Cheap car insurance Wyoming drivers can find comes from two different insurers, and the order flips with the coverage level. Among the 5 insurers we compared, SAFECO has the lowest full-coverage average, $74 a month, and the lowest 50/100/50 average, $78. GEICO has the lowest Liability Only 25/50/20 average, $15. Wyoming cheap auto insurance is mostly a question of which coverage level you are pricing.
Two facts set Wyoming apart in our data. The company matters far more than the town: the 27 ZIP codes we priced run only from $156 to $168 a month for full coverage, a $12 spread, while the five insurers’ averages run from $74 at SAFECO to $249 at Allstate, $175 apart. And GEICO, the lowest on liability at $15, averages $220 for full coverage, fourth of the five.
How much is car insurance in Wyoming? Averaging all 5 insurers, our sample driver pays $161 a month ($1,936 a year) for full coverage, $162 ($1,940) for 50/100/50 and $30 ($365) for Liability Only 25/50/20. The Wyoming Department of Transportation lists 25/50/20 as the liability limits, so the liability-only package is priced at exactly those limits.
Next come insurer-by-insurer prices, county averages, every one of the 27 ZIP codes we priced, a closer look at Cheyenne, Casper, Gillette, Laramie and Jackson, and a comparison of our three packages with the Wyoming limits.
Page updated Nov. 19, 2026. Quadrant Information Services modeled every price below for a single made-up driver, using Wyoming rates dated Sept. 30, 2026. Read them as sample prices, never as quotes or offers of insurance. How we priced Wyoming car insurance
Wyoming Cheap Auto Insurance: Who Charges the Least at Each Level
The lowest Wyoming monthly average at each level, across the 5 insurers we compared
Full coverage, 100/300/100 limits and $500 deductibles
SAFECO
$74/mo
$893 a year. Next: Farmers, $124.
$50 below the next insurer
Liability Only 25/50/20
GEICO
$15/mo
$182 a year. Next: State Farm, $22.
Equals the limits on the Wyoming DOT FAQ
Mid-tier 50/100/50 with $500 deductibles
SAFECO
$78/mo
$938 a year. Next: Farmers, $120.
Lowest of the 5
Liability Only 25/50/20 equals the limits on the Wyoming DOT FAQ
The Wyoming Department of Transportation FAQ gives the minimum liability limits as $25,000 per injured person, $50,000 for all injured people in one crash and $20,000 for damage to other people’s property. Our Liability Only 25/50/20 package carries the identical numbers, so as the Wyoming Department of Transportation states them it works as state minimum liability (25/50/20).
Wyoming Car Insurance Rates: Who Leads at Each Coverage Level
Your car, record and address drive an insurer’s price, which means your quotes may not follow the order below. Statewide, SAFECO leads full coverage and 50/100/50 by a wide margin: it sits $50 a month under Farmers on full coverage and $42 under it at 50/100/50. GEICO leads liability, $7 under State Farm.
| Insurer | Liability Only 25/50/20 | 50/100/50 | Full coverage |
|---|---|---|---|
| SAFECO | 3rd, $23 | 1st, $78 | 1st, $74 |
| Farmers | 4th, $33 | 2nd, $120 | 2nd, $124 |
| State Farm | 2nd, $22 | 3rd, $136 | 3rd, $139 |
| GEICO | 1st, $15 | 4th, $219 | 4th, $220 |
| Allstate | 5th, $58 | 5th, $256 | 5th, $249 |
| Wyoming average | $30 | $162 | $161 |
Why the order flips between liability and full coverage
Read the table across a row. GEICO is first on liability at $15 and fourth on full coverage at $220, so adding collision, comprehensive and bigger injury limits costs a GEICO customer $205 a month. At SAFECO the same step is $51 a month, from $23 to $74, and at State Farm $117. SAFECO is far below the rest at full coverage and at 50/100/50, and GEICO is far below the rest at liability. We report the prices as Quadrant returned them and do not explain the gap.
Shopping for a policy that also protects your own car? Begin with SAFECO and add Farmers. Need only liability at the listed limits? Begin with GEICO. SAFECO’s liability price, $23, is just $1 above State Farm’s $22, so a quote from SAFECO can cover both needs.
Cheapest Wyoming Car Insurance at Each Level of Coverage
First: the limits the Wyoming DOT lists
| Coverage level | Cheapest insurer | WY price a month | WY average |
|---|---|---|---|
| Liability Only 25/50/20 | GEICO | $15 | $30 |
| 50/100/50, $500 deductibles | SAFECO | $78 | $162 |
| Full coverage 100/300/100 | SAFECO | $74 | $161 |
Liability Only 25/50/20
Cheapest: GEICO $15/mo ($182/yr)
Wyoming average: $30/mo. State Farm is next at $22, then SAFECO $23, Farmers $33 and Allstate $58. This package never pays for repairs to your car.
Second: higher limits
50/100/50 with $500 deductibles
Cheapest: SAFECO $78/mo ($938/yr)
Wyoming average: $162/mo. Farmers is next at $120. Collision and comprehensive join in, each with a $500 deductible.
Third: full protection
Full coverage, 100/300/100
Cheapest: SAFECO $74/mo ($893/yr)
Wyoming average: $161/mo. Farmers is next at $124, State Farm $139. Liability rises to 100/300/100 and the deductibles do not change.
The ZIP-level results are uniform. SAFECO has the lowest full-coverage price and the lowest 50/100/50 price in all 27 of our ZIP codes, and GEICO has the lowest Liability Only 25/50/20 price in all 27. Farmers, State Farm and Allstate lead in none.
Price Your Wyoming ZIP Code Now
Car Insurance Wyoming Drivers Compare: SAFECO, Farmers, State Farm, GEICO and Allstate
All 5 insurers returned a price in each of the 27 ZIP codes. Every bar shows one identical full-coverage policy at that company, so the shorter the bar, the cheaper the month. Insurers we did not price also sell in Wyoming, which makes this chart a sample of the market.
| Insurer | Liability Only 25/50/20 | 50/100/50 | Full coverage |
|---|---|---|---|
| SAFECO | $23 ($280) | $78 ($938) | $74 ($893) |
| Farmers | $33 ($400) | $120 ($1,438) | $124 ($1,486) |
| State Farm | $22 ($265) | $136 ($1,626) | $139 ($1,671) |
| GEICO | $15 ($182) | $219 ($2,624) | $220 ($2,642) |
| Allstate | $58 ($696) | $256 ($3,075) | $249 ($2,986) |
| Average of all 5 | $30 ($365) | $162 ($1,940) | $161 ($1,936) |
Allstate is the highest in every column. For the same full coverage it costs $175 a month more than SAFECO ($2,093 a year), and its liability price of $58 is $43 above GEICO’s. GEICO’s full-coverage $220 is $146 above SAFECO’s. Only SAFECO, Farmers and State Farm land under the $161 full-coverage mean, which GEICO and Allstate lift.
When 50/100/50 costs more than full coverage
Two insurers price the middle package above full coverage. SAFECO averages $78 a month for 50/100/50 and $74 for full coverage, and Allstate $256 against $249. Farmers, State Farm and GEICO go the other way, by $4, $3 and $1 a month. The state averages land $1 apart, $162 for 50/100/50 and $161 for full coverage. Every table shows the price as Quadrant returned it.
Average Cost of Car Insurance in Wyoming
The average cost of car insurance in Wyoming, taking the 5 insurers across 27 ZIP codes, is $161 a month for full coverage, $162 for 50/100/50 and $30 for Liability Only 25/50/20.
| Coverage level | Average price | Lowest-priced insurer | Highest-priced insurer |
|---|---|---|---|
| Liability Only 25/50/20 | $30 ($365) | GEICO, $15 | Allstate, $58 |
| 50/100/50, $500 deductibles | $162 ($1,940) | SAFECO, $78 | Allstate, $256 |
| Full coverage, 100/300/100 | $161 ($1,936) | SAFECO, $74 | Allstate, $249 |
| Sample | 27 ZIPs | 5 insurers | 135 prices |
Between companies the gaps are far wider than between places. Allstate’s full-coverage $249 is $175 a month over SAFECO’s $74, while our cheapest and priciest ZIP codes for the five-insurer average are only $12 a month apart ($144 a year). Within these data, switching insurers shifts the bill more than moving across the state does.
The lowest full-coverage price a shopper can find in each ZIP code
Those averages blend all 5 companies, yet a shopper who compares quotes ends up with the lowest. Take only the lowest full-coverage quote in each of the 27 ZIP codes and the range is $69 to $80 a month, with a typical ZIP code near $75. In all 27 of them that quote is under $150, and none reaches $300. Because each is the lowest price available in its ZIP among the compared insurers, these figures run below what a typical driver is billed.
Liability Only 25/50/20, 50/100/50 or Full Coverage in Wyoming?
The first step up is large and the second is not. Going from Liability Only 25/50/20 at $30 to 50/100/50 at $162 adds $132 a month ($1,575 a year), and two changes arrive together: injury and property-damage limits rise, and your own car gains collision and comprehensive protection, each with a $500 deductible. From 50/100/50 to full coverage at $161 the state average moves the other way by $1 a month, since SAFECO and Allstate price the middle package above full coverage.
| Insurer | First step: to 50/100/50 | Next: to full coverage | Total of the two |
|---|---|---|---|
| SAFECO | +$55 | −$4 | +$51 |
| Farmers | +$87 | +$4 | +$91 |
| State Farm | +$114 | +$3 | +$117 |
| GEICO | +$204 | +$1 | +$205 |
| Allstate | +$198 | −$7 | +$191 |
| Wyoming average | +$132 | −$1 | +$131 |
With the second step this small, ask for 50/100/50 and full-coverage prices in the same conversation. At SAFECO and Allstate the step is a minus $4 and $7, meaning 50/100/50 costs more, while Farmers, State Farm and GEICO charge $4, $3 and $1 more a month for full coverage.
Wyoming’s State Minimum Liability (25/50/20) Beside Our Packages
The Wyoming Department of Transportation’s FAQ lays out three minimum liability caps: $25,000 for each injured person, $50,000 across all injuries from one crash and $20,000 for property damage. Our cheapest package uses those very numbers. Wyoming’s limits here come from that FAQ alone, and we cite no statute.
| Coverage | Wyoming DOT FAQ lists | Our Liability Only 25/50/20 | Our 50/100/50 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Injury, one person | $25,000 | $25,000 | $50,000 |
| Injury, all people in one accident | $50,000 | $50,000 | $100,000 |
| Property damage | $20,000 | $20,000 | $50,000 |
| Versus the DOT limits | Reference | Equal | Higher |
Full coverage in our data, 100/300/100, sits above the listed limits on all three numbers.
- Each limit is a ceiling. If a claim against you exceeds it, the extra falls to you.
- Your own car is covered only under 50/100/50 and full coverage, which include collision and comprehensive at $500 deductibles. The Wyoming average climbs $132 a month between Liability Only 25/50/20 and 50/100/50.
- A lower total means little unless the limits match. Have every insurer quote identical limits first.
Our request named no PIP or medical-payments amount, so we cannot tell how much of either any price includes. Your own quote depends on whether you add either, so ask each company to price the same amount.
Law source: Wyoming Department of Transportation, Frequently Asked Questions.
Cheap Car Insurance by County and ZIP Code in Wyoming
Our 27 priced ZIP codes sit in 18 Wyoming counties, and most counties have only one or two of them. Only Laramie and Natrona have three, the threshold for ranking a county, and both rest on a small sample (marked †). They average the same $158 a month for full coverage after rounding, so we name neither cheapest nor priciest. Every other county is listed for reference, in alphabetical order, and is never ranked. A community in a county or town not listed has no figure on this page.
Wyoming counties, with the number of ZIP codes behind each figure
| County | ZIPs | Full coverage | Liability Only |
|---|---|---|---|
| Albany | 2 | $163 | $30 |
| Campbell | 2 | $164 | $32 |
| Carbon | 1 | $156 | $28 |
| Converse | 1 | $159 | $28 |
| Fremont | 2 | $163 | $29 |
| Goshen | 1 | $163 | $29 |
| Johnson | 1 | $163 | $28 |
| Laramie† | 3 | $158 | $34 |
| Lincoln | 1 | $164 | $29 |
| Natrona† | 3 | $158 | $35 |
| Park | 2 | $161 | $29 |
| Platte | 1 | $163 | $29 |
| Sheridan | 1 | $156 | $27 |
| Sweetwater | 2 | $162 | $31 |
| Teton | 1 | $167 | $31 |
| Uinta | 1 | $162 | $28 |
| Washakie | 1 | $163 | $28 |
| Weston | 1 | $168 | $29 |
| Wyoming, all ZIP codes | 27 | $161 | $30 |
A county figure is the mean of every insurer’s price across that county’s ZIP codes, so for a county with one ZIP code it is simply that ZIP code’s number. County averages for full coverage span $156 (Carbon and Sheridan, one ZIP code each) to $168 (Weston, one ZIP code), a spread of $12 a month. Because those are one-ZIP counties, we rank none of them.
Wyoming car insurance prices by ZIP code
Lowest ZIP, full coverage
$156/mo
82801, Sheridan
Highest ZIP, full coverage
$168/mo
82701, Newcastle
Gap between them
$12/mo
$144 a year
All 27 ZIP codes are listed, cheapest for full coverage first. Each figure averages the five insurers.
| ZIP and city | Full coverage | 50/100/50 | Liability Only |
|---|---|---|---|
| 82801 Sheridan (Sheridan) | $156 | $157 | $27 |
| 82301 Rawlins (Carbon) | $156 | $157 | $28 |
| 82604 Casper (Natrona) | $157 | $157 | $35 |
| 82609 Casper (Natrona) | $157 | $157 | $35 |
| 82007 Cheyenne (Laramie) | $158 | $158 | $33 |
| 82001 Cheyenne (Laramie) | $158 | $158 | $34 |
| 82009 Cheyenne (Laramie) | $158 | $158 | $34 |
| 82633 Douglas (Converse) | $159 | $160 | $28 |
| 82601 Casper (Natrona) | $159 | $159 | $35 |
| 82414 Cody (Park) | $161 | $162 | $29 |
| 82435 Powell (Park) | $161 | $162 | $29 |
| 82930 Evanston (Uinta) | $162 | $163 | $28 |
| 82935 Green River (Sweetwater) | $162 | $162 | $31 |
| 82501 Riverton (Fremont) | $162 | $163 | $28 |
| 82901 Rock Springs (Sweetwater) | $162 | $163 | $32 |
| 82070 Laramie (Albany) | $163 | $163 | $30 |
| 82072 Laramie (Albany) | $163 | $163 | $30 |
| 82201 Wheatland (Platte) | $163 | $163 | $29 |
| 82240 Torrington (Goshen) | $163 | $163 | $29 |
| 82718 Gillette (Campbell) | $163 | $163 | $32 |
| 82834 Buffalo (Johnson) | $163 | $164 | $28 |
| 82520 Lander (Fremont) | $163 | $164 | $29 |
| 82401 Worland (Washakie) | $163 | $164 | $28 |
| 83110 Afton (Lincoln) | $164 | $164 | $29 |
| 82716 Gillette (Campbell) | $166 | $166 | $32 |
| 83001 Jackson (Teton) | $167 | $167 | $31 |
| 82701 Newcastle (Weston) | $168 | $168 | $29 |
| Wyoming, all ZIP codes | $161 | $162 | $30 |
Full coverage runs from $156 in Sheridan (82801) to $168 in Newcastle (82701). Liability Only 25/50/20 shows a slightly different picture: Sheridan is lowest at $27, and the three Casper ZIP codes (82601, 82604 and 82609) are highest at $35, $8 above Sheridan. At 50/100/50 Sheridan is lowest at $157 and Newcastle highest at $168.
Wyoming Car Insurance by ZIP Code: Lowest Monthly Price Where You Live
Looking for your own corner of Wyoming? Both tables list all 27 ZIP codes we priced, and the search box filters them by ZIP code or place name. You get the lowest-priced company among the five we compared (none requires a membership) and its monthly price for one benchmark driver.
At full coverage, SAFECO has the lowest price in 27 ZIP codes. On Liability Only 25/50/20, GEICO has the lowest price in 27 ZIP codes.
| Measure | ZIP code | Per month | Per year |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cheapest WY ZIP code | 82801, Sheridan | $156 | $1,869 |
| Wyoming average, 27 ZIP codes | All Wyoming | $161 | $1,936 |
| Priciest WY ZIP code | 82701, Newcastle | $168 | $2,013 |
Both tables use the lowest price among the five Wyoming insurers for the same modeled driver and car in each ZIP code, from rates in effect Sept. 30, 2026; How We Priced Wyoming Car Insurance explains the driver and the three packages. All five insurers returned a price for all 27 ZIP codes, so none was left out. The request named no PIP or medical-payments amount, so a price may or may not carry some of either. Your own quote could differ a lot.
ZIP code lookup: full coverage
| ZIP code | Place | Cheapest insurer | Lowest monthly price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 82001 | Cheyenne | SAFECO | $73/mo |
| 82007 | Cheyenne | SAFECO | $73/mo |
| 82009 | Cheyenne | SAFECO | $73/mo |
| 82070 | Laramie | SAFECO | $75/mo |
| 82072 | Laramie | SAFECO | $75/mo |
| 82201 | Wheatland | SAFECO | $69/mo |
| 82240 | Torrington | SAFECO | $69/mo |
| 82301 | Rawlins | SAFECO | $69/mo |
| 82401 | Worland | SAFECO | $77/mo |
| 82414 | Cody | SAFECO | $73/mo |
Showing 1–10 of 27
Liability Only 25/50/20 by ZIP code
| ZIP code | Place | Cheapest insurer | Lowest monthly price |
|---|---|---|---|
| 82001 | Cheyenne | GEICO | $17/mo |
| 82007 | Cheyenne | GEICO | $17/mo |
| 82009 | Cheyenne | GEICO | $17/mo |
| 82070 | Laramie | GEICO | $15/mo |
| 82072 | Laramie | GEICO | $15/mo |
| 82201 | Wheatland | GEICO | $15/mo |
| 82240 | Torrington | GEICO | $15/mo |
| 82301 | Rawlins | GEICO | $14/mo |
| 82401 | Worland | GEICO | $15/mo |
| 82414 | Cody | GEICO | $15/mo |
Showing 1–10 of 27
Car Insurance Wyoming by City: Cheyenne, Casper, Gillette, Laramie and Jackson
The ZIP table shows how the main places compare. A city’s figure is the average of its ZIP codes in our data.
Cheyenne
Cheyenne has three ZIP codes in our data (82001, 82007 and 82009), all in Laramie County. Each averages $158 a month for full coverage ($1,891 to $1,894 a year) and $158 for 50/100/50. Liability Only 25/50/20 runs $33 in 82007 and $34 in the other two. That is $3 under the state full-coverage average of $161.
Casper
Casper has three ZIP codes, all in Natrona County. For full coverage 82604 and 82609 are among the four lowest in the state at $157, and 82601 is $159. For Liability Only 25/50/20 the same three are the highest we priced, each at $35. A Casper driver who wants liability alone pays $8 a month more than one in Sheridan, yet for full coverage the two lowest Casper ZIP codes are only $1 above Sheridan’s $156. Run quotes at both levels.
Gillette and Laramie
Gillette (Campbell County) has two ZIP codes: 82718 at $163 and 82716 at $166 for full coverage, and both at $32 for liability. The two Laramie ZIP codes (82070 and 82072, in Albany County) are level at $163 for full coverage and $30 for liability. The city of Laramie sits in Albany County in our data, while Laramie County holds the Cheyenne ZIP codes, and the county table keeps the two apart.
Jackson, Sheridan and Newcastle
Jackson (83001, Teton County) averages $167 for full coverage, the second highest of our 27 ZIP codes, with Newcastle (82701, Weston County) highest at $168. Sheridan (82801) is lowest for full coverage and for liability, at $156 and $27. Even the gap from Sheridan to Newcastle is only $12 a month, so a move inside Wyoming moves the price far less than a change of insurer.
Find Out What Your Wyoming Address Costs
Why Prices Run High or Low in Wyoming
The numbers above come from rate filings run through Quadrant, not from a study of causes. Treat these Wyoming facts as context for the WY prices rather than an explanation of them.
- Young drivers: the Wyoming Department of Transportation issues an intermediate (I2C) permit at 16, after the driver has held a learner’s permit for at least 10 days and passed a driving skills test. It carries 50 behind-the-wheel hours, 10 of them at night, and is held for at least six months or until age 17. Driving is allowed between 5 a.m. and 11 p.m., with no more than one passenger under 18 who is not an immediate family member unless a licensed driver 18 or older rides in the front seat. A hardship learner’s permit for ages 14 and 15 limits driving to 5 a.m. to 8 p.m. within 50 miles of home.
- Uninsured drivers: the Insurance Research Council’s 2025 study, published by Triple-I, puts Wyoming’s share of drivers with no insurance in 2023 at about 6.7 percent. That is a modeled figure built from uninsured-motorist claim ratios rather than a count of drivers.
- Your ZIP code: across our 27 Wyoming ZIP codes the full-coverage average starts at $156 a month (Sheridan, 82801) and tops out at $168 (Newcastle, 82701). That $12 monthly gap comes from our data alone.
| Fact | Number | Year | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Teen driver licensing rules | Intermediate (I2C) permit at 16 after 10 days on a learner’s permit, 50 supervised hrs (10 night), held 6 months or to age 17. Driving 5 a.m.-11 p.m.; max 1 non-family passenger under 18 (waived with a licensed front-seat passenger 18+). | Current | Wyoming Department of Transportation |
| Drivers without insurance | 6.7 percent (modeled) | 2023 | Insurance Research Council, published by Triple-I |
Sources: Wyoming Department of Transportation, Learner permits; Insurance Research Council, published by Triple-I, Facts and statistics: uninsured motorists. Checked 2026-11-19.
Six Ways to Find Cheap Auto Insurance in Wyoming
- Collect at least three quotes. Identical full coverage costs our driver $74 a month at SAFECO and $249 at Allstate, a $2,093 difference across a year.
- Price each coverage level on its own. SAFECO is lowest for full coverage and 50/100/50, GEICO for Liability Only 25/50/20. One insurer rarely leads all three.
- Quote Farmers and State Farm too. Farmers is next at $124 for full coverage and $120 for 50/100/50, and State Farm is next at $22 for liability.
- Request both mid-tier and full-coverage prices together. On average they differ by $1 a month, and at SAFECO and Allstate the middle package is the costlier one.
- Do not choose by town alone. Our 27 ZIP codes span only $12 a month for full coverage, while the insurers span $175.
- Match the limits. The lowest limits on the Wyoming DOT FAQ are 25/50/20, so ask every company for the same figures before comparing totals.
How to Compare Wyoming Car Insurance Quotes Limit for Limit
Every price above belongs to one modeled driver, so yours will move with the vehicle, any tickets or claims, the other people on the policy and the place the car is kept overnight. These habits keep Wyoming auto insurance quotes comparable:
- Give every company the same liability limits to price, 25/50/20 or higher.
- Pick one pair of collision and comprehensive deductibles and hold it fixed.
- Want personal injury protection or medical-payments coverage? Request the same amount everywhere, or leave it off every quote.
- Describe identical drivers and vehicles to each company.
Line Up Wyoming Quotes for Your Own Driver
How We Priced Wyoming Car Insurance
Quadrant Information Services applies each insurer’s filed rates and rules to one fixed driver profile and returns the premium. Our source is its Wyoming output dated Sept. 30, 2026; the comparing and averaging are ours.
- Driver and car: one 40-year-old single man who has held a license for 24 years, has strong credit and no accidents or tickets, and drives a 2024 Toyota Camry LE only for personal use.
- Three packages: Liability Only 25/50/20 has no collision or comprehensive and uses the 25/50/20 limits that the Wyoming Department of Transportation FAQ lists. The 50/100/50 package lifts injury limits to $50,000/$100,000, sets property damage at $50,000 and brings in collision and comprehensive with $500 deductibles. Full coverage keeps those two coverages and deductibles and moves liability to 100/300/100. The request behind each package named no PIP or medical-payments amount, so what any price carries of either is unknown to us. It did set the uninsured and underinsured motorist limits equal to each package’s bodily injury limits.
- Reach: 27 ZIP codes in 18 counties. All five insurers (SAFECO, Farmers, State Farm, GEICO and Allstate) returned a price in each ZIP code, which makes 135 prices at each level. Many Wyoming towns and counties are not among our ZIP codes.
- Averaging: where an insurer returns several rates for one ZIP code, only its lowest counts (none of the five did here). ZIP, county and state figures are plain means. A monthly price is the yearly premium divided by twelve and rounded to a whole dollar, and a monthly gap is one rounded price subtracted from another.
- Naming rule: an insurer can be named cheapest only if it takes any driver and priced at least half of Wyoming’s ZIP codes, and all 5 meet both tests. If a second insurer lands within a few dollars a month of the lowest, we name the two together. That never happened here, since each leader is far ahead: SAFECO $50 under Farmers on full coverage, SAFECO $42 under Farmers at 50/100/50 and GEICO $7 under State Farm on liability. A county with fewer than three ZIP codes is never ranked.
- Law source: the 25/50/20 limits come from the Wyoming Department of Transportation FAQ, and we cite no statute for them.
- Left out and kept: nothing was left out. Quadrant returned 405 priced quotes for Wyoming (5 insurers, 27 ZIP codes and 3 packages), all with its standard rate code 0 and no quote note, and each insurer returned exactly one price per ZIP code and package, so nothing was removed: no Wyoming quote carried a rejected required coverage, a program-only plan, a county the insurer does not write, an eligibility tier or a duplicate company row. The data holds no USAA, Auto Club (AAA) or CSAA quote for Wyoming, and none of the five insurers sells only to members of an organization. All 5 insurers and all 27 ZIP codes are in the rankings, averages and tables, and a market this small means every average rests on only five companies.
What you pay will turn on your vehicle, address, driving record, coverage choices and discounts. No figure here is a binding quote or a guaranteed price.
Rates in effect Sept. 30, 2026
Data from Quadrant Information Services (bundle 845), refreshed on the page . Treat each Wyoming figure as one modeled example, not a WY quote or offer.
Compare nearby states
Average monthly price for full coverage in nearby states, compared with the Wyoming average of $161 a month. Same Quadrant Information Services rates (as of Sept. 30, 2026).
- Idaho rates: $156 a month, $5 less than the Wyoming average
- Montana rates: $178 a month, $17 more than the Wyoming average
- South Dakota: $194 a month, $33 more than the Wyoming average
- Nebraska car insurance: $199 a month, $38 more than the Wyoming average
- Utah car insurance: $243 a month, $82 more than the Wyoming average
- Colorado: $269 a month, $108 more than the Wyoming average
See prices for every state: Cheap Car Insurance by State.
Wyoming Car Insurance FAQ: Prices, Averages and Limits
Is $200 a month too much for car insurance in Wyoming?
In our data, yes. $200 a month is $39 above the $161 full-coverage average of the 5 insurers we compared and $126 above SAFECO’s $74, the lowest; only GEICO ($220) and Allstate ($249) average above $200. In 27 of our 27 priced ZIP codes the cheapest full-coverage quote is under $200, and all 27 of those are under $150, ranging from $69 to $80 a month. That is the lowest price a shopper can find in each ZIP code among the compared insurers, not what the average driver pays.
Who has the cheapest car insurance in Wyoming right now?
Using rates in effect on Sept. 30, 2026, among the 5 insurers we compared, SAFECO has the lowest full-coverage average at $74 a month and the lowest 50/100/50 average at $78, while GEICO has the lowest Liability Only 25/50/20 average at $15. SAFECO is $50 below the next insurer, Farmers, on full coverage; GEICO is $7 below State Farm on liability. Your own driver, car and address may reorder the list.
Is SAFECO or GEICO cheaper in Wyoming?
The answer flips with the coverage level. SAFECO is cheaper for full coverage ($74 a month against GEICO’s $220) and for 50/100/50 ($78 against $219). GEICO is cheaper for Liability Only 25/50/20 ($15 against SAFECO’s $23). SAFECO has the lowest full-coverage and 50/100/50 price in all 27 of our ZIP codes, and GEICO has the lowest liability price in all 27. GEICO’s full-coverage average is $146 a month above SAFECO’s.
Why is car insurance so expensive in Wyoming?
Our data shows where the price differences sit, not why. The company you choose moves the price far more than the town: across the 5 insurers, full coverage runs from $74 at SAFECO to $249 at Allstate, $175 a month apart, while our 27 ZIP codes run only from $156 in Sheridan (82801) to $168 in Newcastle (82701), $12 apart. The all-insurer full-coverage average is $161, against $74 at the lowest-priced insurer. The Wyoming Department of Transportation lists 25/50/20 as the liability limits, and our Liability Only 25/50/20 average is $30 a month.
What is the minimum car insurance in Wyoming?
According to the Wyoming Department of Transportation’s FAQ, the minimum liability limits are $25,000 for injury to one person, $50,000 for injury to everyone in one accident and $20,000 for property damage, written 25/50/20. Our Liability Only 25/50/20 package is priced at exactly those limits: $15 a month at GEICO, the lowest, and $30 on average. Our 50/100/50 package raises the limits to $50,000/$100,000 for injury and $50,000 for property damage and adds collision and comprehensive; SAFECO has it at $78.
Is 50/100/50 enough car insurance in Wyoming?
Whether it is enough depends on your finances, and we cannot judge that. The numbers themselves are plain: 50/100/50 carries double the injury limits that the Wyoming Department of Transportation lists for 25/50/20, $50,000 for property damage against $20,000, plus collision and comprehensive with $500 deductibles. It averages $162 a month, against $30 for Liability Only 25/50/20 and $161 for full coverage. SAFECO has the lowest 50/100/50 price at $78.
How much is full coverage car insurance in Wyoming?
Full coverage in our data, 100/300/100 liability with collision and comprehensive at $500 deductibles, averages $161 a month ($1,936 a year) across the 5 insurers we compared. The insurers’ own averages run from $74 at SAFECO, the lowest, through Farmers ($124) and State Farm ($139) to GEICO ($220) and Allstate ($249). Our request named no PIP or medical-payments amount, so we cannot tell how much of either any price includes.
Is liability coverage full coverage?
No. Liability pays for harm you cause to other people and their property, and it never repairs your own car. “Full coverage” usually refers to liability combined with collision and comprehensive, the two coverages that do protect your car. In Wyoming our Liability Only 25/50/20 averages $30 a month ($365 a year), while full coverage averages $161 ($1,936). The Insurance Information Institute describes liability, collision and comprehensive as separate coverages.
How much is car insurance in Wyoming, and what is the average cost?
A modeled driver aged 40, with a clean record, pays $161 a month ($1,936 a year) for full coverage, $162 ($1,940) for 50/100/50 and $30 ($365) for Liability Only 25/50/20, averaging the 5 insurers at their Sept. 30, 2026 rates. An actual quote depends on the car, the record and the address. The county averages we have sit close together, from $156 in Sheridan County to $168 in Weston County for full coverage.
Which companies offer cheap auto insurance in Wyoming?
Among the 5 insurers we compared, SAFECO ($74 a month) and Farmers ($124) have the cheapest full-coverage averages, with State Farm ($139), GEICO ($220) and Allstate ($249) following. For Liability Only 25/50/20 the order changes: GEICO $15, State Farm $22, SAFECO $23, Farmers $33 and Allstate $58. At 50/100/50, SAFECO leads at $78. Get a quote from each, since your car and record can change the order.
Where is car insurance cheapest in Wyoming?
For full coverage, among the 27 Wyoming ZIP codes we priced, Sheridan (82801) is lowest at $156 a month, with Rawlins (82301) at the same $156 after rounding, and Newcastle (82701) is highest at $168, only $12 apart. For Liability Only 25/50/20, Sheridan is lowest at $27 and the three Casper ZIP codes are highest at $35. Laramie and Natrona are the only counties with three priced ZIP codes, and both average $158 for full coverage, so we name no cheapest county.
Is car insurance cheaper in Cheyenne or Casper?
The answer changes with coverage. On full coverage the two sit within a few dollars: the three Cheyenne ZIP codes average $158 a month, and the Casper ZIP codes run $157 to $159. For Liability Only 25/50/20 Cheyenne is cheaper, $33 to $34 against $35 in all three Casper ZIP codes. Each figure averages the 5 insurers.
What happens if you drive without insurance in Wyoming?
The Wyoming Department of Transportation FAQ lists no fine for driving without insurance, so we state none. It does say that after a crash with more than $1,000 in property damage or an injury to a person outside your household you must provide proof of current liability insurance, and that when coverage cannot be confirmed the law “requires suspension action” against your driving privileges, regardless of fault or residency. A suspension that takes effect also requires an SR22 filing and a $50 reinstatement fee, according to the same FAQ. Wyoming checks coverage through online verification: the Department of Transportation verification page says electronic proof of insurance is accepted, the program covers vehicles on personal-lines policies and commercial policies are exempt. For the current rules, read those pages or ask your insurer.
