| 60643 – Chicago, Calumet Park, Morgan Park | $257 | $146 |
| 60644 – Chicago | $302 | $174 |
| 60645 – Chicago | $237 | $126 |
| 60646 – Chicago, Lincolnwood | $233 | $115 |
| 60647 – Chicago | $225 | $118 |
| 60649 – Chicago | $296 | $169 |
| 60651 – Chicago | $298 | $159 |
| 60652 – Chicago, Ashburn Park | $262 | $144 |
| 60653 – Chicago | $263 | $153 |
| 60654 – Chicago, Merchandise Mart | $211 | $106 |
| 60655 – Chicago, Merrionette Park | $236 | $118 |
| 60656 – Chicago, Harwood Heights, Norridge | $229 | $115 |
| 60657 – Chicago, Graceland | $201 | $99 |
| 60659 – Chicago | $243 | $128 |
| 60660 – Chicago, Rogers Park | $237 | $112 |
| 60661 – Chicago | $205 | $108 |
| All 52 ZIP codes | $249 | $134 |
USPS place names beside Chicago
29 of the 52 ZIP codes list at least one extra USPS place name next to Chicago, for instance Lincoln Park on 60614 and Rogers Park on 60626 and 60660. Labels tell you which addresses a ZIP code includes; they do not mark boundaries. All 52 ZIP codes are in Cook County in our data, so no county ranking appears.
See What Progressive and GEICO Charge at Your Chicago Address
From Liability Only to Full Coverage in Chicago: What Each Step Costs
The first step is where the money goes. On the city average, going from Liability Only 20/40/15 ($82) to 50/100/50 ($239) adds $157 a month, because 50/100/50 pairs higher liability limits with collision and comprehensive at $500 deductibles. Moving on to full coverage adds only $10.
By company, the first and second steps are $69 and then $4 less at Progressive, $107 then $18 at Country Financial, $165 then $3 at GEICO and $288 then $21 at Allstate. Progressive’s full-coverage price ($134) sits under its 50/100/50 price ($138), so ask for both.
Liability money goes to other people, never to your own car. The collision and comprehensive in both larger packages are what pay for your vehicle, and lenders and lessors often require them.
What Illinois Requires of Chicago Drivers
- Liability limits: 25/50/20 according to the Illinois Department of Insurance, meaning injury limits of $25,000 and $50,000 plus $20,000 for property damage.
- Left out of our prices: personal injury protection and medical-payments coverage. No package includes either, and adding one would raise a total.
Six Ways to Lower Your Chicago Car Insurance Bill
- Start with a Progressive quote. Its full-coverage price was the lowest of the four in all 52 ZIP codes, between $23 and $85 a month below the next company.
- Put GEICO next to it for Liability Only 20/40/15. On the city average the two are $1 a month apart, and GEICO has the lowest price in 21 ZIP codes at that level.
- Ask for 50/100/50 and full coverage together. Progressive’s full coverage is $4 a month below its 50/100/50; at Country Financial it is $18 above.
- Hold Allstate up against the field. Its full-coverage average is $288 a month more than Progressive’s, and it was the most expensive company in every ZIP code.
- Quote the ZIP code where you park. Four-insurer full-coverage averages run from $201 to $304 a month across the priced ZIP codes, and Allstate moves the most.
- Keep every quote at 25/50/20 or higher. A 20/40/15 offer will look cheapest and still fall under the Illinois requirement.
How to Line Up Chicago Quotes Fairly
Our sample driver is not you, so quotes only compare when the inputs match:
- Liability limits of 25/50/20 or more from every company.
- Identical deductibles on collision and comprehensive.
- Identical drivers, vehicles and annual mileage.
- The garaging ZIP code, because Chicago ZIP codes do not price alike.
- Annual cost alongside the monthly figure.
Start Your Chicago Car Insurance Quote
How We Priced Chicago Car Insurance
Quadrant Information Services is our rate source. Its software applies each insurer’s filed rating plan to a single fixed driver and car and logs the premium that results. We rank and average the Chicago results, which reflect rates in effect Sept. 30, 2026.
- The driver and car: male, single, age 40, good credit, licensed for 24 years, with no violations and no at-fault claims on his record. He insures a 2024 Toyota Camry LE that he owns and drives for personal use only.
- The three packages: Liability Only 20/40/15 covers harm to other people and pays nothing toward the Camry. The 50/100/50 package pairs 50/100 injury limits with $50,000 of property cover and adds collision and comprehensive at $500 deductibles. Full coverage moves the liability limits to 100/300/100 and keeps those deductibles. Neither personal injury protection nor medical payments cover is part of any package, so neither is in any price.
- Which ZIP codes: 84 ZIP codes list Chicago as the USPS primary city. 52 have prices in our Illinois data (all in Cook County) and 32 have none, so every Chicago figure speaks for the 52 and not for the 32. With one county there is no county table.
- Which insurers: All four, Allstate, Country Financial, GEICO and Progressive, produced a price in every one of the 52 ZIP codes, giving 208 prices per level, and we set none aside. If a ZIP code produced two prices from the same insurer for the same package, the lower one is used. The data provider attached no notes to these quotes, and no insurer was excluded. State Farm is not in our Illinois data.
- Averaging: every insurer gets one price per ZIP code, and its Chicago figure is the plain mean of those 52 prices. Averaging the four company figures gives the city average, and the Illinois comparison uses the same method across 475 ZIP codes. To get a monthly figure we divide the yearly price by 12 and round; a dollar gap is the difference between two of those rounded monthly figures.
- Naming a company: whoever has the lowest price at a level gets the name, and any company within a few dollars a month of it is named with it, as GEICO is with Progressive at Liability Only 20/40/15. A company must have quotes in at least half of the ZIP codes to qualify, and all four have them in all of them.
Your own premium will differ with your vehicle, record, limits and discounts, so treat every number here as a benchmark rather than an offer.
Chicago Car Insurance Questions Answered
Is $200 a month a lot for car insurance in Chicago?
Not against the average: $200 is $49 below Chicago’s $249 four-insurer full-coverage figure, though $66 above Progressive’s $134. In 52 of 52 priced ZIP codes the cheapest full-coverage quote is under $200 a month, and in 39 it is under $150. Those lowest prices mark the floor a shopper can reach in each ZIP code among these insurers, rather than what most drivers pay.
Who has the cheapest car insurance in Chicago right now?
Progressive, among the 4 insurers we compared, at full coverage ($134 a month) and at 50/100/50 ($138), for rates as of Sept. 30, 2026. At Liability Only 20/40/15, Progressive ($69) and GEICO ($70) are a dollar apart and share the name. Progressive posts the lowest full-coverage price in all 52 ZIP codes.
Is GEICO or Progressive cheaper in Chicago?
Progressive at full coverage and at 50/100/50: $134 against $238, and $138 against $235, each month. Liability Only 20/40/15 is a near match, $69 for Progressive and $70 for GEICO, and the ZIP codes split three ways: Progressive is lowest in 26, GEICO in 21, Country Financial in 5. At full coverage GEICO is not lowest in any ZIP code.
Why is car insurance so expensive in Chicago?
Our data can show how much, not why. Chicago’s four-insurer full-coverage average is $249 a month, $49 above Illinois’ $200, and the company matters most: Progressive averages $134, Allstate $422. ZIP code averages run from $201 to $304. Illinois also requires liability limits of 25/50/20.
What is the minimum car insurance in Illinois?
Illinois sets its liability floor at 25/50/20, according to the Illinois Department of Insurance: injury limits of $25,000 per person and $50,000 per crash, plus $20,000 for property damage. The 20/40/15 tier we priced is $5,000, $10,000 and $5,000 short, while the 50/100/50 and full-coverage packages clear all three limits.
Is 50/100/50 enough car insurance in Chicago?
This page only compares prices and limits. 50/100/50 is above Illinois’ 25/50/20 on all three lines and costs $138 a month at Progressive, $183 at Country Financial, $235 at GEICO and $401 at Allstate, against a Chicago average of $239. It also adds collision and comprehensive at $500 deductibles. Fit depends on your vehicle, assets and loan terms, and we make no recommendation.
How much is full coverage car insurance in Chicago?
Full coverage averages $249 a month ($2,983 a year) across the four insurers in Chicago, and Progressive is cheapest at $134 ($1,603). Country Financial is $201, GEICO $238 and Allstate $422. Here full coverage means 100/300/100 liability and $500 deductibles on collision and comprehensive; personal injury protection and medical payments cover are not priced in.
Is liability coverage full coverage?
No. Liability coverage handles what you owe other people after a crash you cause, their injuries and their property, and nothing for your own vehicle. People say “full coverage” to mean liability together with collision and comprehensive, the two parts that cover your own car. In Chicago the Liability Only 20/40/15 average is $82 a month against $249 for full coverage. The Insurance Information Institute breaks down what each coverage in an auto policy does.
Can insurers use my credit score to set car insurance prices in Illinois?
Yes, with limits. Illinois bars an insurer from refusing, cancelling or declining to renew a policy on credit alone, and from setting rates on credit alone. It also limits how a missing credit history is treated and requires reasons for adverse actions, and credit models are filed under 215 ILCS 157. Our prices assume good credit, so another credit profile can change your quote. Source: NAIC credit-scoring chart.
Which Chicago ZIP codes have the cheapest car insurance?
Looking at four-insurer full-coverage averages, 60657 (Graceland) and 60614 (Lincoln Park) are lowest at $201 a month, followed by 60661 ($205), 60601 ($207) and 60654 ($211). The highest are 60624 ($304), 60644 ($302) and 60623 ($300). Progressive is the lowest-priced company at full coverage in each of them.
Is Country Financial cheaper than GEICO in Chicago?
At full coverage and 50/100/50, yes: Country Financial averages $201 and $183 against GEICO’s $238 and $235. At Liability Only 20/40/15, GEICO is $6 lower, $70 against $76. Country Financial is also below GEICO at full coverage statewide, $173 against $178, but the gap is $5 a month statewide and $37 in Chicago.
How does Chicago car insurance compare with the Illinois average?
Every level costs more in Chicago. Full coverage averages $249 a month here and $200 across Illinois, 50/100/50 averages $239 against $193, and Liability Only 20/40/15 $82 against $69. Progressive is the lowest-priced company at full coverage in both places, $134 in Chicago and $113 statewide. The Illinois figures rest on 475 ZIP codes.
Why isn’t State Farm in your Chicago comparison?
State Farm did not return prices in our Illinois data, so it is not in this comparison, and we make no statement about why. The four insurers we compared, Progressive, Country Financial, GEICO and Allstate, each returned prices in all 52 Chicago ZIP codes, and none was set aside.
Do these prices cover every Chicago ZIP code?
No. 84 ZIP codes list Chicago as their USPS primary city and 52 have prices in our Illinois data, all in Cook County. The other 32 have no quote in our data, and nothing on this page describes them. Every Chicago figure here speaks for the 52 priced ZIP codes only.
